ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Carmel, IN

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Carmel, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Carmel, Indiana is Dean Ballenger Agency Inc, rated 5.0 stars across 610 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hittle Insurance, Howard Medicare and Health Insurance, BWC Insurance. This directory lists 20 medicare insurance agents serving Carmel.

Showing 20 medicare insurance agents in Carmel, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dean Ballenger Agency Inc14767 Oak Rd(317) 867-5433
2Hittle Insurance14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130(317) 895-5555
3Howard Medicare and Health Insurance4933 Briarwood Ct(317) 663-7602
4BWC Insurance13295 Illinois St # 134(317) 324-1489
5ShieldPoint Insurance571 Monon Blvd Ste 200(317) 395-3877
6Shepherd Insurance111 Congressional Blvd Suite 200(317) 846-5554
7Independent Senior Insurance, Inc3309 E 146th St(317) 921-5919
8The DeRoss Insurance Agency1905 S New Market St Suite 265(317) 219-3100
9Zeitler Financial Insurance Agency LLC - Health Insurance/Marketplace/Business Insurance14843 Sulky Way(317) 439-9505
10Washington National11299 Illinois St Suite 200(800) 525-7662
DB
14767 Oak Rd
Dean Ballenger Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Dean Ballenger Agency Inc serves the Carmel area and surrounding Hamilton County as a full-service Medicare insurance agency. It helps individuals navigate Medicare options during initial enrollment and annual open enrollment periods. The firm provides guidance on Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Advantage plans. Additional support is available for those transitioning from employer coverage to Medicare. The agency handles Part D prescription drug plan comparisons to align coverage with individual medication needs.

HI
14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130
Hittle Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Hittle Insurance provides a range of Medicare insurance options to clients in the Carmel, Indiana area. They assist individuals with navigating plan selections and annual enrollment periods, helping to match coverage with healthcare needs. The agency offers ongoing support for policy management and addressing client questions throughout the year. This service helps ensure beneficiaries maintain appropriate and effective health coverage. The agency primarily services individual policies for those aged sixty-five and over, covering single-family homeowners and apartment residents.

HM
4933 Briarwood Ct
Howard Medicare and Health Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Homeowners and individuals approaching Medicare eligibility throughout Carmel rely on Howard Medicare and Health Insurance for guidance on plan options. The agent explains differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans, including Part D drug coverage and supplemental policies. Each client’s healthcare needs are reviewed to recommend suitable coverage during the annual enrollment period. This specialized assistance extends to residents of the surrounding Hamilton County suburbs, as well as the Fishers and Noblesville areas in the broader Indianapolis metro.

BI
13295 Illinois St # 134
BWC Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

BWC Insurance, a Medicare insurance agent based in Carmel, IN, helps clients understand the key distinction between one-time enrollment assistance and ongoing, year-round service options. Their guidance covers Medicare Advantage, prescription drug plans, and Medigap supplemental coverage, tailoring each recommendation to individual healthcare needs. For those requiring consistent support, policy reviews are available during Annual Enrollment and other special periods. Service runs on a scheduled basis, coordinated to align with enrollment windows and client-specific plan renewals.

SI
571 Monon Blvd Ste 200
ShieldPoint Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

ShieldPoint Insurance specializes in helping individuals navigate Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans. Based in Carmel, IN, the agency serves clients across the region by assessing healthcare needs and comparing available coverage options to find suitable plans. It guides new Medicare enrollees through initial choices and assists existing beneficiaries with annual plan reviews. As the Annual Enrollment Period approaches each fall, the agency specifically helps clients evaluate changes in premiums, drug formularies, and provider networks to avoid coverage gaps for the coming year.

SI
111 Congressional Blvd Suite 200
Shepherd Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Shepherd Insurance serves residents of Carmel, Indiana with Medicare insurance guidance. Commercial coverage options are also available for local businesses throughout the broader Hamilton County area. The agency helps clients understand their plan choices during initial enrollment and during annual open enrollment periods. Follow-up appointments are routinely scheduled between regular visits to review any changes in health needs or prescription drug coverage. This ongoing service ensures policies remain appropriately aligned with each client’s evolving situation.

IS
3309 E 146th St
Independent Senior Insurance, Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

For seniors in Carmel reviewing their coverage during the Annual Enrollment Period, choices about Part D and Medicare Advantage can feel overwhelming. Independent Senior Insurance, Inc addresses this seasonal need by guiding clients through their options with clear, practical explanations. The agent details how each plan structure may coordinate with existing prescriptions and preferred local providers. To ensure you see how coverage matches your circumstances, the first step involves scheduling a personalized consultation, during which agents assess your current health needs and any upcoming medical plans before recommending specific policies.

DI
1905 S New Market St Suite 265
The DeRoss Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

The DeRoss Insurance Agency helps clients understand and enroll in Medicare coverage, with a particular focus on Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans. It serves the Carmel, Indiana area by analyzing individual healthcare needs and comparing available plan options. The agency assists beneficiaries through the annual enrollment period and special enrollment periods. Its services extend to small commercial enterprises needing group health coverage, including offices, warehouses, and food service businesses.

ZF
14843 Sulky Way
Zeitler Financial Insurance Agency LLC - Health Insurance/Marketplace/Business Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Zeitler Financial Insurance Agency LLC helps residents of Carmel and the surrounding area navigate Medicare insurance options, while also offering commercial coverage for local businesses through its Health Insurance and Marketplace divisions. The agency guides individuals through plan selection and enrollment, focusing on matching coverage to specific healthcare needs. Local clients return for annual reviews during open enrollment periods, allowing the agent to adjust policies as health requirements or budgets change between regular visits.

WN
11299 Illinois St Suite 200
Washington National
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Washington National serves the Carmel, Indiana, area and surrounding Hamilton County communities, focusing on assisting clients with Medicare insurance options. It handles plan comparisons, enrollment guidance, and supplemental coverage needs for beneficiaries navigating their healthcare decisions. The company works closely with each individual to clarify eligibility and simplify the transition into Medicare. Its standard approach involves a thorough review of a client’s current health needs and budget to identify coverage that fits their personal situation.

RO
231 Lark Dr Unit 1
Rain or Shine Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 601-7472
rainorshineinsurance.com
AH
10255 Commerce Dr Suit 261
Aloe Health Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
aloehealthinsurance.com
MI
11939 N Meridian St
Midwest Insurance Indiana
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 349-7943
SI
1320 City Center Dr
Special Insurance Brokers LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 349-7954
SI
11455 N Meridian St
Superb Insurance IN
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(574) 281-9296
II
11611 N Meridian St
Independent Insurance Agents of Indiana
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(800) 438-4424
bigi.org
SI
301 E Carmel Dr SUITE C500
Sunday Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 571-5200
sundayins.com
CM
113 Veterans Wy
Cover Me Insurance Service
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 406-7819
MI
468 Gradle Dr
Mutual Insurance IN
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 207-6490
MI
11711 N Meridian St #225
Medicare Independent Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 509-3768

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Carmel Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Indiana do not charge you directly for their help. They receive commissions from insurance companies. Plan costs vary widely: Medicare Advantage plans may have $0 monthly premiums while Medigap plans in Indiana often range from $100 to $300 per month depending on age gender and tobacco use. Part D prescription drug plans have premiums typically between $10 and $80 per month. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Carmel

Medicare insurance agents in Carmel Indiana help residents compare Part D Advantage and Medigap plans. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed and follow state regulations for marketing and enrollment. Local agents understand the specific network options available in Hamilton County and can guide you through Initial Enrollment Periods and Special Enrollment Periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in Carmel Indiana?

Your Initial Enrollment Period begins three months before your 65th birthday month and ends three months after. Indiana follows federal rules for this timeline. Missing this window may result in late enrollment penalties.

What is the difference between Medicare Advantage and Medigap in Indiana?

Medicare Advantage plans replace Original Medicare and often include drug coverage. Medigap plans supplement Original Medicare and help pay for deductibles and coinsurance. Indiana residents in Medigap have guaranteed issue rights during certain enrollment periods.

Do Medicare agents in Carmel charge fees for their services?

Most Medicare insurance agents in Indiana are compensated by insurance carriers not by clients. You typically pay no direct fee for agent services. Always confirm the compensation arrangement before working with an agent.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.