ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsMissouri › Columbia

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Columbia, MO

Browse auto insurance agents serving Columbia, Missouri. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Columbia, Missouri is Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 232 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bry Reine Agency LLC American Family Insurance, Insurance Plus, Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Columbia.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Columbia, MOListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent2609 E Broadway Ste 214(573) 445-5774
2Bry Reine Agency LLC American Family Insurance2909 Falling Leaf Ln suite c(573) 442-3368
3Insurance Plus1604 Business Loop 70 W(573) 615-0291
4Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede3201 S Providence Rd Ste 203(573) 443-6080
5Acrisure Columbia, MO (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group)29 N 10th St(573) 449-5395
6Phyllis Nichols - State Farm Insurance Agent1006 West Blvd N Ste 102(573) 443-8727
7Lisa Cravens - State Farm Insurance Agent33 E Broadway Ste #175(573) 875-6696
8Shelter Insurance - Jeremy Hughes1715 W Worley St Ste A1(573) 445-8627
9Will Garrett - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance2415 Carter Ln #2(573) 514-8000
10Kasmann Insurance Agency116 N Garth Ave(573) 442-1105
SW
2609 E Broadway Ste 214
Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Columbia, Missouri metro area, specializing in auto insurance policies. The agency helps local drivers navigate coverage options to protect their vehicles and meet state requirements. Residents can secure liability, collision, and comprehensive plans tailored to individual needs and driving habits. The office also assists customers with bundling auto coverage with renters or homeowners insurance. For those in Columbia, the agency handles policy adjustments, new driver enrollments, and claims support for auto insurance.

BR
2909 Falling Leaf Ln suite c
Bry Reine Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Bry Reine Agency LLC American Family Insurance in Columbia, MO offers a full range of auto insurance coverages designed to meet drivers' needs. The agency helps clients select appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive policies, as well as optional protections like uninsured motorist coverage. Regular policy reviews are provided to ensure coverage stays aligned with changing circumstances. Claims assistance is available to guide clients through the reporting and repair process. In addition to auto policies, the agency services properties such as single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants using specialized insurance products.

IP
1604 Business Loop 70 W
Insurance Plus
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Insurance Plus serves Columbia, Missouri, and the surrounding communities, handling a full range of auto insurance policies for local drivers. It manages coverage for personal vehicles, including liability and comprehensive protection to meet state requirements. The company guides clients through selecting appropriate coverage levels and deductibles based on individual driving habits and vehicle needs. It provides policy reviews to ensure limits remain adequate as circumstances change. To handle a typical job, it works directly with clients to compare options and finalize paperwork for immediate proof of insurance.

SI
3201 S Providence Rd Ste 203
Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede, located in Columbia, MO, primarily handles ongoing auto insurance policies that renew periodically, unlike one-time service products that require a single purchase. As a local agent, Mitch Theede focuses on helping drivers secure adequate liability and collision coverage to meet both state requirements and individual financial protection needs. Service for existing policies largely operates on a scheduled basis, with annual renewals and periodic policy reviews offered as needed by the customer.

AC
29 N 10th St
Acrisure Columbia, MO (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group)
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

In Columbia, Missouri, Acrisure (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group) serves homeowners, renters, and local business owners with personal auto insurance policies. It also assists drivers with coverage options such as liability, collision, and comprehensive plans, helping customers meet state requirements. The agency aims to match each client with suitable protection for their vehicles. In addition to its Columbia location, the company covers clients throughout nearby Boone County and into the community of Ashland.

PN
1006 West Blvd N Ste 102
Phyllis Nichols - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

As the weather in Columbia shifts with each season, drivers from the University district to the Business Loop face changing road conditions and coverage needs. Phyllis Nichols operates a local State Farm Insurance agency focused on auto insurance protection for area motorists. The office assists clients with evaluating their current policies during life events like a new car purchase or a move across Boone County. After an initial phone consultation, a staff member schedules a brief inspection of the vehicle to confirm its current condition and mileage before finalizing any policy details.

LC
33 E Broadway Ste #175
Lisa Cravens - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

As an auto insurance agent in Columbia, MO, Lisa Cravens of State Farm helps clients secure the specific coverage they need, from liability and collision to comprehensive policies. In addition, the agency provides general services such as reviewing existing coverage, adjusting policies for life changes, and handling claims support. During the winter months, the office can advise drivers on how to evaluate their policies for potential weather-related losses, ensuring protection against hazards like ice and snow on local roads.

SI
1715 W Worley St Ste A1
Shelter Insurance - Jeremy Hughes
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Shelter Insurance - Jeremy Hughes provides auto insurance services to residents in Columbia, Missouri. Commercial auto coverage is also available for businesses in the local area requiring fleet or individual vehicle protection. As a local agent, Jeremy works with customers to understand their driving habits and coverage needs. After an initial policy is set, the agency offers follow-up support to adjust coverage. Clients are encouraged to return between regular visits for any questions about claims, policy changes, or new vehicles to ensure their protection remains current and appropriate.

WG
2415 Carter Ln #2
Will Garrett - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Will Garrett - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance provides auto insurance policies tailored to the needs of drivers in Columbia, MO. Beyond standard coverage, agents can assist clients with specialized add-ons such as roadside assistance and rental reimbursement to enhance their protection plans. The agency focuses on understanding local driving conditions to recommend appropriate liability and collision options. Its services also extend to commercial clients, helping to secure policies for offices, warehouses, and food service operations throughout the area.

KI
116 N Garth Ave
Kasmann Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
AO
1600 E Pointe Dr
Auto-Owners Insurance Missouri Regional Office
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 875-0289
auto-owners.com
LH
1900 Providence Rd Ste 203
Lloyd Henry Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 442-2800
lloydhenryjr.com
AC
1205 Grindstone Pkwy #117
AAA Columbia Insurance and Member Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 445-8426
ace.aaa.com/locations/Columbia-65201-148
SI
107 Hitt St
Shelter Insurance - Kelly Veach
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 443-1588
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/KELLYVEACH
CI
2102 Whitegate Dr
Columbia Insurance Group
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(800) 877-3579
colinsgrp.com
GI
401 Locust St Suite 301
Gallaher Insurance Group
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 777-9696
gallaherinsurance.com
NN
3928 S Providence Rd
Naught Naught Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 874-3102
assuredpartners.com/ColumbiaMO
HA
2100 Whitegate Dr
Harrison Agency Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 474-9537
harrisonagencyinc.com
PI
4210 Philips Farm Rd Ste 105
Progressive Insurance - Claims Office
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(800) 776-4737
progressive.com/claims
OI
29 N 10th St
Oerly Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 615-3211

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Columbia Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in Missouri is around 1500 dollars per year for full coverage but rates vary widely. Factors include your driving record age vehicle type and location within Columbia. Minimum liability coverage may cost as little as 400 to 600 dollars per year for some drivers. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Columbia

Auto insurance agents in Columbia Missouri help drivers find coverage that meets Missouri state requirements. Missouri law requires all drivers to carry liability insurance with minimum limits of 25000 dollars per person for bodily injury and 50000 dollars per accident. Local agents can also explain optional coverages like uninsured motorist protection and comprehensive plans for Columbia weather events.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Missouri?

Missouri requires liability coverage of 25000 dollars per person for bodily injury and 50000 dollars per accident. Property damage liability must be at least 25000 dollars. Uninsured motorist coverage is also required with the same limits.

How do I find a reputable auto insurance agent in Columbia?

You can search for agents through the Missouri Department of Insurance website or ask for referrals from local friends and family. Many national and regional insurance companies have offices in Columbia that offer in person consultations.

Can my auto insurance agent help with SR-22 requirements in Missouri?

Yes many Columbia agents can assist with SR-22 filings. An SR-22 is a certificate of financial responsibility required for drivers with certain violations like DUIs or repeated traffic offenses. Your agent can file this with the Missouri Department of Revenue.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Missouri Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.