ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Lake Geneva

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Lake Geneva, WI

Browse health insurance agents serving Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin is Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance, rated 4.7 stars across 171 reviews. Other highly rated options include Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent, Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance, Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance. This directory lists 15 health insurance agents serving Lake Geneva.

Showing 15 health insurance agents in Lake Geneva, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance728 Wisconsin St(262) 248-0861
2Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent612 S Wells St STE H(262) 812-4139
3Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance803 S Wells St(262) 248-9502
4Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance772 W Main St Suite 105(262) 248-4239
5Interstate Insurance Group Inc100 W Main St(262) 248-6295
6Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Christopher Hanna836 W Main St #A(262) 729-4034
7Glass Insurance Center500 Commercial Ct #500(262) 248-5555
8Marlene Conroy - State Farm Insurance Agent7273 State Rd 50(262) 248-4771
9Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Robert Hanna836 W Main St(262) 729-4034
10John H MartinN3445 Como Rd Stop 4(262) 248-6000
TI
728 Wisconsin St
Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Tunnell Insurance Agency Inc: Allstate Insurance serves the Lake Geneva area of Walworth County as a health insurance agent. The agency helps individuals and families evaluate and select medical coverage plans that meet their needs and budgets. It works with clients to navigate enrollment periods and understand policy benefits. In this area, the agency specifically handles Medicare supplement plans and individual Affordable Care Act marketplace policies.

JI
612 S Wells St STE H
Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Jordan Innis - State Farm Insurance Agent in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin provides a range of health insurance options designed to help individuals and families manage their medical expenses. Their service includes evaluating plan details and navigating enrollment periods to maintain continuous coverage. The agency offers ongoing support for policy maintenance, including adjustments for life changes and annual renewals. They serve households, apartment residents, local retail businesses, and restaurants by addressing their distinct health coverage needs.

SA
803 S Wells St
Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Spiegelhoff & Assoc Insurance serves homeowners, businesses, and individuals in the Lake Geneva area by helping them navigate health insurance agent options. The agency assists clients in finding individual and family health plans, as well as group coverage for local employers. Its work involves explaining policy details and comparing available benefits to meet different budgetary needs. Residents and business owners can access these services for coverage that fits their specific situations. The agency also covers neighboring communities throughout Walworth County.

RA
772 W Main St Suite 105
Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Resler & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance serves Lake Geneva and surrounding communities in southeastern Wisconsin. The agency handles health insurance plans, helping individuals and families find coverage that fits their needs and budget. As a local health insurance agent, it guides clients through the enrollment process, explaining policy options and answering questions about benefits. The approach typically involves assessing each client’s specific situation, then recommending suitable plans from available carriers while clearly outlining all terms and requirements for enrollment.

II
100 W Main St
Interstate Insurance Group Inc
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Interstate Insurance Group Inc in Lake Geneva, WI specializes in helping individuals and families find suitable health coverage plans. The agency works to assess client needs and provide clear policy comparisons for medical, dental, and vision insurance. It also assists small business owners with group health options. As open enrollment periods approach each year or when a major life event like a job change occurs, the agent guides clients through the selection process to ensure they maintain necessary coverage without gaps.

RM
836 W Main St #A
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Christopher Hanna
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

As the seasonal influx of visitors and second-home owners puts pressure on healthcare access around Lake Geneva, Rural Mutual Insurance Agent Christopher Hanna provides residents with guidance through the complex health insurance market. He helps individuals compare Affordable Care Act plans and Medicare options suited to their changing needs. Local clients appreciate having an agent who understands the distinct rhythm of life in this lakeside community. The process begins with a free initial consultation to assess each person’s current coverage priorities.

GI
500 Commercial Ct #500
Glass Insurance Center
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

At Glass Insurance Center in Lake Geneva, WI, a health insurance agent assists individuals and groups with selecting suitable medical coverage plans. This agency specializes in adding supplemental policies, such as dental and vision benefits. It provides professional guidance on navigating open enrollment periods and comparing plan options from various carriers. The agency serves local businesses, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments, helping them obtain appropriate health insurance for their employees.

MC
7273 State Rd 50
Marlene Conroy - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Marlene Conroy, a health insurance agent in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, helps clients understand the difference between one-time plans, such as short-term medical coverage, and recurring services like marketplace policies that renew annually. Health insurance agents in this area guide individuals and families through the enrollment process and assist with selecting appropriate coverage based on medical needs and budget. Marlene Conroy offers her services on both a scheduled appointment basis and an as-needed basis for questions or policy changes.

RM
836 W Main St
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Robert Hanna
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance agent Robert Hanna offers health insurance coverage to residents of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, and the surrounding area. His services are available for individuals and families seeking personal plans. He also works with local businesses to secure group health options for their employees. Serving clients across Geneva Lake communities, he can address a full range of medical coverage needs. Follow-up appointments are scheduled to review policy changes or adjust benefits between regular visits.

JH
N3445 Como Rd Stop 4
John H Martin
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI

John H Martin operates as a health insurance agent serving clients throughout the Lake Geneva area. The company assists individuals and families in evaluating medical coverage options that fit their healthcare needs and financial situations. It offers guidance on selecting health plans and understanding policy details. The agent works with different insurers to provide a range of possible plans. As a specialty service, the agency can help customers navigate open enrollment periods for individual health insurance policies.

SE
N 3219 County Rd H Unit C
Scott English - COUNTRY Financial Representative
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(847) 265-0799
advisors.countryfinancial.com/usa/il/crystal-lake/scott-english
RM
N3475 Springfield Rd
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Ashley Rogers
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(262) 203-5678
ruralmutual.com/agent/ashley-rogers
LG
647 W Main St
Lake Geneva Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(262) 374-5600
lakegenevainsurance.com
LG
836 W Main St
Lake Geneva Health Insurance - The Premium Package
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(262) 686-3123
thepremiumpackage.com
JI
493 W South St
Jones Insurance Services
Health Insurance Agent · Lake Geneva, WI
(815) 575-0401

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Lake Geneva Cost?

The cost of health insurance in Wisconsin varies by plan type, age, income, and coverage level. ACA marketplace plans with premium tax credits can reduce monthly premiums to as low as zero dollars for some individuals. Without subsidies, a standard silver plan for a 40-year-old in Lake Geneva might range from 400 to 700 dollars per month. Medicare Supplement plans typically cost between 100 and 300 dollars per month. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Lake Geneva

Health insurance agents in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin help individuals and families find coverage that meets their needs and budget. Wisconsin law requires agents to be licensed by the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance. Local agents can explain plans available through the Wisconsin health insurance marketplace and private insurers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of health insurance plans can an agent in Lake Geneva help with?

Agents in Lake Geneva can assist with Affordable Care Act marketplace plans, Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans, short-term health insurance, and individual or family plans. They can also explain Wisconsin BadgerCare eligibility and enrollment.

Is there a specific enrollment period for health insurance in Wisconsin?

Yes, the annual Open Enrollment Period for ACA plans runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. Special Enrollment Periods are available for qualifying life events like losing other coverage or moving to Lake Geneva.

Do health insurance agents charge fees for their services in Wisconsin?

Most health insurance agents in Wisconsin are paid by the insurance companies, not by the client. They typically do not charge a separate fee for helping you compare plans and enroll. Always confirm the payment arrangement before working with an agent.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.