ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsArizona › Show Low

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Show Low, AZ

Browse health insurance agents serving Show Low, Arizona. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Show Low, Arizona is Trevor Tinkel - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.8 stars across 315 reviews. Other highly rated options include Farmers Insurance - Matthew Smith, Medicare Made Clear By Denny Shankland, PLLC, Goodman Insurance. This directory lists 14 health insurance agents serving Show Low.

Showing 14 health insurance agents in Show Low, AZListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Trevor Tinkel - State Farm Insurance Agent1881 E Deuce of Clubs(928) 537-5700
2Farmers Insurance - Matthew Smith940 E Deuce of Clubs(928) 537-0400
3Medicare Made Clear By Denny Shankland, PLLC640 S 20th Ave Ste. 2(928) 242-4522
4Goodman Insurance640 S 20th Ave(928) 532-0032
5Stickler Webb Insurance - Show Low, AZ600 S Clark Rd # A(928) 537-2928
6Brown & Russo Insurance50 S White Mountain Rd(928) 537-2135
7MedCare3605198 Cub Lake Rd Ste. A(928) 368-3297
8Wahl Insurance3051 S White Mountain Rd(928) 240-3281
9Melissa Covington American Family Insurance141 N 6th St(928) 532-1678
10Senior Select Advisors3051 S White Mountain Rd # D(928) 532-6698
TT
1881 E Deuce of Clubs
Trevor Tinkel - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Trevor Tinkel - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Show Low, Arizona area and provides health insurance agent services. This agent helps individuals and families in the region understand their health coverage options through the marketplace. They assist clients with enrolling in plans that fit medical needs and budgets. Customers can also receive help comparing plan benefits and navigating policy renewals. In this area, the office handles individual health insurance plans and short-term health coverage.

FI
940 E Deuce of Clubs
Farmers Insurance - Matthew Smith
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Farmers Insurance - Matthew Smith provides a range of health insurance agent services, including helping clients select and maintain individual health plans and Medicare supplements. It also assists with plan renewals and policy adjustments to accommodate changing medical needs. The agent serves the Show Low, Arizona, area, offering consultation and annual plan reviews. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail, and restaurants.

MM
640 S 20th Ave Ste. 2
Medicare Made Clear By Denny Shankland, PLLC
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Medicare Made Clear By Denny Shankland, PLLC serves local residents in the Show Low area who are exploring their health insurance options, particularly those approaching or currently enrolled in Medicare. The agency guides clients through plan comparisons and enrollment processes, helping them select suitable coverage for their individual needs. By focusing on personalized consultations, the company aims to simplify health insurance decisions for its customers. Its services also extend to individuals and families in neighboring Pinetop-Lakeside.

GI
640 S 20th Ave
Goodman Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Serving Show Low and the surrounding White Mountain communities, Goodman Insurance handles health insurance plans for individuals and families. The agency provides guidance through the complexities of the annual enrollment period and special enrollment qualifying events. For those with changing needs, it reviews plan options including HMO, PPO, and dental coverage to find appropriate solutions. It begins each client relationship by conducting a thorough needs assessment to identify specific health priorities and budget constraints.

SW
600 S Clark Rd # A
Stickler Webb Insurance - Show Low, AZ
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Stickler Webb Insurance in Show Low, AZ, distinguishes between one-time plan enrollments during open enrollment periods and ongoing service options, such as annual policy reviews or mid-year adjustments. As a health insurance agent, the company helps clients navigate coverage plans that fit medical needs and budgets in the region. Help includes applying for subsidies or understanding out-of-pocket costs. Service is available on both a scheduled and as-needed basis for consultations, claims support, or plan changes.

BR
50 S White Mountain Rd
Brown & Russo Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Brown & Russo Insurance provides health insurance agent services in Show Low, Arizona, offering guidance on individual and family plans, as well as Medicare and supplemental policies. It assists clients in navigating enrollment processes, coverage options, and plan comparisons to suit varying medical needs and budgets. During the annual open enrollment period or if a qualifying life event occurs, the agency helps residents evaluate marketplace options and adjust their health coverage accordingly.

ME
5198 Cub Lake Rd Ste. A
MedCare360
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Winter in Show Low brings unpredictable weather and rising heating costs, making reliable health coverage essential. MedCare360 assists local residents by explaining plan options for doctor visits and unexpected illnesses or injuries. Located within the community, this health insurance agent provides straightforward guidance on enrolling in individual or family policies. Clients receive clear comparisons of deductibles and monthly premiums during a personalized consultation. Every appointment includes a thorough review of the person’s current medications and preferred healthcare providers, followed by an initial coverage assessment.

WI
3051 S White Mountain Rd
Wahl Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Wahl Insurance provides health insurance coverage for residents in the Show Low, Arizona area. The agency also assists businesses with group commercial health plans, helping employers find suitable options for their staff. Clients can review available individual and family plans, as well as Medicare supplement policies. Representatives focus on explaining plan details plainly so customers understand their choices. After enrolling, clients receive guidance on using their new benefits. The agent remains available for follow-up questions and plan adjustments between regular annual visits.

MC
141 N 6th St
Melissa Covington American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Melissa Covington American Family Insurance in Show Low, AZ, provides general health insurance agent services, helping individuals and families navigate plan selection and enrollment. The agency specializes in matching clients with health coverage options that fit personal needs and budget considerations. Its work involves explaining policy details, comparing available plans from various carriers, and guiding customers through the application process. This office can assist commercial clients such as offices, warehouses, and food service establishments with their health insurance needs.

SS
3051 S White Mountain Rd # D
Senior Select Advisors
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ

Senior Select Advisors in Show Low, AZ, is recognized for guiding individuals through the complexities of health insurance plans and coverage options. The firm assists local residents with enrollment services and plan comparisons, tailoring its support to the needs of the community. Its agents focus on explaining policy details clearly, helping clients make informed choices during open enrollment periods. The agency can further add on Medicare supplement plan guidance for those seeking additional coverage beyond original benefits.

LP
810 E Deuce of Clubs
Lyle Power
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ
(928) 537-2990
fbfs.com/find-an-agent/alylepower
FB
810 E Deuce of Clubs
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ
(928) 537-2990
fbfs.com/find-an-agent/Search
AC
1052 E Deuce of Clubs B2
A1 Choice Insurance Agency Associates
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ
(928) 537-7767
MV
49 W Deuce of Clubs
Mountain Valley Insurance Limited
Health Insurance Agent · Show Low, AZ
(928) 537-4235

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Show Low Cost?

Health insurance agents in Arizona typically do not charge a direct fee to clients for plan enrollment. Their compensation comes from commissions paid by insurance carriers, which can range from 2% to 10% of the annual premium depending on the plan type. For private plans, administrative fees may apply in some cases. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Show Low

Health insurance agents in Show Low, Arizona help individuals and families find coverage through the federal marketplace, Medicare, or private insurers. Arizona law requires agents to be licensed by the Arizona Department of Insurance and to follow state regulations on plan disclosures. Working with a local agent can simplify enrollment and help you understand network options available in Navajo County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a health insurance agent in Show Low do?

A health insurance agent helps you compare plans from different carriers, explains coverage details, and assists with enrollment. They can also help you apply for subsidies through the Affordable Care Act marketplace if you qualify.

Do I need to pay a fee to use a health insurance agent in Arizona?

In most cases, health insurance agents in Arizona are paid by the insurance company, not by you. Their commission is built into the plan premium. Always confirm fee arrangements before working with an agent.

What documents do I need to enroll with an agent in Show Low?

You will need identification, Social Security numbers for all household members, income information, and current health coverage details if applicable. For Medicare plans, bring your Medicare card and a list of current prescriptions.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Arizona Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.