ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, PA

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Lancaster, Pennsylvania is HomeSale Insurance Services, rated 5.0 stars across 456 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bagnall Shaw Insurance, Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance, Susquehanna Insurance. This directory lists 27 supplemental insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 27 supplemental insurance agents in Lancaster, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1HomeSale Insurance Services215 S Centerville Rd Ste B(800) 425-5130
2Bagnall Shaw Insurance401 W Orange St(717) 431-8383
3Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance1729 Lititz Pike(717) 290-7290
4Susquehanna Insurance650 Delp Rd(717) 290-7780
5Red Rose Insurance100 S Queen St Ste 226(717) 690-0971
6Gebhard Insurance LLC90 Willow Valley Square(717) 930-2085
7Eagle One Insurance Agency2173 Embassy Dr—
8Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster617B N Prince St #200(717) 397-4729
9Acceptance Insurance454 N Prince St(717) 356-3320
10Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance705 Olde Hickory Rd(717) 560-9733
HI
215 S Centerville Rd Ste B
HomeSale Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

HomeSale Insurance Services serves the Lancaster, Pennsylvania area as a supplemental insurance agent. The company helps clients fill gaps in their existing health coverage by offering policies that pay cash benefits directly to the insured. These plans can assist with expenses not covered by major medical insurance, such as deductibles and copays. Services include helping individuals select hospital indemnity plans and cancer insurance policies that provide financial support during treatment.

BS
401 W Orange St
Bagnall Shaw Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Bagnall Shaw Insurance provides supplemental insurance solutions to help cover gaps in primary health coverage, including accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The company offers straightforward policy management with clear explanations of benefits and claims assistance to ensure clients understand their coverage. This Lancaster agency works with individuals and families throughout the local area. It serves a range of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail stores, and restaurants needing employee and life-protection policies.

FI
1729 Lititz Pike
Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance serves homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, by providing supplemental insurance policies that cover gaps left by standard plans. These plans can help with deductibles, copays, or unexpected losses not covered by primary coverage. Supplemental agents in this area often assist clients in tailoring protection to their specific property or operational risks. The agency also extends its services to clients in nearby Lititz, York, and other communities within the Lancaster metropolitan region.

SI
650 Delp Rd
Susquehanna Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Susquehanna Insurance serves individuals and families in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance needs that fill gaps left by major medical plans. This type of coverage typically addresses costs such as deductibles, copays, and everyday expenses during treatment. For each client, the agency begins with a personal review of existing health policies to identify specific coverage gaps. It then recommends appropriate supplemental plans that align with individual budgets and healthcare usage patterns to complete the overall protection strategy.

RR
100 S Queen St Ste 226
Red Rose Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Red Rose Insurance offers both one-time and scheduled service options for residents of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, focusing on supplemental insurance policies that help cover gaps in primary health coverage. These plans can address unexpected medical costs, such as deductibles, copays, or extended hospital stays. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company assists clients in selecting appropriate plans based on individual needs. Support is available through flexible service arrangements that operate on either a one-time consultation basis or as regularly scheduled reviews, depending on client preference.

GI
90 Willow Valley Square
Gebhard Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

As the leaves change in Lancaster, PA, residents often review their coverage for gaps that Medicare or other primary plans leave. Gebhard Insurance LLC serves as a local supplemental insurance agent in the area. Their role helps clients explore options that cover expenses such as copays or extended care needs not included by standard policies. They typically begin by reviewing a brief initial assessment of an individual’s current plan during a no-obligation meeting in their local office.

EO
2173 Embassy Dr
Eagle One Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
EI
617B N Prince St #200
Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Element Insurance Agency - Lancaster provides specialty supplemental insurance policies, including accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage, and also serves clients with general gap protection and benefit coordination services. It supports individuals and families in Lancaster by helping manage out-of-pocket medical expenses not covered by primary health plans. During tax refund season or after a significant seasonal procedure, the agency helps ensure policyholders can access funds to address sudden financial gaps from deductibles or deductoffs.

AI
454 N Prince St
Acceptance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Acceptance Insurance in York, PA assists with supplemental insurance, distinguishing between one-time policy applications for specific coverage periods and recurring service options that provide ongoing protection. Supplemental agents here help bridge gaps in primary health plans by offering tailored coverage for unexpected medical costs or income loss during recovery. Clients may choose between a single policy purchase and scheduled plan updates that align with changing needs. Service for supplemented policies typically runs on either a one-time or scheduled basis.

HI
705 Olde Hickory Rd
Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance provides supplemental insurance to residents in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Their services extend to offering commercial coverage policies for local business owners operating in the surrounding area. Catastrophic illness policies, accident plans, and hospital indemnity coverage can help bridge gaps left by a primary health plan. Employees strive to offer clear explanations of policy terms during the initial meeting. Clients can contact the office easily when their needs change, ensuring coverage remains consistent between their regular medical visits.

EI
1857 William Penn Way
EHD Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 394-5681
ehdinsurance.com
DI
2127 New Holland Pike
DeverCare Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 392-6888
devercare.com
SS
9 Meadow Ln
Senior Solutions of PA
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 824-4719
seniorsolutionsofpa.com
BG
2101 Oregon Pike # 300
BCF Group Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-7730
bcfgroup.net
CI
101 Good Dr floor 2
Community Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-7531
communitysure.com
AB
2173 Embassy Dr Suite 352
Absolute Best Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 736-3388
absolutebestins.com
IS
1394 Harrisburg Pike
Insurance Services LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 869-4893
myinsuranceteam.com
HA
Warehouse D, 342 N Queen St
PA Health Advocates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 400-1244
pahealthadvocates.com
RI
320 Granite Run Dr
Ruhl Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 665-2283
iruhl.com
JM
2860 Harrisburg Pike
Julie Meyers Insurance Solutions
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 435-4000
meyersins.com
HD
2350 Lincoln Hwy E
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-1972
highmarkdirect.com
NT
2250 Erin Ct
ntiDirectCare
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 619-8110
ntidirectcare.net
KA
202 Butler Ave #103
Karpinski & Associates Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 295-7088
karpinskiassociates.com
MU
39 N Duke St
Murray
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-9600
assuredpartners.com/lancaster
HI
320 Granite Run Dr Suite 201
Horst Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-1919
horstinsurance.com
CH
247 Black Oak Dr
Customized Health/Life Insurance Plans
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 341-6666
askchlip.com
SA
2231 Dutch Gold Dr
Spoonhour Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 553-0444
spoonhourinsurance.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Pennsylvania vary by plan type age and carrier. Medigap Plan G premiums for a 65-year-old in Lancaster typically range from 120 to 200 dollars per month. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but may have copays and network limits. Costs depend on your specific needs and location. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Lancaster

Supplemental insurance agents in Lancaster Pennsylvania help residents find policies that cover gaps in Medicare or employer health plans. Pennsylvania law allows a six-month open enrollment period for Medigap plans starting when you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. Local agents can explain how state regulations affect your coverage options and costs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Lancaster?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you buy policies like Medigap Medicare Supplement or accident plans. These agents are licensed in Pennsylvania and can compare plans from multiple carriers for you.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Pennsylvania?

You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that begins when you are 65 or older and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage due to health conditions.

Do Pennsylvania laws protect my right to buy supplemental insurance?

Yes Pennsylvania has guaranteed issue rights for Medigap in certain situations like losing employer coverage. You also have a 30-day free look period to cancel a new policy for a full refund.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.