ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsColorado › Fort Collins

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Fort Collins, CO

Browse auto insurance agents serving Fort Collins, Colorado. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Fort Collins, Colorado is Marinda Simpson - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 661 reviews. Other highly rated options include Fort Collins Insurance, Ben Parsons - State Farm Insurance Agent, IMA Select. This directory lists 23 auto insurance agents serving Fort Collins.

Showing 23 auto insurance agents in Fort Collins, COListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Marinda Simpson - State Farm Insurance Agent2601 S Lemay Ave Ste 36(970) 223-7800
2Fort Collins Insurance4025 Automation Way E3(970) 204-4553
3Ben Parsons - State Farm Insurance Agent2121 Midpoint Dr #301a(970) 484-3600
4IMA Select3500 John F Kennedy Pkwy Suite 205(970) 204-0044
5Michael Martinez - GEICO Insurance Agent1075 W Horsetooth Rd unit 202(970) 221-5230
6Gwen Brooks - State Farm Insurance Agent4605 Ziegler Rd(970) 226-1306
7Agate Insurance145 N College Ave Suite B(970) 682-1758
8Erin LeVan - State Farm Insurance Agent140 Boardwalk Dr UNIT E(970) 372-2919
9Cristina Walston American Family Insurance2020 S College Ave UNIT A3(970) 229-9393
10Shanti Insurance Services19 Old Town Square(970) 834-3668
MS
2601 S Lemay Ave Ste 36
Marinda Simpson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

Marinda Simpson - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Fort Collins, Colorado metro area, specializing in auto insurance policies to protect local drivers. The agency helps clients navigate coverage options, liability limits, and deductible choices tailored to individual needs. Policyholders receive guidance on bundling auto coverage with other insurance products for potential savings. Additional services provided include adding roadside assistance or rental car reimbursement to policies, ensuring drivers have support on the road.

FC
4025 Automation Way E3
Fort Collins Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

Fort Collins Insurance provides comprehensive auto insurance agent services to drivers in Fort Collins, CO, including policy selection assistance and coverage adjustments. Its service plans involve regular policy reviews and claims support to help clients maintain appropriate protection. The company also assists with integrating new vehicles into existing plans and coordinates with other related coverages. It services personal vehicles for single-family homes, multi-unit properties for apartments, commercial fleets for retailers, and delivery vehicles for local restaurants.

BP
2121 Midpoint Dr #301a
Ben Parsons - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

This agency serves homeowners, renters, and drivers throughout Fort Collins, Colorado, helping them secure appropriate auto insurance policies tailored to their individual needs and budgets. As a local auto insurance agent, the office provides personalized coverage reviews and assistance with claims guidance. Clients can also explore renters insurance options to further protect their personal property. The agency additionally extends its services to the neighboring community of Loveland and other areas within the northern Colorado metro region.

IS
3500 John F Kennedy Pkwy Suite 205
IMA Select
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

IMA Select serves Fort Collins and the surrounding communities in northern Colorado, providing auto insurance coverage for cars and trucks. The agency helps drivers navigate policies that protect against accidents and liability on local roads. Clients can expect assistance with selecting appropriate coverage levels and understanding deductibles. IMA Select approaches each job by first reviewing the driver’s unique needs and then comparing available policy options to fit their budget and state requirements.

MM
1075 W Horsetooth Rd unit 202
Michael Martinez - GEICO Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

Homeowners, businesses, and drivers across Fort Collins turn to Michael Martinez - GEICO Insurance Agent for auto insurance policies tailored to their individual needs. This agency works to help customers find appropriate coverage options for their vehicles and driving habits. It also assists local residents in understanding their policy details and any available discounts. The office regularly serves clients looking for reliable protection and guidance on their auto insurance plans. Michael Martinez - GEICO Insurance Agent additionally provides service to drivers throughout Loveland and the greater Larimer County area.

GB
4605 Ziegler Rd
Gwen Brooks - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

For one-time auto policy purchases, Gwen Brooks - State Farm Insurance Agent in Fort Collins offers initial coverage setup and immediate service. Recurring clients receive ongoing support for policy adjustments, claims assistance, and renewal reviews. The agency provides liability, collision, and comprehensive options tailored to Colorado driving needs. All local guidance addresses regional factors like weather and road conditions. Service runs on a scheduled basis for annual policy reviews and billing inquiries, with additional as-needed support available for claims or coverage changes between scheduled appointments.

AI
145 N College Ave Suite B
Agate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

When winter weather in Fort Collins makes roads slick, many drivers seek reliable coverage that meets Colorado’s insurance requirements and protects against mountain commutes. Agate Insurance provides auto insurance agent services tailored to these local conditions, helping customers select appropriate liability and comprehensive options. They discuss differing limits and deductibles based on each driver’s situation and local risks. An initial consultation with an agent includes reviewing the vehicle’s documentation and completing a preliminary inspection of the car.

EL
140 Boardwalk Dr UNIT E
Erin LeVan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

Erin LeVan in Fort Collins offers comprehensive personal auto protection for everyday driving needs and can arrange specialized coverage such as roadside assistance or rental car reimbursement. The agency serves local residential drivers across all age brackets and driving histories. For commercial vehicle needs, the office extends its services to area offices, warehouses, and food service operations requiring standard business auto policies for their fleets or delivery vehicles.

CW
2020 S College Ave UNIT A3
Cristina Walston American Family Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO

Cristina Walston American Family Insurance provides auto insurance services to residents throughout Fort Collins and the surrounding areas. Residential clients can find coverage options for personal vehicles, while business owners may explore commercial auto policies to protect their fleets. The agency serves clients living and working across northern Colorado, offering guidance on standard liability and comprehensive plans. Following an initial policy setup, the office encourages periodic reviews to adjust coverage as circumstances change, ensuring repeat service and ongoing support between regular visits for continued peace of mind.

SI
19 Old Town Square
Shanti Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
AI
121 E Swallow Rd
ABC Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 484-3200
abcinsurancecolorado.com
AF
3636 S College Ave
AAA Ft. Collins
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 266-1831
locator.acg.aaa.com/co/fort-collins/aaa-ft-collins
TI
2108 Milestone Dr Ste 210
Thompson Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 482-0078
agents.allstate.com/thompson-insurance-agency-fort-collins-co.html
HI
2580 E Harmony Rd #201
Harmony Insurance Advisors, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 999-0488
harmonyinsuranceadvisors.com
SI
2629 Redwing Rd #150
Squires Insurance Solutions
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 377-0638
squiresinsurance.net
PI
1520 E Mulberry St
Plummer Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 484-1401
plummerinsurance.com/who-we-are/locations/fort-collins-co
CI
2803 E Harmony Rd
Collective Insurance Group
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(720) 514-9914
collectiveinsgroup.com
WI
4033 Boardwalk Dr # 200
Welsh Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 206-1810
nocoinsurance.com
RI
732 S Lemay Ave b
Riverside Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 999-0101
riversideinsuranceco.com
IS
2627 Redwing Rd Suite 160
Insurance Specialties Ltd
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 490-1530
insurenortherncolorado.com
NT
2000 Bighorn Dr
NOCO Trusted Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 787-6141
nocotrustedins.net
GI
2809 E Harmony Rd # 160
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(970) 223-1804
assuredpartners.com/FortCollins
SV
1015 W Horsetooth Rd Ste 203, Unit E
Scenic View Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Fort Collins, CO
(855) 598-2822
scenicviewagency.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Fort Collins Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in Colorado is around 1,800 dollars per year for full coverage, but rates in Fort Collins may vary based on your driving record, vehicle type, and coverage limits. Minimum liability policies can cost as little as 500 dollars annually for some drivers. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Fort Collins

Auto insurance agents in Fort Collins Colorado help drivers find policies that meet state requirements and personal needs. Colorado law requires all drivers to carry liability insurance with minimum limits of 25 thousand dollars per person for bodily injury and 15 thousand dollars per property damage. Local agents can explain how factors like Fort Collins weather and traffic patterns affect your coverage options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Colorado?

Colorado requires liability coverage of 25 thousand dollars per person for bodily injury and 50 thousand dollars per accident for bodily injury. Property damage liability must be at least 15 thousand dollars. Uninsured motorist coverage is also required unless you reject it in writing.

How do I find a reliable auto insurance agent in Fort Collins?

You can search for agents through the Colorado Division of Insurance website or ask for referrals from friends and family. Check that the agent is licensed in Colorado and has experience with local driving conditions and laws.

Can my auto insurance rates change after I buy a policy in Fort Collins?

Yes, rates can change due to factors like accidents, traffic violations, or changes in your credit score. Colorado law allows insurers to adjust premiums at renewal, but they must provide notice of any increase.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Colorado Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.