ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsIndiana › Indianapolis

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Indianapolis, IN

Browse health insurance agents serving Indianapolis, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Indianapolis, Indiana is Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group, rated 5.0 stars across 1,155 reviews. Other highly rated options include Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent, Easy Street Insurance, Steffey Insurance Agency. This directory lists 48 health insurance agents serving Indianapolis.

Showing 48 health insurance agents in Indianapolis, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group7212 Shadeland Ave # 201(317) 350-1598
2Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent4010 E Southport Rd(317) 783-1367
3Easy Street Insurance8000 S Meridian St(317) 882-9602
4Steffey Insurance Agency3091 E 98th St SUITE 125(317) 334-3743
5Wenclewicz Insurance7202 Shadeland Ave # 207(317) 288-5099
6Breneman Insurance Group5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A(317) 786-2200
7Access Auto Insurance8249 Pendleton Pike(317) 890-4900
8Acceptance Insurance4850 S Emerson Ave Ste C(317) 597-7000
9Conner Insurance8445 Keystone Crossing #200
10HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117(317) 418-8271
SW
7212 Shadeland Ave # 201
Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group in Indianapolis, IN provides a range of health insurance agent services, including plan comparisons, enrollment assistance, and policy management. Its service approach involves annual plan reviews to adjust coverage as needs change and ongoing support for claims questions. Maintenance plans involve regular check-ins to ensure clients remain compliant with changing regulations. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants, helping both individuals and small business owners secure appropriate health coverage for their specific situations.

SO
4010 E Southport Rd
Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent in Indianapolis, Indiana, distinguishes between one-time health insurance plans and recurring policies that offer ongoing coverage. The agency assists clients in selecting individual healthcare plans or family coverage tailored to medical needs and budget. As a local provider, it offers guidance on plan benefits, deductible options, and network providers available in the area. Service arrangements for these health insurance solutions are available on a scheduled or as-needed basis.

ES
8000 S Meridian St
Easy Street Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Easy Street Insurance serves Indianapolis residents seeking health coverage for their households, including individual plans and family policies. The agency also assists local businesses with commercial health insurance options tailored to their workforce. Their service area covers Indianapolis and the surrounding communities. Clients receive guidance during enrollment periods and claims support as needed. The team maintains ongoing relationships by checking in through phone and email between scheduled appointments, ensuring continuity in coverage adjustments and renewals as circumstances change.

SI
3091 E 98th St SUITE 125
Steffey Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Steffey Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, Indiana, helps clients understand the difference between short-term health plans and ongoing, comprehensive coverage suited for long-term needs. As a health insurance agent, the company assists individuals and families with plan comparisons and enrollment. Services include explaining policy options, managing annual renewals, and answering questions about deductibles and networks. These services are available on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis depending on the client's specific situation.

WI
7202 Shadeland Ave # 207
Wenclewicz Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Wenclewicz Insurance is a health insurance agent located in Indianapolis, Indiana, known for helping individuals and families compare major medical plans in the local marketplace. The company guides clients through open enrollment, explaining coverage options for routine care and prescription drugs in straightforward terms. It also assists small business owners in finding group health benefits that fit their budget and workforce needs. As an added specialty, the agency can help clients explore supplemental dental and vision coverage to strengthen their overall health protection.

BI
5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A
Breneman Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Breneman Insurance Group specializes in connecting individuals and families with suitable health insurance plans, including individual and group coverage. As a Health Insurance Agent based in Indianapolis, Indiana, the company provides guidance through the enrollment process and helps clients understand policy options and network benefits. It assists with plan comparisons for those seeking coverage inside or outside the public marketplace. For residents of Indianapolis, the agent particularly helps address coverage needs during the open enrollment period and when qualifying life events occur.

AA
8249 Pendleton Pike
Access Auto Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As temperatures fluctuate throughout the year in Indianapolis, families often review their coverage needs for unexpected medical events. Access Auto Insurance assists local clients in the health insurance agent category by explaining plan options that suit individual budgets and medical circumstances. Their approach focuses on clarifying policy terms and available subsidies during open enrollment periods. New customers typically begin with a brief needs assessment to identify suitable coverage choices before reviewing specific plan details.

AI
4850 S Emerson Ave Ste C
Acceptance Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Acceptance Insurance, based in Indianapolis, Indiana, works to help individuals and groups navigate their private health coverage needs, often supplementing policies with dental and vision plan options. As a licensed agency, its professionals assist clients by explaining plan benefits, network restrictions, and enrollment periods. The company serves various local commercial sectors, including office spaces, warehouses, and food service establishments.

CI
8445 Keystone Crossing #200
Conner Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
HI
3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117
HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period brings many Indianapolis residents to review their coverage, HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky assists clients in navigating plan options. This Health Insurance Agent focuses on matching individuals and families with suitable health plans from available carriers in the area. Services include explaining the differences between Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and prescription drug plans. The initial step for any interested party is to schedule a free consultation and plan comparison review, allowing for a thorough assessment of specific healthcare needs.

MI
345 Massachusetts Ave # 250
McGowan Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 464-5000
mcgowaninsgrp.com
CI
70 91st St #200
Central Insurance Associates
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 846-4622
centralinsuranceassoc.com
PH
9765 Randall Dr
Premier Health Advisors
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 819-0140
mypremierhealthadvisors.com
MM
6329 Hollister Dr
McClain Matthews Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 298-7500
mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com
NI
8435 Keystone Crossing #160
Nefouse Indiana Group Health Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 846-8615
nefousehealthinsurance.com
SH
4725 S Arlington Ave
Stacey Hamilton - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 780-0088
staceyhamilton.net
WI
6510 Shadeland Ave
WalkerHughes Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 353-8000
walkerhughes.com/locations/indianapolis
II
2818 N High School Rd
IAL Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 480-4111
ialinsurance.com
HI
1232 W 86th St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Michael Wehner
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(614) 270-9921
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mwehner
JI
5700 N College Ave
Jeremiah Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 506-2717
jeremiahinsuranceinc.com
HI
450 E 96th St #500
Hoosier Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 536-2999
hoosierinsurancegroup.com
CA
1016 Country Club Rd
Carson Agency, Inc
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 271-3393
carsonagency.com
IB
5645 N Post Rd # C
Insurance By George
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 544-5207
insurancebygeorge.com
AS
3500 Depauw Blvd Suite 1054
Andrew Sandlin - HealthMarkets Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(574) 536-3947
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/asandlin
MH
2421 Production Dr Ste 203
Merritt Hall Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 247-7737
merritthallins.com
JC
9165 Otis Ave #225
Jay Cox, CRFA - Your Medicare Advocate
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 559-2140
personalbenefitsservice.com
JR
6128 W 25th St
Jeff A. Rieser Agency, Inc American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 280-0449
amfam.com/agents/indiana/indianapolis/jeffery-rieser
VI
5004 W 16th St
VP Insurance Agency, LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 248-0070
vpinsuranceagency.com
HI
5730 N College Ave
HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Geighes
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 413-3280
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/cgeighes
AI
920 Shadeland Ave Suite G-2A
Alleviate Insurance and Retirement Services
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(463) 328-3634
alleviateinsurance.com
FI
10598 N College Ave
Fit Insurance Ltd.
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 978-2956
camilleclinard3198.wixsite.com/fit-insurance-ltd
CI
4920 W 16th St
Cork Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 241-4899
AI
3115 S Keystone Ave
Anchor Insurance Services LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 559-3347
myanchorins.com
JR
4007 N High School Rd
Juan R Diaz Ins Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 295-9150
amfam.com/agents/indiana/indianapolis/Juan-Ruiz-Diaz
HI
1232 W 86th St
HealthMarkets Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 287-3300
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/indianapolis
BA
5236 Elmwood Ave
Barrett & Associates Inc
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 783-9397
insurewithbarrett.com/about-us
SI
2323 E 58th St
Strategic Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 590-0943
stratins.com
GI
5845 Sunnyside Rd Suite 800
Golden Insurance and DOT Services
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 536-5499
thedavisinsuranceagency.com
PA
5905 S Emerson Ave #400
Protect All Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 353-1121
UG
7440 Woodland Dr
UnitedHealthcare - Golden Rule Insurance Company
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 273-8115
uhone.com
RO
5322 W 16th St
Robert A O'Neal Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 243-3557
onealagency.com
JC
2915 N High School Rd
J C Smith Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 244-2707
jcsmithinsurance.com
II
9165 Otis Ave #238
IAmerica Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 250-7184
iamericainsurance.com
EG
5460 Victory Dr #100
Emerald Group Indy, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 353-3071
emeraldindy.com/contact-us
MI
2915 N High School Rd #106
Mateo Insurance Agency LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 332-8082
mateoinsurance.com
MI
5730 W 74th St
Midwest Insurance Marketers of America, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 328-0800
mwima.com
IH
5868 E 71st St Suite E-593
Indy Health Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 296-8881
indyhealthagent.com/indiana-health-insurance
MH
5120 Waybridge Ln
Medicare Health Plans Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 679-8935
medicarehealthplansagent.com

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Indianapolis Cost?

The cost of using a health insurance agent in Indianapolis is usually zero because they earn a commission from the insurance carrier. For individual ACA plans premiums in Indiana range from about 300 to 700 per month for a single adult depending on age income and plan tier. Medicare Supplement plans in Indiana typically cost between 100 and 300 per month. Costs vary by case and by the specific plan you choose. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Indianapolis

Health insurance agents in Indianapolis help individuals families and small businesses find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Indiana law requires all agents to be licensed by the Indiana Department of Insurance. Local agents understand the specific plans available in Marion County and can guide you through open enrollment or special enrollment periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the open enrollment period for health insurance in Indiana?

The federal open enrollment period for ACA plans typically runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. Indiana does not have a separate state exchange so residents use the federal marketplace at HealthCare.gov. Outside this window you may qualify for a special enrollment period due to life events like marriage or job loss.

Do health insurance agents in Indianapolis charge a fee for their services?

Most health insurance agents are paid by the insurance companies through commissions so you do not pay an extra fee directly. Some agents may charge a consultation fee for complex cases but this must be disclosed upfront. Always ask about any fees before you sign an agreement.

Can a health insurance agent help me with Medicare plans in Indianapolis?

Yes many agents in Indianapolis are licensed to sell Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. Indiana has many Medicare options and an agent can compare plans for you. They can also help you understand the annual enrollment period from October 15 to December 7.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.