ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Elkhorn, WI

Browse home insurance agents serving Elkhorn, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Elkhorn, Wisconsin is Tonia Andre - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.8 stars across 37 reviews. Other highly rated options include Kailey Wagener Agency LLC American Family Insurance, Sierra Insurance Marketing & Off Wall Street LLC, Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Bobbie Bonvicini. This directory lists 17 home insurance agents serving Elkhorn.

Showing 17 home insurance agents in Elkhorn, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Tonia Andre - State Farm Insurance Agent5 Ridgway Ct Ste A(262) 723-2664
2Kailey Wagener Agency LLC American Family Insurance210 O'Connor Dr ste 101(262) 723-4370
3Sierra Insurance Marketing & Off Wall Street LLC16 S Broad St #1(262) 723-3331
4Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Bobbie Bonvicini22 S Wisconsin St #6(608) 575-3038
5BWO InsuranceN5860 US-12 c(262) 743-2011
6Longhorn Insurance Services, Inc.18 S Broad St(262) 723-2851
7Henricks Wilging InsuranceN6369 US-12 ste b(262) 742-4029
8Monty Insurance SolutionsW5241 Plantation Rd(262) 742-2400
9Lakes Area Insurance LLC205 Co Trunk H
10Sugar Creek Mutual Insurance Company605 E Geneva St(262) 723-3244
TA
5 Ridgway Ct Ste A
Tonia Andre - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Tonia Andre - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Elkhorn, Wisconsin area, and surrounding Walworth County communities, specializing in home insurance. The agency assists local homeowners with standard dwelling coverage and policies that protect personal belongings. They also guide residents in selecting appropriate liability protection for their properties. In this area, the agent helps clients manage home insurance claims and offers personalized renters insurance options.

KW
210 O'Connor Dr ste 101
Kailey Wagener Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Kailey Wagener Agency LLC American Family Insurance in Elkhorn, WI, provides a full range of home insurance services, helping local property owners evaluate policies that protect their dwellings and personal belongings from common regional risks. It offers guidance on routine policy maintenance, such as updating coverage after home improvements or changes in property value. The agency services single-family homes and apartments in the Elkhorn area, as well as local retail spaces and restaurants needing tailored commercial property coverage.

SI
16 S Broad St #1
Sierra Insurance Marketing & Off Wall Street LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Sierra Insurance Marketing & Off Wall Street LLC serves homeowners and property managers in Elkhorn, Wisconsin, by matching them with home insurance policies that fit their specific coverage needs. The company helps clients navigate policy details, deductible options, and coverage limits to ensure adequate protection for their properties. It also assists with annual policy reviews to adapt coverage as circumstances change. In addition to Elkhorn, Sierra Insurance Marketing & Off Wall Street LLC provides its services to customers in the neighboring community of Lake Geneva.

RM
22 S Wisconsin St #6
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Bobbie Bonvicini
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance Agent Bobbie Bonvicini provides home insurance services to Elkhorn, Wisconsin, and surrounding Walworth County communities, handling policies for homeowners and renters alike. The agency addresses risks common to the region, including severe storm damage, winter freeze issues, and liability concerns. Typical work involves assessing a property’s replacement cost, answering policy questions, and tailoring coverage to each client’s specific needs. To handle a typical job, the agent begins with a thorough initial consultation to understand the property and personal situation before recommending appropriate policy options.

BI
N5860 US-12 c
BWO Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

For those deciding between a one-time policy adjustment and scheduled annual policy reviews, BWO Insurance in Elkhorn, Wisconsin, provides comprehensive home insurance agent services. The office helps residents structure coverage that protects the structure, personal belongings, and liability exposure typical for properties in the local area. Service arrangements are flexible, running on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis depending on the client’s preferred level of engagement.

LI
18 S Broad St
Longhorn Insurance Services, Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Longhorn Insurance Services, Inc. in Elkhorn, WI, provides comprehensive residential home insurance coverage for local homeowners. The agency also offers commercial property policies tailored to area businesses throughout the surrounding region. Their agents work with clients to review existing plans and identify appropriate protection for dwellings and personal belongings. After securing a policy, customers can schedule follow-up appointments for annual coverage reviews or to adjust limits as property values change between regular community visits.

HW
N6369 US-12 ste b
Henricks Wilging Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

As winter weather threatens roofs in Elkhorn with ice dams and heavy snow, Henricks Wilging Insurance helps homeowners review coverage for storm-related damage. This home insurance agent provides personal guidance on policies that protect local properties from common regional risks. Residents meet with an agent to discuss liability and dwelling coverage tailored to their neighborhood. After an initial consultation, a thorough inspection of the home's exterior and interior is arranged to assess current value and identify needed policy updates.

MI
W5241 Plantation Rd
Monty Insurance Solutions
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Monty Insurance Solutions, based in Elkhorn, WI, specializes in customizing coverage plans for unique home features, such as historic properties or in-law suites, alongside its general work of providing standard home insurance policies. The agency assists local residents in navigating the specific risks common to the region. It helps homeowners address potential concerns like spring thaw water damage from snowmelt or ice dam formation along roof edges.

LA
205 Co Trunk H
Lakes Area Insurance LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
SC
605 E Geneva St
Sugar Creek Mutual Insurance Company
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI

Sugar Creek Mutual Insurance Company in Elkhorn, WI, is known for providing tailored home insurance solutions to local homeowners. The agency offers a range of policies designed to protect residential properties from common risks in the area, including weather-related damage and liability concerns. Its services cover basic dwelling coverage and personal property protection. For clients seeking broader security, the company can add on specialized flood insurance to safeguard against water damage not included in standard plans.

CI
W5697 Babcock Rd
Clarity Insurance Group
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 949-2085
TI
15 S Lincoln St # 1
TRICOR Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 723-4841
tricorinsurance.com/elkhorn-insurance-office
SF
501 Nathan Ln
Sierra Financial Services
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 723-3898
sierrafinancialservices.com
FI
23 S Wisconsin St
Farmers Insurance - William Bixby
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 723-8051
agents.farmers.com/wi/elkhorn/william-bixby
AE
15 S Lincoln St #3
AXA Equitable
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 723-6278
WC
119 S Broad St
Walworth County Farm Bureau
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(877) 483-2749
wfbf.com/county-farm-bureaus/walworth
AI
17 W Walworth St
Ascot Insurance Agency Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Elkhorn, WI
(262) 723-5655

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Elkhorn Cost?

The average cost of home insurance in Wisconsin is about 1,200 to 1,800 dollars per year for a standard policy. In Elkhorn rates may vary based on your homes age location and claims history. Older homes or those near flood zones may cost more. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Elkhorn

Home insurance agents in Elkhorn Wisconsin help you protect your property against risks like fire theft and storm damage. Wisconsin law requires insurers to offer coverage for certain perils but does not mandate homeowners insurance. Agents can explain policy options and help you comply with lender requirements if you have a mortgage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Elkhorn do?

A home insurance agent in Elkhorn helps you find a policy that fits your home and budget. They explain coverage limits deductibles and exclusions. They also assist with claims and policy changes after you buy a policy.

Is homeowners insurance required in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin state law does not require homeowners insurance. However most mortgage lenders require it as a condition of the loan. An agent can help you meet lender requirements and protect your investment.

How do I choose a home insurance agent in Elkhorn?

Look for an agent licensed in Wisconsin with experience in Walworth County. Ask about their carrier options and customer service. You can check the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance for agent license status.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.