ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsIndiana › Michigan City

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Michigan City, IN

Browse auto insurance agents serving Michigan City, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Michigan City, Indiana is Crowel Agency, Inc., rated 4.8 stars across 500 reviews. Other highly rated options include Freeway Insurance, Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Michigan City.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Michigan City, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Crowel Agency, Inc.348 Dunes Plaza(219) 874-3800
2Freeway Insurance5174 Franklin St(219) 841-8002
3Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent605 Franklin St Suite A(219) 874-6360
4Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent405 Johnson Rd(219) 879-2329
5Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent2103 Franklin St(219) 879-4408
6Douglas Bradley II - State Farm Insurance Agent301 US-20 Suite 8(219) 872-0554
7General Insurance Services421 Franklin St(219) 879-4581
8Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.1905 Franklin St(219) 879-4343
9Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance1812 US-20(219) 879-5357
10Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance450 St John Rd Ste 109(219) 878-1884
CA
348 Dunes Plaza
Crowel Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Crowel Agency, Inc. serves the Michigan City, Indiana, area for auto insurance agent services. The agency helps local drivers find policies that comply with Indiana’s compulsory liability coverage requirements. It also assists residents in comparing premium options and deductible levels from multiple insurers. A typical client meeting involves reviewing current coverage limits and identifying potential gaps based on driving habits or vehicle value. Common services handled here include quoting liability and collision policies and processing policy changes for mid-term adjustments.

FI
5174 Franklin St
Freeway Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Freeway Insurance in Michigan City, Indiana, helps drivers choose between a single policy purchase or an ongoing plan with renewal options. The agency focuses on providing auto coverage that meets local requirements and personal risk preferences. Residents can compare liability, collision, and comprehensive protection during consultations. This service runs on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to schedule appointments for new quotes or policy adjustments whenever required.

NJ
605 Franklin St Suite A
Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Michigan City, IN, provides auto insurance along with related coverage options such as liability, collision, and comprehensive policies. The office assists clients with tailoring coverage to their driving needs and offers regular policy reviews to maintain appropriate protection. Service plans include claims assistance and guidance on coverage adjustments. The agent works with homeowners, renters, and business owners, servicing single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

AM
405 Johnson Rd
Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners, renters, and drivers seeking personal coverage in Michigan City, Indiana. The agency provides standard auto insurance policies, including liability and comprehensive options, tailored to local driving conditions. It also assists customers with roadside assistance and policy bundling to simplify their coverage needs. Service is offered to individuals and families living throughout the immediate La Porte County area as well as those commuting from nearby Long Beach.

CP
2103 Franklin St
Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Michigan City, Indiana area and the surrounding communities. The agency handles auto insurance policies designed to protect drivers against financial loss from accidents, theft, and other covered incidents. It helps customers select appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options to meet their individual needs and local requirements. The company works with each client to review their driving situation and policy details, then recommends a suitable plan based on their specific circumstances.

DB
301 US-20 Suite 8
Douglas Bradley II - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Auto insurance policies may be purchased as a one-time term or structured with recurring payments to maintain continuous coverage. Coverage options in Michigan City, IN, are tailored to meet local driving conditions and legal requirements. As a local auto insurance agent, Douglas Bradley II - State Farm Insurance Agent assists clients in understanding these choices. Whether selecting a basic policy or a comprehensive plan, residents can expect guidance through the process. Services operate on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis, accommodating last-minute policy changes and planned annual reviews.

GI
421 Franklin St
General Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Winter's icy roads in Michigan City create higher accident risks for drivers, and General Insurance Services addresses these concerns by assessing local coverage needs. This auto insurance agent helps residents compare liability, collision, and comprehensive options suited to winter driving conditions. Their process involves reviewing a potential client's driving history and vehicle details during an initial consultation. After discussing available deductibles and state minimum requirements, they schedule a thorough policy inspection to evaluate current insurance gaps before proposing tailored adjustments.

SI
1905 Franklin St
Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc. specializes in helping drivers secure auto insurance policies that meet state requirements and protect against liability. It serves Michigan City, Indiana, car owners by comparing coverage options through multiple carriers. The agency assists with policy selection, accident claims support, and periodic coverage reviews. It particularly focuses on adjusting policies for winter weather conditions, helping drivers assess whether their deductibles are appropriate for snow-related incidents on local roads.

RP
1812 US-20
Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

As an auto insurance agent in Michigan City, Indiana, Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance provides specialized coverage options such as liability, collision, and comprehensive plans. The agency also handles routine policy reviews to ensure drivers maintain adequate protection for their vehicles. Seasonal concerns like winter driving hazards on local roads are addressed by helping clients adjust deductibles or add roadside assistance. Wind and hail claims common during Great Lakes summer storms are a specific concern the agent helps policyholders navigate annually.

MC
450 St John Rd Ste 109
Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

As winter turns to spring and potholes emerge on Michigan City roads, drivers may need coverage updates to protect their vehicle. Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance responds to such seasonal concerns by offering a range of personal auto insurance options. Their local agency serves Michigan City residents with standard policies and guidance on liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. To tailor a policy to a driver’s specific situation, the agent begins by reviewing the driver’s current coverage and vehicle details during a complimentary initial-assessment visit or phone consultation.

WA
106 S Woodland Ct Suite #3
Warren Attar - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 210-4293
warrenattar.com
MI
5385 Johnson Rd
Michiana Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 879-6482
michianainsurance.com
IF
5416 Johnson Rd
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0607
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
DI
124 S Woodland Ct # D
Dolson Insurance agency inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 879-4524
dolsoninsuranceagency.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Shula Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
BI
1551 S Woodland Ave
Best Insurance IN
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 232-6841
HI
516 Wabash St
Haddad Insurance Agency LLC.
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 259-5755
agents.farmers.com/in/michigan-city/joseph-haddad
AT
2004 US-20
Aaron Theophilus Agency Inc. American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 878-9727
amfam.com/agents/indiana/michigan-city/aaron-theophilus
HM
1703 1/2 Franklin St
Health Markets
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 291-4449
healthmarkets.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Matt Shula Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/offices/shula-agency

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Michigan City Cost?

The average cost of full coverage auto insurance in Indiana is around $1,500 to $2,000 per year, though rates in Michigan City may vary based on factors like driving record, vehicle type, and credit history. Minimum liability coverage typically costs less, often between $500 and $900 annually. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Michigan City

Auto insurance agents in Michigan City, Indiana help drivers find coverage that meets state legal requirements. Indiana law mandates minimum liability limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury. An agent can also explain local factors like lake effect weather risks that may affect your policy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Indiana?

Indiana law requires drivers to carry liability coverage of at least $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $25,000 per accident for property damage. Uninsured motorist coverage is also required at the same limits.

How do I choose an auto insurance agent in Michigan City?

Look for an agent licensed in Indiana who has experience with local driving conditions and coverage needs. You can verify an agents license through the Indiana Department of Insurance website.

Can an agent help me lower my auto insurance premium in Michigan City?

Yes, an agent can review your policy for available discounts such as safe driver discounts, multi-policy bundling, and anti-theft device credits. They can also help adjust deductibles to find a balance between cost and coverage.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.