ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsMichigan › Plymouth

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Plymouth, MI

Browse auto insurance agents serving Plymouth, Michigan. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Plymouth, Michigan is C. L. Finlan Insurance, rated 4.9 stars across 621 reviews. Other highly rated options include Amanda Ross - State Farm Insurance Agent, Nick Nestorovski - State Farm Insurance Agent, Kennedy Nemier Insurance Services. This directory lists 21 auto insurance agents serving Plymouth.

Showing 21 auto insurance agents in Plymouth, MIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1C. L. Finlan Insurance47784 Halyard Dr(734) 453-6000
2Amanda Ross - State Farm Insurance Agent44327 Plymouth Oaks Blvd(734) 404-6133
3Nick Nestorovski - State Farm Insurance Agent259 N Main St(734) 453-3640
4Kennedy Nemier Insurance Services1225 S Main St(734) 454-4058
5Cindy Fletcher - State Farm Insurance Agent409 Plymouth Rd Ste 202(734) 459-2023
6Farmers Insurance - Antonio Asmar42193 Ann Arbor Rd(734) 454-9660
7Laginess Insurance Agency199 N Main St(734) 455-5088
8Progressive Insurance - Claims Office46333 Five Mile Rd #100(800) 776-4737
9Antonelli Agency9450 S Main St #105(734) 738-0050
10Hemlock Insurance Group-Plymouth Branch15398 N Haggerty Rd(734) 463-3500
CL
47784 Halyard Dr
C. L. Finlan Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

C. L. Finlan Insurance provides auto insurance agent services to customers in Plymouth, Michigan, and the surrounding Wayne County area. The company helps clients obtain essential coverage for their personal vehicles. Typical work includes explaining policy options for liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. The firm also assists local drivers in navigating the process of choosing appropriate deductibles and coverage limits. In this area, the office handles new policy setup for standard automobiles and manages policy adjustments for existing clients.

AR
44327 Plymouth Oaks Blvd
Amanda Ross - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Amanda Ross - State Farm Insurance Agent in Plymouth, MI, provides auto insurance policies along with related coverage options such as liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. The agency offers ongoing policy reviews to help ensure coverage remains appropriate as driving needs change. Personalized service plans are available for customers seeking periodic adjustments to their deductibles or limits. In addition to auto insurance, the agency services a variety of local property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants.

NN
259 N Main St
Nick Nestorovski - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Serving local homeowners, businesses, and drivers in Plymouth, Michigan, Nick Nestorovski - State Farm Insurance Agent provides auto insurance policies to help protect vehicles and manage liability risks. As a neighborhood agent, he works closely with clients to review their driving needs and coverage options. His office also assists customers in nearby communities such as Northville and Canton, ensuring those in the greater western Detroit suburbs have access to reliable insurance guidance and support.

KN
1225 S Main St
Kennedy Nemier Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Kennedy Nemier Insurance Services serves clients in Plymouth, Michigan, and the surrounding communities. The company handles auto insurance policies for individuals and families in the region. It works with standard coverage options, including liability, collision, and comprehensive plans. To handle a typical job, it begins by reviewing a driver’s personal situation and vehicle details. It then compares available coverage levels to recommend a policy that meets both state requirements and the customer’s budget. This practical approach ensures each client receives a tailored solution without unnecessary extras.

CF
409 Plymouth Rd Ste 202
Cindy Fletcher - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Cindy Fletcher - State Farm Insurance Agent in Plymouth, MI provides auto insurance policies tailored to individual coverage needs and risk profiles. The agency assists clients with personal liability protection, comprehensive and collision coverage, and roadside assistance plans. It also helps customers navigate claims processes and policy updates for vehicles ranging from commuter cars to family SUVs. During winter months, the office addresses common concerns such as coverage for weather-related damage and safe driving discounts for accident-free records.

FI
42193 Ann Arbor Rd
Farmers Insurance - Antonio Asmar
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

As the snowy Plymouth winters approach, local drivers often review their coverage for ice and collision protection. Farmers Insurance agent Antonio Asmar helps customers in the area evaluate their auto policies to ensure adequate protection during these demanding months. The agency specializes in tailoring personal auto insurance plans to match each driver’s specific needs. New clients begin by scheduling a no-obligation policy review, where an initial assessment of their current coverage and vehicle information is conducted.

LI
199 N Main St
Laginess Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Laginess Insurance Agency in Plymouth, MI, provides auto insurance coverage for personal vehicles and can arrange additional protections such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement. The agency works to match policies with individual driving habits and vehicle types found throughout the surrounding area. Commercial auto insurance options are available for businesses, including coverage for company cars used by sales teams, delivery vans for offices, trucks serving warehouses, and vehicles for food service operations.

PI
46333 Five Mile Rd #100
Progressive Insurance - Claims Office
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Many local car owners visit this Plymouth agency for a single immediate claim solution, while others choose recurring policy management for ongoing protection. As an auto insurance agent, the office helps clients select bodily injury and property damage liability coverage that meets standard Michigan requirements. For drivers seeking long-term agreements, the staff explains comprehensive and collision options with straightforward policy adjustments. Service appointments are available on both a scheduled basis for annual policy reviews and as-needed for filing accident claims.

AA
9450 S Main St #105
Antonelli Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Antonelli Agency provides auto insurance for residential drivers in Plymouth, Michigan. The agency also offers commercial coverage for local vehicles used in business operations. Serving Plymouth and the surrounding area, the agency helps clients review policy options to fit their individual driving needs. After initial enrollment, the agency reaches out to customers for renewal discussions and coverage updates between regular visits to ensure continued protection.

HI
15398 N Haggerty Rd
Hemlock Insurance Group-Plymouth Branch
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI

Hemlock Insurance Group-Plymouth Branch is an auto insurance agent company serving Plymouth, Michigan. The agency helps local drivers compare coverage options to meet state minimums and personal financial needs. Policyholders can work with agents to bundle auto protection with other lines for potential discounts. A specialty service the office offers is roadside assistance plan enrollment for added driver security.

AI
1365 S Main St Ste E
AAA Insurance - Schwegler Insurance Plymouth
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 453-2100
locator.acg.aaa.com/mi/plymouth/aaa-insurance-schwegler-insurance-plymouth
PI
696 N Mill St Ste 108
plymouth Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 212-8067
AI
40350 Five Mile Rd
AAA Insurance - Salem Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 892-2312
locator.acg.aaa.com/mi/Plymouth/aaa-insurance-Salem-Insurance-Agency
TB
40600 Ann Arbor Rd STE 150
Tammy Brown Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 844-9180
michfb.com/insurance/find-an-agent/tammy-brown-40600-ann-arbor-rd-e-ste-150
RE
40516 E Ann Arbor Trail
Randy Ellison: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 456-6066
agents.allstate.com/randy-ellison-plymouth-mi.html
TW
47821 Ann Arbor Rd
Tom Wilson Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 459-8873
locator.meemic.com/mi/plymouth-charter-twp/tom-wilson-agency
AI
1365 S Main St
AAA Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 453-2100
aaa.com
MI
859 S Main St
Michigan Insurance Group Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 459-9797
mig-ins.com/plymouth
SI
40600 Ann Arbor Rd STE 150
Sturla Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 927-6143
sturlainsurance.com
CA
864 S Main St
Caviston Agency Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 455-8120
cavistonagency.com
FI
42193 Ann Arbor Rd E
Farmers Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Plymouth, MI
(734) 234-5053
farmers.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Plymouth Cost?

Auto insurance costs in Plymouth Michigan vary by driver age vehicle and driving record. Average annual premiums in Michigan range from 1500 to 3000 or more for full coverage. Factors like credit score and annual mileage also affect rates. This is general information not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Plymouth

Auto insurance agents in Plymouth Michigan help drivers find coverage that meets state requirements. Michigan law mandates unlimited medical benefits under no-fault insurance for injuries. A local agent can explain these rules and help you choose liability collision and comprehensive options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Plymouth auto insurance agent do?

An agent helps you compare policies from different insurers and explains Michigan no-fault coverage. They can also assist with policy changes claims filing and finding discounts.

Is Michigan no-fault insurance required in Plymouth?

Yes Michigan requires all drivers to carry no-fault insurance. This covers your medical expenses after an accident regardless of fault. A Plymouth agent can help you meet the minimum liability limits of 25000 per person and 50000 per accident.

How do I choose an auto insurance agent in Plymouth Michigan?

Look for agents licensed in Michigan with experience in no-fault policies. Ask about their carrier options and customer service availability. You can also check reviews from other Plymouth drivers.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.