ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Appleton, WI

Browse renters insurance agents serving Appleton, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Appleton, Wisconsin is Thiel Insurance Group, LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 783 reviews. Other highly rated options include 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin, Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance, Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency. This directory lists 26 renters insurance agents serving Appleton.

Showing 26 renters insurance agents in Appleton, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Thiel Insurance Group, LLC620 N Richmond St(920) 739-6241
25 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin119 N McCarthy Rd suite g(920) 831-3210
3Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance150 W Northland Ave(920) 730-1100
4Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400(920) 931-3693
5Jordyn Hendzel - State Farm Insurance Agent4055 E Calumet St Ste D(920) 882-4200
6Ken Heiner - State Farm Insurance Agent3110 N Ballard Rd(920) 734-3141
7Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent2711 N Mason St(920) 739-3003
8Comparion Insurance Agency2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400(920) 749-9799
9Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton ClaimsW6207 Aerotech Dr(920) 993-8550
10Andy Wescott - State Farm Insurance Agent1117 N Badger Ave ste e(920) 750-7800
TI
620 N Richmond St
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC serves the Appleton area as a renters insurance agent, helping clients protect personal belongings and liability. The company guides renters through policy options that cover losses from theft, fire, or water damage. As a local agency, it offers personalized advice on choosing appropriate coverage limits and deductibles. Thiel Insurance Group, LLC handles filing claims for damaged property and securing replacement cost policies for renters in Appleton.

5S
119 N McCarthy Rd suite g
5 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

5 Star Insurance Group, LLC in Appleton, Wisconsin provides renters insurance agent services, helping clients secure coverage for personal belongings and liability protection. The agency assists with policy selection, ensuring tenants understand their coverage options and any available endorsements. It also offers guidance on filing claims and updating policies as needs change. This local agency services a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants in the Appleton area.

BB
150 W Northland Ave
Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance serves the Appleton area and its surrounding Wisconsin communities, handling renters insurance policies for local tenants and landlords. It covers personal property protection and liability coverage for individuals living in apartments, condos, or rental homes throughout the region. The agency helps clients assess their belongings and potential risks to determine appropriate policy limits. For a typical job, it reviews the customer's lease agreement and specific personal inventory needs to structure a customized coverage plan.

SN
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency in Appleton, WI offers both one-time applications for immediate coverage and recurring policy management for ongoing protection. Renters insurance typically safeguards personal belongings against theft or damage and provides liability coverage for accidents within a rented home. Policies are designed to suit local apartment dwellers and homeowners looking for tenant protection. Service is available on an as-needed basis for clients requiring policy adjustments or new enrollment.

JH
4055 E Calumet St Ste D
Jordyn Hendzel - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Jordyn Hendzel - State Farm Insurance Agent is known for providing renters insurance policies tailored to the needs of local tenants in Appleton, WI. The agency covers a range of property protection, including personal belongings and liability coverage for residents in the area. A specialty service it can add on is identity theft protection, which helps safeguard personal information.

KH
3110 N Ballard Rd
Ken Heiner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Ken Heiner - State Farm Insurance Agent in Appleton, Wisconsin is known for helping individuals safeguard their personal belongings and liability. The agency provides tenant-specific policies that cover theft, fire damage, and loss of use. Policies can be customized to protect electronics, furniture, and other valuables within a rental unit. Deductible options are available to fit different renters’ financial situations. A specialty service this agent can offer is adding identity restoration coverage to a renters policy for comprehensive protection.

MH
2711 N Mason St
Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent in Appleton, Wisconsin provides residential renters insurance to local tenants protecting personal belongings and liability. Commercial coverage is also available for small business owners renting office or retail space. Service extends throughout the Appleton area and nearby communities. The agency specializes in helping renters understand policy details and adjust coverage as their needs change. Clients often return for annual policy reviews or when moving to a new rental property, ensuring continued protection between regular visits.

CI
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Comparion Insurance Agency serves Appleton and the surrounding Wisconsin area as a renters insurance agent. It helps tenants protect their personal belongings and provides liability coverage for accidents that occur in a rental property. The agency assists customers in finding policies that match their specific living situations, whether for apartments or single-family rentals. A standard renters policy with Comparion covers personal property loss from perils like fire or theft and extends liability protection for guest injuries on the premises.

AO
W6207 Aerotech Dr
Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton Claims
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton Claims provides renters insurance policies that cover personal property, liability protection, and additional living expenses. It also assists with filing new claims and managing ongoing service requests. The agency operates on a straightforward consultation model, helping customers understand their coverage options and adjust deductibles as needed. Its team processes claims efficiently and offers policy reviews to ensure adequate protection. This agent services single-family homes, apartments, retail shops, and restaurants throughout the Appleton area.

AW
1117 N Badger Ave ste e
Andy Wescott - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Andy Wescott - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners, renters, and landlords throughout the Appleton area. The agency focuses on helping tenants protect their personal belongings and liability with customized renters insurance policies. Staff members assist clients in understanding coverage for unexpected events such as theft, fire, or water damage. They also provide guidance on affordable deductibles and replacement cost options tailored to individual living situations. The agency extends its renters insurance services to neighboring communities around the Fox Cities metro, including the areas near Grand Chute.

MF
1400 N Rankin St
McHugh Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 364-9400
mchughfamilyins.com
RR
2405 S Oneida St
Ryan Renard - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 734-8331
ryanrenardinsurance.com
MH
3131 W Spencer St ste b
Michael Hyne American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 882-3838
amfam.com/agents/wisconsin/appleton/michael-hyne
PI
1011 N Lynndale Dr Ste 1B
Packerland Insurance Advisors
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 315-8412
askpackerland.com
MA
2500 N Richmond St
Monday and Associates, Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 306-6948
mondayandassociates.com
KH
1656 N Casaloma Dr
Kyle Hangartner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 268-1691
yourneighborkyle.com
DF
225 N Richmond St #106
Diedrich Family Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-7331
diedrichagency.com
VH
2500 N Richmond St
Van Handel Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-1440
vanhandelagency.com
TI
2100 S Kensington Dr #7
Total Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 731-3200
totalinsuranceappleton.com
HI
N365 Rogers Ln
Hurley Insurance Services
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 687-0687
erieinsurance.com
SI
421 W Northland Ave
Smart Insurance Agency WI
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 696-9714
SM
1407 N Lynndale Dr
Ste Marie Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 734-5868
ansay.com/advisor-directory/terri-tesch
MI
2835 W College Ave
Maurer Insurance Agency, LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 560-5800
maurer-insurance.com
KI
1000 W Wisconsin Ave #2
Koehn Insurance Agency, Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 739-7111
koehninsurance.com
BW
225 N Richmond St #106
Bob Walter Agency LLC: Diedrich Wendy
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-7331
diedrichagency.com/about
CI
611 N Lynndale Dr # 165
Calder Insurance Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 735-9191
calderinsuranceappletonwi.com

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Appleton Cost?

Renters insurance in Wisconsin typically costs between 12 and 20 dollars per month, or 150 to 250 dollars per year for a standard policy. Factors like your credit score, coverage limits, deductible amount, and location in Appleton can affect the premium. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Appleton

Renters insurance agents in Appleton, Wisconsin help tenants protect their personal property and liability. Wisconsin law does not require renters insurance, but many landlords in the Fox Cities area now include it as a lease condition. An agent can explain how Wisconsin statutes affect coverage limits and claim procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a renters insurance agent in Appleton do?

A renters insurance agent in Appleton helps you choose a policy that covers your belongings and liability. They explain Wisconsin-specific rules, such as the 12-month statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit after a claim denial. Agents also compare quotes from multiple insurers to find a plan that fits your budget.

Is renters insurance required by law in Appleton Wisconsin?

No, Wisconsin state law does not require renters insurance. However, many landlords in Appleton now require tenants to carry a policy as part of the lease agreement. An agent can help you meet that requirement with the right coverage.

How much personal property coverage do I need in Appleton?

The amount of personal property coverage you need depends on the total value of your belongings. A renters insurance agent can help you create a home inventory and estimate replacement costs. Typical policies in Wisconsin offer between 15,000 and 50,000 dollars in personal property coverage.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.