ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Erie, PA

Browse renters insurance agents serving Erie, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Erie, Pennsylvania is Cronk Insurance Inc., rated 5.0 stars across 433 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent, Jeremy Borrero - State Farm Insurance Agent, Chris Wertz - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 31 renters insurance agents serving Erie.

Showing 31 renters insurance agents in Erie, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Cronk Insurance Inc.3838 W 12th St(814) 456-7501
2Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent2244 W 38th St(814) 838-9650
3Jeremy Borrero - State Farm Insurance Agent952 W 38th St(814) 866-1941
4Chris Wertz - State Farm Insurance Agent4402 Dexter Ave.(814) 452-4609
5Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent4532 Peach St(814) 868-4839
6Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent864 Silliman Ave(814) 899-1112
7Sitter Insurance, LLC4267 W Ridge Rd(814) 835-3889
8Jacob Krezmien - GEICO Insurance Agent3732 Sterrettania Rd Unit 104(814) 738-6000
9Historic Square Agency LLC3731 W 26th St(814) 835-3743
10Tony DeMichele - State Farm Insurance Agent1804 W 8th St(814) 455-8669
CI
3838 W 12th St
Cronk Insurance Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Cronk Insurance Inc. serves the Erie, Pennsylvania metro area and its surrounding county, specializing in renters insurance policies for local residents. The agency helps tenants secure coverage that protects personal belongings against common perils like theft, fire, and water damage. It can also assist renters in obtaining liability protection in case someone is injured inside a rented apartment or home. The team guides clients through selecting appropriate policy limits and deductibles tailored to their specific lease agreements and property values.

MS
2244 W 38th St
Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

As autumn storms can suddenly create water damage in apartments around Erie, many tenants seek affordable protection for their belongings. Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent provides renters insurance policies tailored to local property types and tenant needs. Their office helps clients understand coverage for personal possessions against theft, fire, or burst pipes common in the region. A quick online or phone conversation typically schedules a brief assessment of the dwelling and individual inventory requirements before issuing a quote.

JB
952 W 38th St
Jeremy Borrero - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Serving Erie renters, Jeremy Borrero - State Farm Insurance Agent offers tailored renters insurance policies covering personal belongings and liability protection. The agency works with clients to bundle coverage with auto policies for potential savings. It assists local residents in assessing the value of their possessions, including electronics and furniture, to ensure adequate coverage limits. During Pennsylvania’s harsh winter months, the agency helps renters understand protections against frozen pipes and burst water heater damage that can impact apartments or rental homes.

CW
4402 Dexter Ave.
Chris Wertz - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Chris Wertz - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Erie, Pennsylvania, and its surrounding communities, handling renters insurance policies for tenants in apartments and homes. It offers coverage for personal belongings and liability protection against common risks like theft or fire damage. The agent typically begins each job by reviewing a client's inventory of possessions and discussing their daily living situation to tailor the policy limits accordingly.

TM
4532 Peach St
Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

In Erie, PA, Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent offers both a one-time policy setup and recurring coverage for renters seeking protection. Monthly premium payments are typical for ongoing policies, which safeguard personal belongings from common perils like theft or fire. Clients are guided through selecting a liability limit to cover accidents within their rental unit. This local agency provides services on an as-needed basis, such as when a new renter moves in or an existing policy requires an adjustment.

BF
864 Silliman Ave
Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent in Erie, PA, provides residential renters insurance for tenants protecting personal belongings and providing liability coverage. Commercial renters insurance is also available for local businesses leasing their workspace. The agency serves the greater Erie area and surrounding communities. After an initial policy is set, the agent follows up between regular visits to adjust coverage as needs or circumstances change. Clients are encouraged to schedule periodic check-ins to discuss any updates.

SI
4267 W Ridge Rd
Sitter Insurance, LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Sitter Insurance, LLC, operating in Erie, PA, is known for providing renters insurance policies that protect personal property against theft and damage. The agency assists local residents in selecting coverage that aligns with their individual rental situations and budgets. A standard policy typically covers personal belongings and liability for accidents in the rented home. For an added layer of protection, Sitter Insurance can also offer an endorsement for valuable items like jewelry or electronics.

JK
3732 Sterrettania Rd Unit 104
Jacob Krezmien - GEICO Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Jacob Krezmien - GEICO Insurance Agent in Erie, PA, helps local residents secure renters insurance coverage. The agency focuses on policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage against common household risks. It offers specialty add-ons for valuable items such as jewelry, electronics, and fine art. Renters insurance can also include loss-of-use coverage if a home becomes uninhabitable. The agent serves tenants in various sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments, ensuring protection for both residential and commercial rental situations.

HS
3731 W 26th St
Historic Square Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Historic Square Agency LLC serves Erie, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding communities with renters insurance policies. It handles coverage for personal belongings and liability protection. The agency evaluates each client's unique living situation and inventory needs to determine appropriate policy options. It works directly with tenants to explain key provisions and exclusions. To handle a typical job, the agent conducts a thorough walkthrough of rental units to document potential risks and recommend suitable coverage limits.

TD
1804 W 8th St
Tony DeMichele - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Tony DeMichele - State Farm Insurance Agent in Erie, Pennsylvania, helps renters distinguish between one-time liability-focused policies and recurring plans that include broader personal property coverage. These insurance options protect belongings against theft, fire, and certain weather-related losses. Renters Insurance Agents typically guide clients through selecting coverage limits and deductibles that fit individual rental situations. Service for in-person consultations, policy reviews, and claims support operates on both a scheduled appointment basis and an as-needed walk-in basis.

JB
3404 State St
Jeremy Borrero - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 455-4698
statefarm.com/agent/us/pa/erie/jeremy-borrero-6fyylbfxfal
MS
5320 Buffalo Rd Unit B
Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 806-3466
insurancewithmike.net
BI
1460 W 38th St
Bort Insurance Services
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 868-3400
bortinsurance.com
MW
6031 W Ridge Rd
Michael Walling: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 616-3600
agents.allstate.com/michael-walling-erie-pa.html
NI
2340 W Grandview Blvd #3
Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 838-8310
northshoreinsuranceagency.com
CE
3319 W 26th St
Cam El-Farouki - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 833-6663
teamerie.com
LS
3537 W 12th St
Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 833-5433
lsinsure.com
LI
4627 Peach St
Lafaro Insurance Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 866-5528
manlafins.com
LB
4602 Peach St
Locastro Bonini Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 868-0858
locastrobonini.com
HM
2562 W 12th St
Hart McConahy & Martz Insurance Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 455-0987
hmm-ins.com
LI
3715 Zimmerman Rd
Lighthouse Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 453-4721
weinsureerie.com
LI
4620 Buffalo Rd
Laskowski Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 897-8467
laskins.com
RH
2900 Copperleaf Dr STE. 100
R. H. Rutkowski Insurance Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 870-3131
rhrins.com
BI
4603 Wattsburg Rd
Burick Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 825-3660
jessicaburickinsurance.com
FI
1131 W 38th St
Farmers Insurance - Christine Pustelak
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 866-6000
agents.farmers.com/pa/erie/christine-pustelak
NB
1338 E 38th St
Natalie Braddock - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 825-3186
nataliebraddock.com
CM
8270 Peach St Suite 200
Cheryl Mitchell Insurance Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 651-0711
cherylmitchellinsurance.com
DK
1730 W 26th St
Drushel & Kolakowski Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 455-8434
dk4ins.com
MI
10 N Park Row
Murray Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 870-3124
jjmurrayinsurance.com
BI
121 E 2nd St
Black Insurance Group
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 453-6746
samuelpblack.com
FI
3910 Caughey Rd #220
Farmers Insurance - Patrick Geary
Renters Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 315-2700
agents.farmers.com/pa/erie/patrick-geary

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Erie Cost?

In Pennsylvania renters insurance policies usually cost between 150 and 360 dollars per year or about 12 to 30 dollars per month. Factors that affect your rate include the value of your belongings your deductible amount and your location in Erie near the lake may increase wind coverage costs. This is general information not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Erie

Renters insurance agents in Erie Pennsylvania help tenants protect their personal property from theft fire and water damage. Pennsylvania law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in Erie now include it in lease agreements. Agents can explain how local risks like Lake Erie storms affect your coverage needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does renters insurance cover in Erie Pennsylvania?

Renters insurance typically covers your personal belongings against perils like fire theft and vandalism. It also provides liability protection if someone is injured in your rental unit. In Erie policies often include coverage for wind and hail damage common near the lake.

Is renters insurance required by law in Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania state law does not require tenants to have renters insurance. However many landlords in Erie now require it as a condition of the lease. Check your rental agreement to see if insurance is mandatory.

How much does a renters insurance agent cost in Erie?

Agents do not charge a fee for their services they earn a commission from the insurance company. The cost of the policy itself typically ranges from 15 to 30 dollars per month in Pennsylvania. Your premium depends on your coverage limits and deductible.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.