ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, PA

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Lancaster, Pennsylvania is HomeSale Insurance Services, rated 5.0 stars across 454 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bagnall Shaw Insurance, Susquehanna Insurance, Red Rose Insurance. This directory lists 30 medicare insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 30 medicare insurance agents in Lancaster, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1HomeSale Insurance Services215 S Centerville Rd Ste B(800) 425-5130
2Bagnall Shaw Insurance401 W Orange St(717) 431-8383
3Susquehanna Insurance650 Delp Rd(717) 290-7780
4Red Rose Insurance100 S Queen St Ste 226(717) 690-0971
5Gebhard Insurance LLC90 Willow Valley Square(717) 930-2085
6Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster617B N Prince St #200(717) 397-4729
7Acceptance Insurance454 N Prince St(717) 356-3320
8Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance705 Olde Hickory Rd(717) 560-9733
9Aubrey Montgomery - State Farm Insurance Agent630 Delp Rd Ste 200(717) 283-4910
10EHD Insurance1857 William Penn Way(717) 394-5681
HI
215 S Centerville Rd Ste B
HomeSale Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

HomeSale Insurance Services serves Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, offering Medicare insurance guidance to local residents. The company helps individuals navigate their healthcare coverage options as they approach eligibility. This includes explaining the differences between Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Supplement policies. Clients receive assistance with plan comparisons, enrollment periods, and understanding out-of-pocket costs. These services aim to clarify the complexities of Parts A and B, as well as Part D prescription drug coverage. HomeSale Insurance Services provides support specifically for annual enrollment periods and initial enrollment at age sixty-five.

BS
401 W Orange St
Bagnall Shaw Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Bagnall Shaw Insurance provides Medicare insurance guidance to clients in Lancaster, PA, helping them navigate plan options, enrollment periods, and coverage details. Its agents offer services related to initial sign-ups as well as plan reviews and changes during annual enrollment. Maintenance support includes annual policy check-ins to ensure coverage remains aligned with healthcare needs. The practice serves individuals in a variety of residential settings, including single-family homes, apartments, and retirement communities.

SI
650 Delp Rd
Susquehanna Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Susquehanna Insurance serves local homeowners and individuals seeking guidance on Medicare coverage options in the Lancaster, PA area. The agency provides personalized assistance navigating plan selections and enrollment processes, helping clients understand their health insurance choices during annual enrollment periods. It regularly works with community members to review Medicare supplements, Advantage plans, and prescription drug coverage. The agency also extends its services to residents in the neighboring community of Mount Joy, ensuring broader access for those in the metro region who require professional insurance agent support.

RR
100 S Queen St Ste 226
Red Rose Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Red Rose Insurance serves Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding communities in the area. The company handles Medicare insurance options. It helps individuals understand the differences between Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans. The agent works to match clients with suitable coverage based on their specific needs. A typical job begins with a free consultation to review a person's current health requirements and existing plan. The agent then compares local plan options to recommend the most appropriate choice for the client.

GI
90 Willow Valley Square
Gebhard Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Gebhard Insurance LLC in Lancaster, PA specializes in Medicare insurance planning, including help with original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plan options. It guides clients through supplemental coverage and Part D prescription drug plans. The agency assists individuals with open enrollment periods, ensuring they understand available choices. It also helps with the annual Medicare Advantage disenrollment period, addressing coverage changes for those who need to switch back to original Medicare before the start of a new year.

EI
617B N Prince St #200
Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Element Insurance Agency in Lancaster, PA helps differentiate between one-time Medicare plan evaluations and recurring annual policy reviews, ensuring ongoing coverage aligns with changing needs. They assist clients with understanding the differences between Medicare Advantage, supplement plans, and Part D drug coverage. The agency provides guidance on initial enrollments and the annual open enrollment period, clarifying complex rules and penalties. Their service operates on both a scheduled appointment basis for comprehensive reviews and an as-needed basis for specific enrollment questions or changes.

AI
454 N Prince St
Acceptance Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Acceptance Insurance in York, PA offers medicare insurance guidance that explains the difference between one-time plan comparisons and recurring annual reviews of coverage options. Medicare insurance agents in this area help residents evaluate Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and prescription drug plans for their specific needs. Local advisors can often meet in person or conduct consultations by phone to ensure clients understand enrollment periods and plan changes. Service runs on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis depending on client preference.

HI
705 Olde Hickory Rd
Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance provides health coverage guidance to clients in the Lancaster area, focusing on Medicare insurance plans that help seniors manage their medical costs. The company assists individuals with plan selection, enrollment, and annual policy reviews. It also offers supplemental coverage options to address out-of-pocket expenses not covered by original Medicare. Commercial insurance solutions are available for offices, warehouses, and food service operations, ensuring businesses have appropriate liability and property protection.

AM
630 Delp Rd Ste 200
Aubrey Montgomery - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Aubrey Montgomery, a Medicare insurance agent based in Lancaster, PA, assists residents with enrolling in and understanding their Medicare coverage options. The agency also addresses commercial insurance needs for local businesses. Service across Lancaster County is provided, helping clients navigate plan selection during open enrollment and special periods. Between regular annual visits, the agent provides follow-up support for any changes in coverage or claims questions.

EI
1857 William Penn Way
EHD Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
OS
Lower Level Manor Shopping Center, 1250 Millersville Pike
One Stop Services Solution LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 340-0993
onestoplancaster.com
AC
804 Estelle Dr
AAA Central Penn
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 898-6900
centralpenn.aaa.com/branch-locations/lancaster
SS
9 Meadow Ln
Senior Solutions of PA
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 824-4719
seniorsolutionsofpa.com
LF
3008 Columbia Ave
Landis Financial Advisors, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 208-6990
landisfinancialadvisors.com
WI
2286 Pullman Rd
Walker Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 569-3016
walkerinsuranceservices.net
CI
101 Good Dr floor 2
Community Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-7531
communitysure.com
IS
1394 Harrisburg Pike
Insurance Services LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 869-4893
myinsuranceteam.com
HA
Warehouse D, 342 N Queen St
PA Health Advocates
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 400-1244
pahealthadvocates.com
RI
320 Granite Run Dr
Ruhl Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 665-2283
iruhl.com
JM
2860 Harrisburg Pike
Julie Meyers Insurance Solutions
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 435-4000
meyersins.com
HD
2350 Lincoln Hwy E
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-1972
highmarkdirect.com
NT
2250 Erin Ct
ntiDirectCare
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 619-8110
ntidirectcare.net
KA
202 Butler Ave #103
Karpinski & Associates Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 295-7088
karpinskiassociates.com
MU
39 N Duke St
Murray
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-9600
assuredpartners.com/lancaster
DE
90 Willow Valley Square
David E Gebhard and Associates
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 464-3707
erieinsurance.com/agencies/pa/lancaster/aa7658
PH
480 New Holland Ave #7203
Preferred Health Care
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(800) 701-5909
phcunity.com
HI
320 Granite Run Dr Suite 201
Horst Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-1919
horstinsurance.com
CH
247 Black Oak Dr
Customized Health/Life Insurance Plans
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 341-6666
askchlip.com
SG
137 Greenview Dr
Sheaffer Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 519-6664
sheaffergroupllc.com
WW
1300 Millersville Pike
WFG/ world financial group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 723-9683
wfgconnects.com/haidao

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Pennsylvania typically do not charge you directly for their services. They receive commissions from insurance carriers. Some agents may charge a consultation fee ranging from 50 to 200 dollars but this is uncommon. Costs for Medicare plans themselves vary by carrier and coverage level. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Lancaster

Medicare insurance agents in Lancaster Pennsylvania help residents navigate plan options including Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans. Pennsylvania law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict marketing guidelines during the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7. Local agents understand the specific healthcare networks available in Lancaster County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Lancaster do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you compare plans explain coverage details and assist with enrollment. They can review your current medications and doctors to find a plan that works for you. Agents in Pennsylvania must be certified to sell Medicare products.

How do I choose a Medicare insurance agent in Lancaster?

Look for an agent licensed in Pennsylvania with experience in Medicare plans. You can check their license status on the Pennsylvania Insurance Department website. Ask about the carriers they represent to ensure they offer a range of options.

Is there a time limit to enroll in Medicare in Pennsylvania?

Yes your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after. The Annual Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7 each year. Missing these windows may result in late enrollment penalties.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.