ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsNew York › Middletown

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Middletown, NY

Browse auto insurance agents serving Middletown, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Middletown, New York is James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 922 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Joy Insurance, Curabba Insurance Agency. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Middletown.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Middletown, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent13 James P Kelly Way ste a(845) 344-3276
2Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent246 NY-211(845) 775-3277
3Joy Insurance639 E Main St(845) 342-4888
4Curabba Insurance Agency334 E Main St(845) 343-0855
5De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent809 NY-211(845) 692-3456
6Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt690, 4 NY-211 E(845) 673-6127
7The Premium Select Group Inc.32 County Rd 78(845) 520-9774
8Hutchings Agency Inc.682 E Main St # 2D(845) 343-2148
9Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent4 E Main St Ste 3B(845) 394-2622
10Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency265 NY-211 Suite 106B(845) 394-6155
JD
13 James P Kelly Way ste a
James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Middletown, Orange County area and its surrounding communities. The agency provides auto insurance coverage, helping customers select policies that meet New York financial responsibility requirements and personal protection needs. They also work with drivers to review deductibles and liability limits. This office assists local residents with comprehensive and collision coverages for their vehicles.

CG
246 NY-211
Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent offers auto insurance policies in Middletown, NY, along with related coverage options like roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement. The agency helps clients customize their liability, collision, and comprehensive plans to meet individual driving needs and local requirements. Regular policy reviews and claims assistance are provided to maintain appropriate protection over time. This agency serves drivers for personal vehicles, as well as those requiring coverage for single-family homes, apartments, retail, and restaurants.

JI
639 E Main St
Joy Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Joy Insurance serves homeowners, drivers, and local business owners throughout the Middletown area. As an auto insurance agent, the company helps clients find and maintain personal car insurance policies that meet New York requirements for liability and coverage levels. The firm also assists with bundling auto and homeowners protection for greater convenience and potential savings. Through direct consultations, the agent works to match each driver with suitable insurance plans based on their vehicle type and driving needs. The agency extends its services to neighboring communities in Orange County.

CI
334 E Main St
Curabba Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Serving Middletown and the surrounding communities of Orange County, Curabba Insurance Agency focuses on auto insurance coverage for local drivers. It handles policies that protect individuals and families against liability, collision, and other common risks on the road. The agency works to match each customer with a plan that fits their specific driving habits and budget. Its general approach to a typical job involves reviewing a driver’s situation, explaining available coverage options, and helping them secure a policy that meets local insurance requirements.

DA
809 NY-211
De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Some clients require a single policy adjustment, while others need ongoing support as their coverage evolves. De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent, based in Middletown, NY, provides auto insurance options designed for these varying situations, from initial liability setups to comprehensive protection. Recognizing that local driving conditions and personal circumstances change, an agent can help review annual renewal terms or update a policy after a life event. This service operates on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to schedule meetings or request assistance whenever their current coverage requires discussion or a change.

EI
690, 4 NY-211 E
Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
PS
32 County Rd 78
The Premium Select Group Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

As winter weather and unpredictable road conditions arrive in the Middletown area, the need for dependable auto coverage becomes especially pressing. The Premium Select Group Inc. serves local drivers by assessing their individual risk profiles and matching them with suitable policies from available carriers. Each consultation focuses on aligning coverage levels with the customer’s daily commute and vehicle usage. After reviewing the driver’s current policy and discussing potential liability gaps, an agent schedules a brief vehicle inspection to confirm eligibility details before finalizing the initial quote.

HA
682 E Main St # 2D
Hutchings Agency Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Hutchings Agency Inc. in Middletown, NY is a local provider of auto insurance policies designed to meet the needs of area drivers. The company helps customers navigate coverage options, from basic liability to more comprehensive plans that protect against common road risks. Policies can be tailored to fit different vehicles and driving habits in the region. An available specialty service includes adding roadside assistance to a standard auto policy for extra peace of mind during travel.

KS
4 E Main St Ste 3B
Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY provides auto insurance protection for households and personal vehicles throughout the local area. Commercial coverage is also available for local businesses operating in and around Middletown. The agency helps clients understand their policy options and file claims when accidents occur. Many area customers return for regular policy reviews or to adjust coverage as their driving needs change between each scheduled visit.

NF
265 NY-211 Suite 106B
Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

As an auto insurance agent, Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency in Middletown works with clients to identify and secure appropriate vehicle coverage. Standard policies can be tailored with add-ons such as roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and comprehensive protection against non-collision damages. The agent serves individual drivers, families, and also handles commercial needs for offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

LB
125 Dolson Ave Ste 22b
Lori Buhagiar: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-5909
agents.allstate.com/lori-buhagiar-middletown-ny.html
MS
90 Crystal Run Rd
Marshall+Sterling
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-2138
marshallsterling.com/middletown
GG
15 Dolson Ave
Glenn Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5721
glenngleeson.com
LA
22 County Rd 78 #2
The Lang Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5264
thelangagency.com
MI
593 NY-211
Macri Isola Catherine Insurance Agency Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 692-2277
cmiinsuranceagency.com
RI
112 North St
Reineke Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-8000
curabba.com/reineke-insurance-agency
EI
117 North St
Estrella Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 535-0095
agents.estrellainsurance.com/en-us/ny/middletown/402.html
MI
610 Route 211 E, Ste 2
The Misner Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 434-7755
misneragency.com
IC
200 North St
Insurance Center
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-0603
JW
265 NY-211 Suite 106B
Jillian Wied at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 394-6145
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/middletown-074p/jillian-wied

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Middletown Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in New York is around 1300 to 2000 per year for full coverage and 600 to 900 per year for minimum liability. In Middletown rates may vary based on local accident statistics and population density. Your actual premium will depend on your personal risk profile. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Middletown

Middletown NY drivers need auto insurance that meets New York state minimum liability requirements of 25/50/10. A local auto insurance agent can help you navigate these requirements and find coverage tailored to your vehicle and driving history. Agents in Middletown understand the specific risks of driving in Orange County and can explain options like no-fault benefits and uninsured motorist coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in New York?

New York requires liability coverage of 25/50/10 meaning 25000 for bodily injury per person 50000 per accident and 10000 for property damage. You also need no-fault personal injury protection and uninsured motorist coverage.

How can a local agent help me in Middletown NY?

A local agent can explain NY-specific laws like the no-fault system and the statute of limitations for filing claims which is generally 3 years for property damage and 3 years for personal injury. They can also help you compare quotes from multiple insurers.

What factors affect auto insurance rates in Middletown?

Rates depend on your driving record age vehicle type credit history and where you live in Middletown. NY law also allows insurers to consider your zip code and annual mileage. An agent can help you find discounts for safe driving or bundling policies.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.