ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Portage, WI

Browse auto insurance agents serving Portage, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Portage, Wisconsin is Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance, rated 4.8 stars across 86 reviews. Other highly rated options include Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance, TRICOR Insurance, Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance. This directory lists 13 auto insurance agents serving Portage.

Showing 13 auto insurance agents in Portage, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance1606 New Pinery Rd Ste B(608) 742-3888
2Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance214 W Cook St(608) 742-6548
3TRICOR Insurance236 W Cook St(608) 742-5548
4Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance131 W Cook St(608) 742-3999
5Sean Malone - State Farm Insurance Agent415 W Wisconsin St(608) 742-6754
6Miller Simonson Insurance118 W Collins St(608) 745-4665
7Okray Insurance Agency LLC2555 New Pinery Rd(608) 742-5560
8Evolution Agency2559 New Pinery Rd(608) 745-4680
9Armor Insurance Services LLC141 E Cook St(608) 745-9144
10Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Brad Damon201 DeWitt St #C1(608) 742-4444
RK
1606 New Pinery Rd Ste B
Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance serves Portage and surrounding Columbia County, offering auto insurance agency services. The agency helps drivers find coverage that meets local road requirements. It provides guidance on policy options, including liability and comprehensive protection. Drivers in the area can discuss their specific needs during an appointment. The agency also handles accident-related claims support and coverage adjustments for personal vehicles in this region.

SC
214 W Cook St
Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance provides a range of services including auto insurance policy options for local drivers in the Portage, WI area. The agency helps clients choose appropriate coverage levels and assists with policy maintenance, renewals, and making updates as driving needs change. For single-family homeowners, apartment dwellers, retail shop operators, and restaurant owners, the agency also offers bundled insurance options that combine auto coverage with their property protection needs.

TI
236 W Cook St
TRICOR Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

TRICOR Insurance provides residential auto insurance coverage for drivers in Portage, Wisconsin, helping protect personal vehicles with standard and optional policy features. The agency also offers commercial auto insurance policies tailored for local business fleets and work vehicles. Its service area extends throughout Portage and nearby communities within Columbia County. Agents work with clients to adjust coverage during policy renewals and after life changes, ensuring continued protection between regular annual policy reviews for ongoing driving needs.

SL
131 W Cook St
Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Located in Portage, Wisconsin, Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance serves the city and its surrounding communities with personalized auto insurance coverage. Policy offerings include liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protection tailored to local driving needs. The agency handles each client’s account by thoroughly reviewing their driving history and vehicle details before recommending appropriate coverage levels. This methodical process helps ensure each policy aligns with individual risk profiles regarding safety and regulatory requirements.

SM
415 W Wisconsin St
Sean Malone - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Residents, homeowners, and local business owners in Portage, WI, turn to Sean Malone for auto insurance coverage through State Farm. The agency helps clients with personal auto policies and related protection options, ensuring they have the necessary coverage for their vehicles. In addition to insurance solutions, the office provides customer support for claims and policy adjustments. The agent also assists drivers throughout the nearby communities of the greater Portage area.

MS
118 W Collins St
Miller Simonson Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Miller Simonson Insurance in Portage, WI distinguishes between one-time policy setup and recurring coverage reviews to address ongoing protection for local drivers. Their standard auto insurance agent work includes liability, collision, and comprehensive options that meet Wisconsin requirements. Claims assistance and policy adjustments are provided as part of the recurring service model. Coverage runs on a scheduled basis when a policy term ends, with as-needed service available for immediate questions or policy changes.

OI
2555 New Pinery Rd
Okray Insurance Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

As a full-service provider, Okray Insurance Agency LLC specializes in tailored auto insurance policies in Portage, WI, covering everything from liability to collision and comprehensive protection for personal vehicles. Beyond standard coverage, the agency also assists local motorists with navigating claims and adjusting policies to match evolving driving needs. Drivers in the Portage area often rely on Okray Insurance to review coverage and adjust deductibles before the snowy winter months when road conditions can lead to increased accident risks.

EA
2559 New Pinery Rd
Evolution Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

As winter storms approach, Portage drivers need auto coverage that responds to changing road conditions and local risks. Evolution Agency helps local motorists evaluate their policies before seasonal hazards peak. Understanding the varied commute patterns throughout Columbia County, this auto insurance agent can review personal and commercial coverage needs alike. Regular clients mention seeking clearer explanations of deductibles and liability protections before renewing. The initial process begins with a quick consultation and a thorough inspection of the current policy to pinpoint any coverage gaps.

AI
141 E Cook St
Armor Insurance Services LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Armor Insurance Services LLC serves residents of Portage, Wisconsin, with personal auto insurance coverage tailored to individual driving needs and vehicle protection requirements. Commercial auto policies are also available, extending coverage to businesses operating within the region. The agency provides attentive service for drivers across the local area, ensuring policyholders understand their options. Clients often return between regular visits to update coverage for life changes, such as a new vehicle purchase or a change in commute length, ensuring consistent follow-up care.

RM
201 DeWitt St #C1
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Brad Damon
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance through Brad Damon provides auto insurance policies designed to cover personal vehicles in the Portage area. Specialty add-ons may include rental reimbursement coverage and roadside assistance options for unexpected breakdowns. The agency helps clients manage liability protection requirements while explaining common deductible structures. Commercial operations such as offices, warehouses, and food service businesses can receive tailored insurance solutions for their company cars and delivery vans.

FI
2910 New Pinery Rd Ste A
Farmers Insurance - Gary Witt
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 745-1547
agents.farmers.com/wi/portage/gary-witt
CE
109 W Cook St
Cutting Edge Insurance Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 697-8282
cuttingedgeinsurancewi.com/contact
WA
2910 New Pinery Rd
Witt Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 745-1547
agents.farmers.com/wi/portage/gary-witt

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Portage Cost?

Average annual auto insurance costs in Wisconsin range from about 900 to 1400 dollars for standard coverage, though rates in Portage may vary based on driving record, vehicle type, and coverage levels. Factors like age and credit history also influence premiums. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Portage

Auto insurance agents in Portage, Wisconsin help drivers find coverage that meets state requirements. Wisconsin law mandates liability insurance with minimum limits of 25/50/10 for bodily injury and property damage. Local agents can also advise on additional options like uninsured motorist coverage and comprehensive plans.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin requires liability coverage of at least 25000 dollars per person for bodily injury, 50000 dollars per accident, and 10000 dollars for property damage. Drivers must also carry uninsured motorist coverage of 25000 per person and 50000 per accident.

How do I find a reliable auto insurance agent in Portage?

You can search for agents through the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance website to verify licenses. Local options include independent agents and representatives from national carriers who serve Columbia County.

Can my auto insurance agent help with SR-22 filings in Wisconsin?

Yes, many Portage agents can assist with SR-22 certificates required after certain driving violations. The agent files the form with the state to prove you carry the minimum liability insurance.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.