ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in York, PA

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving York, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in York, Pennsylvania is William Penn Insurance, LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 1,123 reviews. Other highly rated options include McMillan Insurance Agency, Sal Castro - State Farm Insurance Agent, Peiffer Insurance. This directory lists 30 supplemental insurance agents serving York.

Showing 30 supplemental insurance agents in York, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1William Penn Insurance, LLC1120 Roosevelt Ave Suite A(717) 900-8658
2McMillan Insurance Agency2343 S Queen St(717) 850-0503
3Sal Castro - State Farm Insurance Agent2206 S Queen St(717) 741-2200
4Peiffer Insurance2220 E Market St(717) 854-6004
5Trish Howser - State Farm Insurance Agent1865 N Susquehanna Trail(717) 848-4336
6Acceptance Insurance970 Loucks Rd G(717) 358-2393
7AAdvantage Insurance Group, Inc.1830 E Market St(717) 913-8091
8Milestone Insurance Agency215 N Main St Ste 3(717) 851-8010
9Nicholas Insurance Solutions1550 Kenneth Rd Suite 5(717) 764-2477
10Dietz & Bluett Insurance2000 S Queen St(717) 757-2761
WP
1120 Roosevelt Ave Suite A
William Penn Insurance, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

William Penn Insurance, LLC serves York, Pennsylvania, providing supplemental insurance options that help cover the costs not paid by major medical plans. These plans bridge gaps in traditional coverage, offering financial protection for unexpected health expenses. Policies include accident and critical illness insurance, which pay fixed cash benefits directly to the policyholder. Such support assists individuals and families with deductibles or lost income during recovery. The agency handles hospital indemnity plans and short-term disability coverage for local residents.

MI
2343 S Queen St
McMillan Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

McMillan Insurance Agency in York, PA offers a range of supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps left by primary health plans. Its ongoing service includes personalized policy reviews and claims assistance to help clients manage coverage changes. The agency maintains clear communication, ensuring policyholders understand their benefits and options. It serves individuals with supplemental plans for medical, accident, and hospital needs. The agency provide policies for single-family homes, apartments, retail operations, and restaurants.

SC
2206 S Queen St
Sal Castro - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Sal Castro, a local supplemental insurance agent in York, PA, serves homeowners and businesses seeking extra coverage to fill gaps in their primary policies. The agency helps clients explore options such as accident, hospital, and disability supplemental plans designed to provide additional financial protection. By working alongside existing health or property insurance, these policies offer a layer of support for unexpected expenses. Sal Castro’s office also serves the surrounding York County communities, including Hellam, and parts of the Red Lion area beyond the city limits.

PI
2220 E Market St
Peiffer Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Serving York, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding communities, Peiffer Insurance focuses on supplemental insurance coverage. It helps individuals and families address gaps in primary health plans by offering policies designed for specific needs. Agents work to clarify coverage options and costs for potential clients. They explain how supplemental plans can assist with out-of-pocket expenses not covered by major medical insurance. The company generally begins each job by reviewing a client's existing coverage and personal healthcare concerns, then presents tailored policy choices to match their individual financial and medical situation.

TH
1865 N Susquehanna Trail
Trish Howser - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Trish Howser - State Farm Insurance Agent in York, PA, offers supplemental insurance policies that cover expenses beyond primary health plans, including accident and critical illness options for local residents. The agency also assists clients with standard insurance products to protect their homes and vehicles. Approaching the winter season, it helps individuals address gaps in coverage that can arise from seasonal illnesses or unexpected injuries during outdoor activities like shoveling and skiing.

AI
970 Loucks Rd G
Acceptance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Acceptance Insurance in York, PA assists with supplemental insurance, distinguishing between one-time policy applications for specific coverage periods and recurring service options that provide ongoing protection. Supplemental agents here help bridge gaps in primary health plans by offering tailored coverage for unexpected medical costs or income loss during recovery. Clients may choose between a single policy purchase and scheduled plan updates that align with changing needs. Service for supplemented policies typically runs on either a one-time or scheduled basis.

AI
1830 E Market St
AAdvantage Insurance Group, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

As the seasons change in York, PA, residents often find themselves reviewing their existing health coverage and considering gaps that standard plans may leave. AAdvantage Insurance Group, Inc. serves as a supplemental insurance agent, offering policies that help cover out-of-pocket expenses such as deductibles and copays. These plans can provide financial support during unexpected medical events or hospital stays. Their process typically begins with a no-obligation assessment of an individual’s current coverage to identify potential gaps, which is completed during an in-person or phone consultation with a local agent.

MI
215 N Main St Ste 3
Milestone Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Milestone Insurance Agency in York, PA, connects individuals and businesses with supplemental insurance policies that fill gaps in primary coverage. It specializes in offering add-on plans for specific needs like accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity. These policies provide direct cash benefits to policyholders during unexpected health events. The agency serves a range of commercial sectors, including professional offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

NI
1550 Kenneth Rd Suite 5
Nicholas Insurance Solutions
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
DB
2000 S Queen St
Dietz & Bluett Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA

Dietz & Bluett Insurance provides supplemental insurance coverage to residential clients in York, Pennsylvania, with additional policies available for commercial customers throughout the local area. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company helps individuals and businesses fill gaps left by primary health or life plans. Follow-up service is provided between regular visits to ensure coverage remains appropriate and any changes are addressed promptly.

CI
1940 Carlisle Rd
Covenant Insurance Group Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 292-2028
covenantcares.com
BI
150 Farm Ln 2nd Floor
Basile Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 792-6400
insuranceyork.net
AP
303 E Market St
Asset Protectors, LLC.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 699-2336
assetprotectorspa.com
KI
3217 E Market St
Kocman Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 854-0300
kigyork.com
KI
2811 E Prospect Rd Suite 12
Kearse Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 718-1390
kearseins.com
GI
1801 E Market St
Guerrini Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 755-2886
guerrini.net
CB
303 E Market St
Community Benefits Solutions, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 818-1827
communitybenefitssolutions.com
IS
123 E Market St Fl 3F
Insurance Services United
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 854-4043
insuranceservicesunited.com
KB
43 W King St
Kling Bros. Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 854-7851
klingbros.com
KI
35-37 W Philadelphia St
KE Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 204-4961
libbyohlund1134424.wixsite.com/-ke-insurance
GS
2527 S Queen St
Gentzler & Smith Associates Insurance and Financial Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 741-0965
gentzlersmith.com
CI
3621 E Market St
Covenant Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 755-2755
covenantcares.com
MI
303 Arsenal Rd
MED INSURANCE
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
saarapecor4433691.wixsite.com/med-insurance
JB
2615 W Market St
Joe Bonene Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 792-0914
joeboneneinsurance.com
PG
1041 S Queen St
The Patton Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 812-1982
thepattongroup.biz
TG
183 Leader Heights Rd
TGA - The Glatfelter Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 852-8000
tga-ins.com
RF
2350 North Point Dr
Ridinger Financial Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 848-1500
ridingerfinancial.com
CA
303 E Market St
Central PA Advisors, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 699-2335
centralpaadvisors.com
LF
1115 Futurity Dr
Litten Financial Group, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 845-5511
littenfinancial.com
HI
1200 W Princess St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Jerrica Wilkins
Supplemental Insurance Agent · York, PA
(717) 476-1690
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/jerricawatson

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in York Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Pennsylvania vary by plan type age and location. Medigap Plan G premiums in York typically range from 100 to 250 dollars per month. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but include copays and deductibles. Costs also depend on the insurance company and whether you use tobacco. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in York

Supplemental insurance agents in York Pennsylvania help residents choose Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans that cover gaps in Original Medicare. Pennsylvania law guarantees a six-month open enrollment period for Medigap when you turn 65. Local agents can explain how state rules affect your coverage options and premiums.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best time to buy a Medigap policy in York Pennsylvania?

The best time is during your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period which starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage or charged more for pre-existing conditions. After this period insurers may use medical underwriting.

Can a supplemental insurance agent in York help with Medicare Advantage plans?

Yes many agents are licensed to sell both Medigap and Medicare Advantage plans. They can compare plan costs provider networks and out-of-pocket limits. Pennsylvania allows Medicare Advantage plans to offer extra benefits like dental and vision.

Are there special rules for Medigap in Pennsylvania?

Yes Pennsylvania has a birthday rule that gives you 60 days after your birthday to switch to a Medigap plan with equal or lesser benefits without medical underwriting. This applies only if you already have a Medigap policy. Agents can explain how this rule works for York residents.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.