ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Pittsburgh, PA

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania is MediConnect Insurance, rated 4.9 stars across 2,302 reviews. Other highly rated options include SteelKey Insurance LLC, Matthew Langford - State Farm Insurance Agent, Sharp Insurance Agency, LLC. This directory lists 75 supplemental insurance agents serving Pittsburgh.

Showing 75 supplemental insurance agents in Pittsburgh, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1MediConnect Insurance300 Bilmar Dr #200(888) 818-6334
2SteelKey Insurance LLC134 Three Degree Rd(412) 408-4002
3Matthew Langford - State Farm Insurance Agent2818 Golden Mile Hwy(724) 327-3227
4Sharp Insurance Agency, LLC3019 Brownsville Rd FLR 1(412) 207-9047
5Murray Insurance Services1565 McFarland Rd(412) 561-1600
6Madia Insurance Agency Inc9370 McKnight Rd #300a(412) 367-9200
7McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance4175 Steubenville Pike(412) 444-4470
8Feldman Brothers Company, Inc./Marc Schermer, Broker206 St Charles Pl(412) 855-4828
9Jacoby & Associates Agency LLC1000 Main St(412) 781-2382
10Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency201 S Highland Ave Suite 303(412) 586-7340
MI
300 Bilmar Dr #200
MediConnect Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

MediConnect Insurance serves Pittsburgh and Allegheny County as a licensed supplemental insurance agent. It helps local residents navigate gap coverage to manage out-of-pocket medical costs not paid by major health plans. The agency focuses on clarifying plan details and claims processes so clients understand exactly what their Medicare Supplement or hospital indemnity policies will and will not cover. It facilitates enrollment in dental and vision supplemental plans while also addressing specific short-term needs like accident coverage for active individuals.

SI
134 Three Degree Rd
SteelKey Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

SteelKey Insurance LLC serves as a supplemental insurance agent in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, offering a range of ancillary coverage options for individuals and businesses. Services typically include accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity, and dental or vision plans designed to fill gaps in primary health policies. The agency works with clients to evaluate existing coverage, explain supplemental products, and assist with enrollment and claims support. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants throughout the Pittsburgh area.

ML
2818 Golden Mile Hwy
Matthew Langford - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

Matthew Langford operates as a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, focusing on policies that fill coverage gaps left by primary health plans. The agency provides assistance with accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity options to help manage out-of-pocket expenses. Serving the local community, it guides clients through plan details and claims processes to support financial preparedness. As winter approaches, this business can help evaluate coverage needs related to seasonal injuries or unexpected cold-weather health events.

SI
3019 Brownsville Rd FLR 1
Sharp Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

With the shifting seasons in Pittsburgh bringing new health considerations, Sharp Insurance Agency, LLC helps residents address coverage gaps that Medicare or employer plans may leave unfilled. As a local Supplemental Insurance Agent, the company focuses on explaining policies that can cover out-of-pocket costs like deductibles and copays. Their straightforward guidance aims to clarify individual options rather than present every possible plan. Before any recommendation, the agency conducts a personal coverage assessment to review the client’s current benefits and specific healthcare needs.

MI
1565 McFarland Rd
Murray Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

Murray Insurance Services offers residential supplemental insurance coverage to clients throughout Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and also provides commercial policies for local businesses in the area. Their brokers assess each policyholder’s existing health plan and identify gaps in Medicare, dental, or life insurance benefits. The agency serves neighborhoods across Allegheny County and surrounding communities, scheduling appointments to review policy options at clients’ homes or offices. After an initial enrollment, they remain available for follow-up service, assisting with claims questions and policy renewals between annual open enrollment periods.

MI
9370 McKnight Rd #300a
Madia Insurance Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

Madia Insurance Agency Inc in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, is known for providing supplemental insurance coverage that addresses gaps in standard health plans. It serves individuals and families throughout the region, helping them secure financial protection for unexpected medical costs. Its service range includes evaluating client needs and offering products such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity policies. A specialty service it can add on is dental and vision insurance for comprehensive everyday care.

MB
4175 Steubenville Pike
McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance serves the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. The company assists individuals with selecting policies that address coverage gaps not filled by primary health insurance. These plans help manage out-of-pocket costs for medical events, accidents, and critical illnesses. Supplemental coverage in this region frequently considers Medicare gaps or employer plan limitations. McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance guides clients through options for hospital indemnity or accident-specific policies to provide additional financial protection during unforeseen medical situations.

FB
206 St Charles Pl
Feldman Brothers Company, Inc./Marc Schermer, Broker
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

Serving homeowners, businesses, and property managers in the greater Pittsburgh area, Feldman Brothers Company, Inc./Marc Schermer, Broker provides supplemental insurance policies that help cover costs not included in standard plans. This brokerage assists clients in selecting additional coverage to protect against gaps in existing insurance. Its services address the specific financial exposures that private and commercial property owners often face. The firm also serves clients in Allegheny County and neighboring communities like Fox Chapel.

JA
1000 Main St
Jacoby & Associates Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA

Jacoby & Associates Agency LLC offers a range of supplemental insurance services in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, including gap coverage for health plans and policies tailored to out-of-pocket medical expenses. The agency assists clients with routine policy reviews and adjustments to ensure ongoing coverage meets changing needs. It also helps navigate claims filing and policy updates for existing plans. Its services apply to single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

PG
201 S Highland Ave Suite 303
Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
NI
704 McKnight Park Dr
Nationwide Insurance: William G Neofes Jr
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 364-3388
agency.nationwide.com/pa/pittsburgh/15237/neofes-insurance-group-llc
NI
915 Saxonburg Blvd # 217
National Insurance Markets
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 782-1979
nimbroker.com
MI
5624 Brownsville Rd Second Floor
McElhinny Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 650-5700
mcelhinny.com
JL
304 Cochran Rd
James L Smith Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 531-3111
jlsins.net
HH
1000 Gamma Dr 4th Floor
Howard Hanna Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 696-0310
howardhanna.com/Insurance
AP
4790 McKnight Rd
AAA Pittsburgh Insurance and Member Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 367-7600
ace.aaa.com/locations/Pittsburgh-15237-21554
DL
3403 Saw Mill Run Blvd
Dott-Leavitt Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 927-2400
leavitt.com/dott
HI
21 Yost Blvd
The Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 349-8818
getyourbestplan.com
BI
213 Smithfield St suite 216
Brown Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 681-7114
brown4insurance.com
TR
400 Penn Center Blvd # 110
T Rankin - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 795-5500
trankinins.com
LI
151 Roessler Rd Suite 800
Liberty Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 571-5700
libertyins.com
BB
8101 Perry Hwy #105
B&B Benefits
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 366-6334
bb-benefits.com
CA
110 Roessler Rd #200c
Christie & Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 563-7828
christie-associates.com
JS
156 Perry Hwy
J.S. Smith Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 931-6070
jssmithinsurance.com
DR
3201 McKnight E Dr
DaDao Risk Solutions 大道保险 匹兹堡华人保险经纪公司
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 472-8877
dadaosolutions.com
DP
665 Rodi Rd #102
Don Panigall ChFC - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 795-7400
donpanigall.com
KS
975 Greentree Rd
Kirk Shaler Agency: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 937-5500
agents.allstate.com/kirk-shaler-agency-pittsburgh-pa.html
CI
982 Perry Hwy Suite A
Coleman Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 366-9465
colemanautoinsurance.com
AI
11639 Penn Hills Dr
Acceptance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 230-3364
locations.acceptance.com/pittsburgh-insurance-pennsylvania-15235
FI
665 Rodi Rd
Fedele Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 244-1000
fedeleinsurance.com
DD
124 Ingram Ave
Dunn Dimond Insurance Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 922-1126
dd-insure.com
CI
611 Mt Royal Blvd
Casper Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 486-9200
casperinsurance.com
FP
2514 Wylie Ave
A For The People Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 621-5581
aforthepeople.com
CI
178 Clairton Blvd
Cusumano Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 655-4432
cusumanoinsurance.com
DP
8006 Broadlawn Dr
Diversified Plan Services Inc - Mildred Moschel RHU
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 366-8055
SI
2550 Boyce Plaza Rd
Stalwart Insurance, LLC - HQ
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 677-2312
stalwartinsurance.com
WI
201 Penn Center Blvd #105
Wentroble Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 373-4500
wentroble.com
TZ
2516 Washington Rd
Tony Zuback Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 833-5100
zubackinsurance.com
WI
770 Pine Valley Dr
Weisser Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 733-3735
weisserinsurance.com
MI
1719 Ardmore Blvd
Masters Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 351-2448
masters-insurance.com
BR
2516 Washington Rd
Brian Ruscello Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 941-8602
ruscelloagency.com
WA
5020 Centre Ave
Wagner Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 681-2700
wagneragency.com
IC
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd # 205A
Insurance Consultants Of Pittsburgh
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 344-2800
icpitt.com
KA
421 Cochran Rd
Kartsonas Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 563-5900
erieinsurance.com/agencies/pa/pittsburgh/aa5134
SI
1811 Golden Mile Hwy
Shanahan Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 229-8423
shanahan-insurance.com
PI
470 Streets Run Rd # 205
Professional Insurance PA
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(720) 776-0684
LI
453 Davidson Rd a5
LM Insurance Agency: Agents Edward Lehman & Michael Medure
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 357-2906
lminsuranceagency.com
PF
201 Penn Center Blvd Suite 400A
Paul A Fisher Insurance Services, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 519-7503
paulfisherinsurancepgh.com
DJ
12806 Frankstown Rd
D Johnson Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 744-4800
djohnsoninsurance.net
KI
700 River Ave #433
Kelly Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 212-2800
kellyinsurancegroup.com
DI
600 Parkway Center Dr S
DK Insurance Co
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 274-0642
hirokodambrosi2594.wixsite.com/dk-insurance-co
GR
340 Siebert Rd
George A Reed Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 367-4880
reedagency.net
JD
7890 Saltsburg Rd
Jaci Dolhi Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 798-4244
dolhiagency.com
IM
300 Bilmar Dr #240
Insure Me Josh
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 288-8355
insuremejosh.com
JV
9800B McKnight Rd Ste 226
Joe Vojtas Agency - ERIE Insurance Pittsburgh
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 847-3743
vojtasinsurance.com
WH
2581 Washington Rd Suite 230-K
Wind Harbor Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 743-9463
windharbor.com
HD
4885 McKnight Rd
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 544-5400
highmarkdirect.com
HD
1775 N Highland Rd
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 544-5267
highmarkdirect.com
CA
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd #316
The Clare Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 563-7511
clareagencyinc.com
CI
3336 Maple Dr
C&K Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 536-3096
myckinsurance.com
UI
400 Penn Center Blvd # 311
United Insurance Co of America
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 825-0999
MS
650 Washington Rd #200
Medicare Specialists of Pittsburgh
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 343-0344
medipgh.com
AM
427 S Meadowcroft Ave
Arick Martin Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 908-0708
arickmartin.com
HI
3333 Babcock Blvd Unit 2
HealthMarkets Insurance - Todd Titsworth
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 275-6570
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/ttitsworth
PN
500 Penn Center Blvd
Penn National Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 247-4556
BL
500 Penn Center Blvd Ste 300
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 871-2000
branches.bankerslife.com/pa/pittsburgh/500-penn-center-blvd
PS
321 Castle Shannon Blvd
Pierson & Scott Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 835-5660
piersonandscott.com
SI
300 Bilmar Dr
Senior Insurance Consultants
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 453-5067
seniorinsuranceconsultants.net
DA
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd #311
D'Alessandro and Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 344-2500
dalessandroassoc.com
SS
1220 Mayview Rd
Single Source Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 220-0300
singlesourcebenefits.com/contact.php
TK
1121 Boyce Rd
Thomas & Kelbro Insurance Services, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(724) 942-2400
EH
305 Mt Lebanon Blvd Suite 215
Erin Hart Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 657-3028
erinhartinsurance.com
SA
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd # 307
The Selario Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 344-6210
selarioagency.com
KA
Pittsburgh, PA 15238
Karas Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 406-7187
karasagency.net
HI
3333 Babcock Blvd Unit 2
HealthMarkets Insurance - Scott Aguglia
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pittsburgh, PA
(352) 574-3441
healthmarkets.com/saguglia

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Pittsburgh Cost?

The cost of a supplemental insurance agent in Pittsburgh is typically paid through commissions from the insurance company so you do not pay a separate fee. Medigap Plan G premiums for a 65-year-old in Pennsylvania range from about 100 to 250 dollars per month depending on the carrier and your location. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but may have higher out-of-pocket costs. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Pittsburgh

Supplemental insurance agents in Pittsburgh help residents choose plans that cover costs not paid by original Medicare or employer insurance. Pennsylvania law requires Medigap policies to be guaranteed issue for eligible beneficiaries during open enrollment. Agents can explain how state regulations affect plan options and pricing in Allegheny County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Pittsburgh?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you buy private plans like Medigap Medicare Advantage or dental coverage. These plans pay for expenses that original Medicare does not cover such as copays deductibles and coinsurance.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Pennsylvania?

You have a six-month open enrollment period starting when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. Pennsylvania also offers a birthday rule allowing you to switch plans within 60 days of your birthday.

Does Pennsylvania require agents to be licensed?

Yes all supplemental insurance agents in Pennsylvania must hold a valid insurance license from the Pennsylvania Insurance Department. You can verify an agents license on the department website before purchasing a policy.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.