ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Lake Geneva

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Lake Geneva, WI

Browse auto insurance agents serving Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin is Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance, rated 4.7 stars across 171 reviews. Other highly rated options include Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent, Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance, Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance. This directory lists 15 auto insurance agents serving Lake Geneva.

Showing 15 auto insurance agents in Lake Geneva, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance728 Wisconsin St(262) 248-0861
2Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent612 S Wells St STE H(262) 812-4139
3Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance803 S Wells St(262) 248-9502
4Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance772 W Main St Suite 105(262) 248-4239
5Interstate Insurance Group Inc100 W Main St(262) 248-6295
6Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Christopher Hanna836 W Main St #A(262) 729-4034
7Glass Insurance Center500 Commercial Ct #500(262) 248-5555
8Marlene Conroy - State Farm Insurance Agent7273 State Rd 50(262) 248-4771
9Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Robert Hanna836 W Main St(262) 729-4034
10John H MartinN3445 Como Rd Stop 4(262) 248-6000
TI
728 Wisconsin St
Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance serves the Lake Geneva, Wisconsin area as a local auto insurance agent. The company offers auto insurance policies designed to help protect drivers and their vehicles on the region’s roads. A general aspect of such work involves helping customers select appropriate coverage levels and navigate deductibles. It also assists with policy adjustments for seasonal driving conditions common in southeastern Wisconsin. In this area, the agency handles both personal auto insurance and additional coverage options like roadside assistance.

JI
612 S Wells St STE H
Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

As an auto insurance agent based in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, this agency provides a full range of personal and commercial auto coverage options. It offers standard liability and collision policies along with comprehensive plans to protect against theft and weather damage. The company also helps clients manage their existing policies and file claims. Service includes regular policy reviews to ensure adequate protection. This agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail shops, and restaurants throughout the local area.

SA
803 S Wells St
Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance in Lake Geneva serves local homeowners, businesses, and property managers by offering auto insurance policies tailored to the area’s driving and weather conditions. The agency helps clients compare coverage options to meet their specific needs. This office also extends its services to the surrounding communities of Walworth County, ensuring drivers in nearby towns have access to professional guidance and policy support.

RA
772 W Main St Suite 105
Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Serving Lake Geneva and the surrounding communities in Walworth County, Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance handles auto insurance policies for local drivers. The agency assists clients in selecting appropriate coverage options, including liability, collision, and comprehensive plans tailored to individual needs. By reviewing each customer’s driving history and vehicle type, the agent works to find a suitable balance of protection and affordability. This process typically begins with a consultation to assess requirements, followed by a comparison of policy options to meet the specific situation.

II
100 W Main St
Interstate Insurance Group Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Interstate Insurance Group Inc specializes in auto insurance coverage tailored to drivers in the Lake Geneva area. It assists clients with policies designed to protect vehicles against common road hazards and accidents. The company also provides guidance on selecting appropriate liability and collision plans for personal and family needs. Residents often turn to it for advice on adjusting coverage during Wisconsin's harsh winter months, ensuring their policies address the increased risks of icy roads and snow-related collisions common to the region.

RM
836 W Main St #A
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Christopher Hanna
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Drivers in Lake Geneva often need coverage that adapts to seasonal weather shifts and local traffic patterns. Christopher Hanna at Rural Mutual helps residents of this area secure auto insurance plans that address these regional concerns. The agent works directly with individuals and families to explain policy options, including liability and comprehensive protection. This straightforward guidance allows customers to make informed decisions about their coverage. A typical meeting begins with a review of the customer’s current driving needs and an assessment of their vehicle’s condition.

GI
500 Commercial Ct #500
Glass Insurance Center
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Glass Insurance Center works with Lake Geneva area drivers to review coverage needs and find suitable policies. The agency specializes in helping clients add important protections such as roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and comprehensive coverage beyond basic liability. Each policy is tailored to the individual situation. Understanding local driving conditions informs the advice provided. The agency serves a variety of commercial clients, including offices that require fleet coverage, warehouses needing liability protections, and food service establishments seeking general business insurance.

MC
7273 State Rd 50
Marlene Conroy - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

For auto insurance, clients may choose between one-time liability policies or recurring full-coverage plans that protect against a wider range of risks. Marlene Conroy - State Farm Insurance Agent in Lake Geneva, WI, offers such coverage options tailored for local drivers, including comprehensive and collision protection. Policies can also bundle roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement. Standard services are provided on a scheduled basis, with options for renewal each term.

RM
836 W Main St
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Robert Hanna
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance agent Robert Hanna provides residential auto insurance service to clients in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. Commercial coverage is also available for area business vehicles and fleets. The agency serves drivers throughout Walworth County and the surrounding region. Customers benefit from policy reviews and updates following life changes such as moving or adding a new vehicle. Personal appointments allow for thorough discussion of protection needs. Returning clients often receive reminders for renewal and coverage adjustments between regular visits.

JH
N3445 Como Rd Stop 4
John H Martin
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

John H Martin is an auto insurance agent in Lake Geneva, WI, known for helping local drivers find coverage that meets their needs. The agency offers a range of personal auto insurance policies, including liability, collision, and comprehensive plans. Services are tailored for area commuters, families, and occasional drivers on area roads. Assisting clients through the claims process is a standard part of the service. Additionally, the agency provides options for adding roadside assistance coverage to a policy.

SE
N 3219 County Rd H Unit C
Scott English - COUNTRY Financial Representative
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(847) 265-0799
advisors.countryfinancial.com/usa/il/crystal-lake/scott-english
RM
N3475 Springfield Rd
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Ashley Rogers
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(262) 203-5678
ruralmutual.com/agent/ashley-rogers
LG
647 W Main St
Lake Geneva Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(262) 374-5600
lakegenevainsurance.com
JI
493 W South St
Jones Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(815) 575-0401
CR
W3230 S Lake Shore Dr
Christopher Roberts Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(608) 774-3705
christopherrobertsinsuranceagency.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Lake Geneva Cost?

Typical annual auto insurance costs in Wisconsin range from $800 to $1,500 for minimum coverage, and $1,200 to $2,500 for full coverage. Lake Geneva rates may vary based on driving history, vehicle type, and location. Factors like winter weather and local accident statistics can influence premiums. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Lake Geneva

Auto insurance agents in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin help drivers find coverage that meets state requirements. Wisconsin law mandates minimum liability limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury. An agent can also explain optional coverages like uninsured motorist protection and comprehensive plans for lake area vehicles.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin requires liability coverage of at least $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $10,000 for property damage. Uninsured motorist coverage of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident is also mandatory.

Do I need an SR22 filing in Lake Geneva Wisconsin?

An SR22 is required for drivers with certain violations like DUI or driving without insurance. Your auto insurance agent can file the SR22 form with the Wisconsin DMV on your behalf. The filing typically costs a small fee plus higher premiums.

Can I bundle auto insurance with other policies in Lake Geneva?

Many agents in Lake Geneva offer bundling options for auto, home, and recreational vehicle insurance. Bundling often provides a discount on your total premium. Ask your agent about multi-policy savings available in Wisconsin.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.