ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Cicero, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Cicero, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Cicero, New York is Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 784 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent, Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency, Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office). This directory lists 19 supplemental insurance agents serving Cicero.

Showing 19 supplemental insurance agents in Cicero, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent8131 Brewerton Rd(315) 699-8000
2Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent5720 S Bay Rd(315) 458-3255
3Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9516
4Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office)8261 Brewerton Rd(315) 752-5100
5Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent6257 NY-31 Ste 2(315) 699-2631
6Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9521
7Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9011
8Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 468-4000
9Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(518) 612-6095
10Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-3450
DT
8131 Brewerton Rd
Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Cicero, New York, area and surrounding Onondaga County as a supplemental insurance agent. The agency assists local residents by offering policies that cover expenses not addressed by primary health plans. These supplemental policies help fill gaps for medical costs and everyday living expenses during unexpected health events. Clients can find support for accident recovery and critical illness management through specific supplemental plans designed for this region.

MB
5720 S Bay Rd
Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent in Cicero, NY, offers a range of supplemental insurance products to address gaps in primary health coverage. This service area includes accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans that provide fixed cash benefits directly to policyholders. Policy maintenance and annual plan reviews are offered to ensure coverage continues to meet individual needs. The business works with a diverse clientele, regularly servicing single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants.

BK
7997 Brewerton Rd
Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Homeowners and small business owners in Cicero turn to Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency for supplemental insurance coverage that fills gaps in standard policies. This agency helps clients navigate options such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans, offering personal guidance through the selection process. Its services also support property managers seeking extra protection for rental units. The agency extends its supplemental insurance expertise to the surrounding communities of the greater Syracuse metro area such as North Syracuse.

TI
8261 Brewerton Rd
Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office)
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Serving Cicero, New York, and the surrounding communities, Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office) handles the sale of supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps left by major medical plans. This work involves explaining the nuances of accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage to local residents. When a client consults them, the agent first reviews their existing health coverage to identify potential financial exposures, then recommends specific supplemental plans tailored to those individual risks.

AC
6257 NY-31 Ste 2
Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent in Cicero, NY, distinguishes between one-time policies and recurring coverage options, the latter offering ongoing protection. Their work as a supplemental insurance agent includes policies that help fill gaps left by primary health plans, such as accident or hospital indemnity. This coverage provides funds for deductibles or unexpected medical costs. Service for this local office runs on an as-needed basis, responding to client inquiries for quotes, policy changes, or claims support. No appointments are required for these reactive services.

JS
7997 Brewerton Rd
Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency in Cicero specializes in offering supplemental insurance policies that help cover out-of-pocket costs traditional health plans may not fully address. This local agency provides dedicated service by guiding area residents through the various supplement options available to them, tailoring coverage to meet individual needs and budgets. As the cold and flu season arrives, the agency assists clients in understanding how supplemental plans can offset expenses from unexpected urgent care visits or prescription costs.

BS
7997 Brewerton Rd
Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

As the seasons shift in Cicero and residents review their Medicare or retirement coverage, local supplemental insurance agent Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency steps in to fill gaps in existing plans. This agency specializes in providing additional policies that address specific out-of-pocket costs and uncovered services. Each appointment begins with a careful inspection of the client’s current benefits and a clear assessment of their financial exposures, ensuring the first meeting produces a tailored initial-review document.

CI
7997 Brewerton Rd
Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Comparion Insurance Agency works to help individuals and businesses in Cicero, New York, address financial gaps through supplemental insurance coverage. This agency focuses on policies that provide added protection beyond standard health or life plans, such as accident, critical illness, or disability income options. Clients receive assistance in understanding how these add-ons can help manage unexpected costs. The agency can serve a range of commercial sectors, including local offices, warehouses, and food service operations needing tailored supplemental benefits for employees or operations.

CC
7997 Brewerton Rd
Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency works with clients to evaluate their existing coverage and identify potential gaps. This supplemental insurance agent specializes in offering additional policies that fill the areas not covered by primary health or life plans. Residents of Cicero and surrounding communities can explore options for accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity insurance here. The agency is equipped to serve a variety of commercial sectors, including professional offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

CJ
7997 Brewerton Rd
Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency serves clients in Cicero and the surrounding area with residential supplemental insurance solutions. The agency also offers commercial coverage options designed to fill gaps not addressed by standard health or property policies. Their work involves helping residents and business owners understand plans that cover deductibles, copays, or other out-of-pocket costs. After an initial consultation and policy setup, the team provides follow-up support and can adjust coverage between regular visits as needs change.

HI
5702 S Bay Rd
Heritage Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 925-5300
heritageagencies.com
KK
7997 Brewerton Rd
Katie King at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 792-7492
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/katie-king
PJ
5797 NY-31
Potter-Jones Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 699-2761
pjagency.com
CC
7997 Brewerton Rd
Charmaine Castle at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-0707
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/charmaine-castle
RT
7997 Brewerton Rd
Robert Thomas at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-0706
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/robert-thomas
SA
5700 S Bay Rd
Senior Advisory Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 668-5222
senioradvisoryinsurance.com
MD
8114 Brewerton Rd
The Michael Dey & Jon Taylor Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 944-6494
NI
5885 Cir Dr E Suite 155
Nationwide Insurance: Lance D Wiltse
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 452-3200
FA
8349 Brewerton Rd
Frey Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 288-5210
freyagency.net

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Cicero Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in Cicero vary by plan type, age, and health status. A Medigap Plan G in New York typically ranges from $120 to $250 per month for a 65-year-old. Cancer and accident plans may cost $30 to $80 per month. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Cicero

Supplemental insurance agents in Cicero, New York help residents fill gaps in their primary health coverage. New York law requires all Medicare supplement plans to be guaranteed issue for eligible beneficiaries during open enrollment periods. Local agents can guide you through Medigap, hospital indemnity, and critical illness policies tailored to your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Cicero?

A supplemental insurance agent in Cicero helps you buy policies that cover costs not paid by your main health insurance. These agents are licensed in New York and must follow state regulations on policy disclosures and sales practices.

What types of supplemental plans are available in New York?

Common supplemental plans in New York include Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental, vision, accident, cancer, and hospital indemnity policies. New York has standardized Medigap plans labeled A through N with fixed benefits.

Are there enrollment deadlines for supplemental insurance in New York?

Yes. For Medicare Supplement plans, you have a six-month open enrollment period starting when you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. Outside this window, insurers may use medical underwriting to decide coverage.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.