ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Appleton, WI

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Appleton, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Appleton, Wisconsin is Thiel Insurance Group, LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 783 reviews. Other highly rated options include 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin, Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency, MIB Health Insurance. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Appleton.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Appleton, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Thiel Insurance Group, LLC620 N Richmond St(920) 739-6241
25 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin119 N McCarthy Rd suite g(920) 831-3210
3Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400(920) 931-3693
4MIB Health Insurance5733 W Packard St(920) 731-2100
5Comparion Insurance Agency2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400(920) 749-9799
6Ulness Health Insurance Agents214 N Superior St(920) 735-2852
7McHugh Family Insurance1400 N Rankin St(920) 364-9400
8Packerland Insurance Advisors1011 N Lynndale Dr Ste 1B(920) 315-8412
9Monday and Associates, Inc.2500 N Richmond St(920) 306-6948
10Medicare Masters & Anchor Health Insurance1500 N Casaloma Dr # 411(920) 882-1307
TI
620 N Richmond St
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC serves the Appleton and greater Outagamie County area as a supplemental insurance agent. It helps clients bridge gaps in primary health coverage by offering policies that cover additional out-of-pocket costs not paid by standard medical plans. The agency focuses on simplifying complex insurance options for local residents, ensuring they understand what each policy covers. Its services commonly include handling Medicare supplement plans and providing accident or critical illness insurance to individuals and families.

5S
119 N McCarthy Rd suite g
5 Star Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton, Wisconsin
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

5 Star Insurance Group, LLC, located in Appleton, Wisconsin, offers supplemental insurance agent services designed to close gaps in primary coverage for local residents and businesses. Its service approach involves assessing individual needs for policies such as accident, cancer, or disability income protection, then helping clients plan for out-of-pocket expenses not covered by major medical insurance. The company services a range of property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

SN
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Homeowners, property managers, and small business owners in the Appleton area rely on Stuart Ninabuck at Comparion Insurance Agency for supplemental insurance designed to fill gaps in standard coverage. The agency helps clients secure policies that address specific risks not covered by primary plans, offering more comprehensive financial protection. Stuart serves Appleton and consistently covers the broader Fox Cities metropolitan region, including Neenah and Menasha.

MH
5733 W Packard St
MIB Health Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

MIB Health Insurance serves the Appleton, Wisconsin area and surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance plans that help cover expenses not paid by major medical policies. It assists clients in addressing gaps for services like dental, vision, or critical illness coverage. For a typical job, the agency first reviews a client's existing health coverage and then compares available supplemental options to find a suitable match for both needs and budget.

CI
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Comparion Insurance Agency in Appleton, Wisconsin offers both one-time policy enrollments and recurring service options for supplemental insurance needs. Agents guide clients through coverage for gaps in primary health, dental, or life insurance. Each consultation focuses on selecting plans that fit individual circumstances and budgets. A key distinction is that agents provide ongoing support for policy questions or claims assistance rather than a single transaction. Service operates on both a scheduled follow-up and as-needed basis for renewals or plan adjustments.

UH
214 N Superior St
Ulness Health Insurance Agents
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

As Wisconsin approaches another unpredictable season, homeowners in Appleton often look for ways to fill gaps in their existing health coverage. Ulness Health Insurance Agents provides supplemental insurance to help cover deductibles, copays, and unexpected out-of-pocket costs that primary plans may leave behind. Their focus is on policies designed for local residents who want more predictable expenses. An initial appointment with an agent reviews current coverage and identifies any missing protections.

MF
1400 N Rankin St
McHugh Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

McHugh Family Insurance in Appleton, Wisconsin provides supplemental insurance policies that cover gaps left by major medical plans, assisting clients with specific needs such as accident, cancer, or critical illness coverage. It also offers general supplemental services designed to help individuals manage out-of-pocket costs and lost income during health events. For local residents approaching Medicare enrollment, this agency helps clarify plan choices during the annual fall open enrollment period.

PI
1011 N Lynndale Dr Ste 1B
Packerland Insurance Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Packerland Insurance Advisors in Appleton, WI is known for helping individuals fill coverage gaps left by major health plans through supplemental insurance policies. Its services include enrolling clients in plans that provide direct cash benefits for unexpected medical events, accidents, or critical illnesses. The agency also serves local residents seeking to manage out-of-pocket costs. A specialty service the company can add on is offering hospital indemnity plans that pay a fixed amount for each day of inpatient care.

MA
2500 N Richmond St
Monday and Associates, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Monday and Associates, Inc., in Appleton, Wisconsin, focuses on supplemental insurance policies that fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans. The agency offers specialized add-ons like accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans to provide financial protection for unexpected health events. Local businesses in the area may find these supplemental options helpful for their workforce, including those in office environments, warehouses, and food service establishments.

MM
1500 N Casaloma Dr # 411
Medicare Masters & Anchor Health Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Serving residents of Appleton, Wisconsin with supplemental insurance plans, Medicare Masters & Anchor Health Insurance helps individuals navigate their coverage needs. Commercial clients in the area also receive support for their supplemental insurance requirements. The agency provides guidance throughout the entire selection process, ensuring clients understand their options. After enrolling a plan, the team offers follow-up assistance during policy changes or annual review periods, providing repeat service between regular visits to address any new questions or adjustments.

DF
225 N Richmond St #106
Diedrich Family Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-7331
diedrichagency.com
VH
2500 N Richmond St
Van Handel Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-1440
vanhandelagency.com
KC
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Kevin Collins at Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 931-3688
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/wisconsin/appleton-0457/kevin-collins
TI
2100 S Kensington Dr #7
Total Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 731-3200
totalinsuranceappleton.com
JB
4321 W College Ave # 385
JMS Brokerage Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 739-5181
jmsbrokerage.com
HI
N365 Rogers Ln
Hurley Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 687-0687
erieinsurance.com
AA
4351 W College Ave
Ansay & Associates, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 560-7000
ansay.com
SI
421 W Northland Ave
Smart Insurance Agency WI
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 696-9714
SI
3030 N Richmond St
Sassman Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 993-9750
sassmaninsurance.agency
BW
225 N Richmond St #106
Bob Walter Agency LLC: Diedrich Wendy
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-7331
diedrichagency.com/about

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Appleton Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Wisconsin vary by plan type age and carrier. A Medigap Plan G in Appleton typically ranges from 120 to 250 dollars per month for a 65 year old. Plan N may cost 90 to 180 dollars per month. Rates can increase over time due to inflation or insurer adjustments. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Appleton

Supplemental insurance agents in Appleton Wisconsin help residents choose Medigap or other gap coverage plans. Wisconsin state law requires Medigap insurers to offer guaranteed issue rights during open enrollment and in certain qualifying events. These agents can explain how Wisconsin standardized plans like Basic and Extended work for your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Appleton?

A supplemental insurance agent in Appleton helps you buy policies that cover costs not paid by original Medicare or other primary insurance. They can explain Wisconsin specific Medigap plan options and help you compare carriers.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin you have a six month Medigap open enrollment period starting the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. After that you may face health questions or higher rates.

Are there Wisconsin laws that protect Medigap buyers?

Yes Wisconsin law provides a free look period of 30 days to cancel a Medigap policy for a full refund. Also insurers cannot deny coverage or charge higher premiums for certain qualifying events like losing employer coverage. These protections are in Wisconsin Statutes Chapter 632.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.