ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsIndiana › Mishawaka

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Mishawaka, IN

Browse health insurance agents serving Mishawaka, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Mishawaka, Indiana is McCarthy Insurance Group, rated 4.9 stars across 170 reviews. Other highly rated options include Backstrom Insurance Group, HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher, Pilot Insurance Agency. This directory lists 13 health insurance agents serving Mishawaka.

Showing 13 health insurance agents in Mishawaka, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1McCarthy Insurance Group802 Lincolnway W(574) 259-5622
2Backstrom Insurance Group3006 Lincolnway E(574) 360-8182
3HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400(574) 307-8882
4Pilot Insurance Agency822 W 8th St(574) 855-4837
5HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry1736 E Day Rd #400(574) 229-8147
6DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency1117 Lincolnway E(574) 256-6707
7Dennis Insurance Agency2401 Lincolnway W(574) 254-1010
8Summers Insurance Agency12415 McKinley Hwy(574) 252-0502
9HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400(574) 240-4013
10Synergy Insurance Group13800 Jackson Rd(574) 258-5555
MI
802 Lincolnway W
McCarthy Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

McCarthy Insurance Group serves the Mishawaka, Indiana, metro area and surrounding St. Joseph County as a health insurance agent. The company assists individuals and families in finding suitable medical coverage plans that meet their healthcare needs and budget. Navigating open enrollment periods and understanding policy details are key parts of the services offered. The agency also provides guidance on Medicare supplement plans and short-term health insurance options for local residents.

BI
3006 Lincolnway E
Backstrom Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Backstrom Insurance Group offers a range of health insurance agent services to individuals and small businesses in the Mishawaka, Indiana area. The agency helps clients compare available plans and enroll in coverage that fits their specific needs and budget. It also assists with navigating open enrollment periods and understanding policy details. Backstrom Insurance Group provides ongoing support for plan changes and claims questions. The company serves single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants throughout the community.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Homeowners and renters in Mishawaka, Indiana, can consult HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher for health insurance coverage and plan comparisons. The agency assists with enrollment guidance and explains different policy options, including deductibles and network considerations. As a local health insurance agent, it helps clients navigate the requirements of the Affordable Care Act and available subsidy qualifications. This service also extends to residents in the nearby South Bend metro area and Elkhart County communities.

PI
822 W 8th St
Pilot Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Pilot Insurance Agency serves residents of Mishawaka, Indiana, and the surrounding South Bend metropolitan communities. The company handles health insurance plans, including individual policies, family coverage, and group benefits for local small businesses. In this region, the agency regularly helps clients evaluate their medical needs against available plan options. To handle a typical job, it reviews a customer’s current healthcare usage and budget, then presents several suitable plans from different insurers, allowing the client to compare coverage features before making a final choice.

HI
1736 E Day Rd #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry distinguishes between individual policy selections, which are established once, and the ongoing service of adjusting coverage as needs evolve over time. Situated in Mishawaka, IN, this health insurance agent assists clients in navigating plan options to match their unique healthcare requirements. Service runs on either a scheduled annual review or a one-time consultation basis, with additional as-needed appointments available upon client request.

DI
1117 Lincolnway E
DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency specializes in matching individuals and families with suitable health insurance plans, including navigating marketplace options and Medicare supplements. Based in Mishawaka, Indiana, the agency serves clients across the region by reviewing coverage needs and plan details. The agents help customers understand policy terms, compare deductibles, and find plans that fit both medical requirements and budgets. Each year, the agency assists residents with enrollment during the annual Open Enrollment Period for individual health plans.

DI
2401 Lincolnway W
Dennis Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

As the cost of medical care continues to rise in the Mishawaka area, finding a suitable health insurance plan offers a layer of financial protection. Dennis Insurance Agency serves local individuals and families, guiding them through available coverage options under current regulations. They assist with comparing plan details to help align benefits with personal health needs. An initial consultation is the first step in assessing circumstances and presenting the relevant policies available for review.

SI
12415 McKinley Hwy
Summers Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Summers Insurance Agency in Mishawaka, Indiana focuses on helping clients navigate their health insurance options and select appropriate coverage. The agency also works to connect individuals and families with supplemental plans that address specific healthcare needs and potential gaps. For commercial clients, the agency can assist with insurance solutions for various settings including office environments, warehouse facilities, and food service operations.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding assists residents in Mishawaka, Indiana with individual health plans and family coverage options. The agency also provides guidance on commercial group policies for local small businesses operating within the greater Michawaka area. Clients receive help comparing available marketplace plans and understanding their network options. Zack Spaulding maintains contact with customers to schedule follow-up consultations for annual plan reviews or when life changes occur between regular visits.

SI
13800 Jackson Rd
Synergy Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Synergy Insurance Group in Mishawaka, Indiana, is known for helping individuals and families navigate the local health insurance market. The agency serves clients by explaining plan options from major carriers and guiding them through enrollment periods. Its advisors assess medical needs and budgets to recommend suitable coverage. For those seeking additional protection, the office also offers supplemental plans such as dental or vision insurance to fill gaps in primary health policies.

WI
425 Park Pl Cir Suite 400
WalkerHughes Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 234-7788
walkerhughes.com
SJ
5215 Holy Cross Pkwy
Saint Joseph Health Insurance Services - Mishawaka
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(855) 887-5633
sjmed.com/location/health-insurance-services-1
MM
509 W McKinley Ave Ste 1
Medicare Michiana
Health Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 370-8555

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Mishawaka Cost?

Health insurance agents in Indiana typically do not charge a fee to consumers because they are paid commissions by the insurance companies. For ACA plans the average monthly premium in Indiana for a benchmark silver plan was around $480 per month for a 40 year old in 2024. Costs vary based on age income tobacco use and plan tier. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Mishawaka

Health insurance agents in Mishawaka Indiana help individuals families and small businesses find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Indiana follows federal ACA guidelines and has its own state based marketplace called the Indiana Health Insurance Marketplace. Local agents understand the specific network options available at area hospitals like Saint Joseph Health System and Beacon Health System.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the open enrollment period for health insurance in Indiana?

The open enrollment period for ACA plans in Indiana typically runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. Outside of this window you may qualify for a special enrollment period if you experience a qualifying life event such as losing other coverage or moving to Mishawaka.

Can a health insurance agent help me with Medicaid in Indiana?

Yes a licensed health insurance agent can help you apply for Indiana Medicaid also known as the Healthy Indiana Plan. They can also help you determine if you qualify for the Childrens Health Insurance Program or other state subsidized plans.

What types of health insurance plans are available in Mishawaka?

Agents in Mishawaka can help you compare ACA marketplace plans employer sponsored plans Medicare Advantage and Medigap policies and short term limited duration health plans. Indiana allows short term plans for up to 364 days with the option to renew for up to 36 months.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.