ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsOhio › Worthington

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Worthington, OH

Browse home insurance agents serving Worthington, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Worthington, Ohio is Hans Schell - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 227 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mike Mathers - State Farm Insurance Agent, Titan Insurance Services, Ankrom Agency. This directory lists 17 home insurance agents serving Worthington.

Showing 17 home insurance agents in Worthington, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Hans Schell - State Farm Insurance Agent5577 N High St ste b(614) 888-0606
2Mike Mathers - State Farm Insurance Agent1000 N High St h(614) 846-7411
3Titan Insurance Services752 N High St(614) 398-1494
4Ankrom Agency5701 N High St UNIT 202(614) 888-1728
5Insurance Agency of Ohio7100 N High St #300(380) 400-8823
6Farmers Insurance - Nicole Glass660 N High St Ste 201(614) 601-6016
7Farmers Insurance - Jeremy Ferguson951 N High St Suite A(614) 769-6436
8Bixler Insurance Agency LLC951 N High St #204(614) 389-2799
9Montana Insurance1311 Worthington Woods Blvd(614) 846-9830
10France & Associates Inc5921 N High St(614) 888-8124
HS
5577 N High St ste b
Hans Schell - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Hans Schell - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Worthington, Ohio area as a local home insurance agent. This office helps homeowners secure coverage for dwelling damage, personal property, and liability protection. They assist clients in tailoring policies to meet individual needs, including coverage for structures like detached garages. Specific services handled by this agency include advising on replacement cost coverage and providing endorsements for valuable personal items such as jewelry or electronics.

MM
1000 N High St h
Mike Mathers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Mike Mathers - State Farm Insurance Agent in Worthington, OH provides a range of home insurance services to help protect clients' property and assets. Policies are designed to cover dwelling damage, personal belongings, and liability exposure, with options for bundling other insurance products. Service maintenance plans include support for filing claims, policy reviews, and updating coverage as needs change. This agency serves multiple property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

TI
752 N High St
Titan Insurance Services
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Titan Insurance Services serves homeowners and property managers throughout Worthington, Ohio, by providing home insurance agent services. The company assists clients in securing coverage that protects residential property against common local risks, including severe storms and liability concerns. Policies are tailored to fit individual housing needs, whether for single-family homes or rental properties. Each customer receives guidance through the selection process to ensure appropriate coverage levels. Titan Insurance Services also extends its home insurance offerings to nearby communities such as Dublin and the greater Columbus metropolitan area.

AA
5701 N High St UNIT 202
Ankrom Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Serving Worthington, OH, and the surrounding communities, Ankrom Agency handles home insurance policies designed to protect local homeowners. The agency works to secure coverage that addresses both structural risks and personal belongings common to the area. For each client, it begins by reviewing the specific features of their property and local hazard considerations. The typical job is then managed by comparing coverage options to match the individual needs of the homeowner.

IA
7100 N High St #300
Insurance Agency of Ohio
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Insurance Agency of Ohio in Worthington offers both one-time and recurring service options for home insurance. One-time policies cover individual homes for a set period, while recurring plans automatically renew, ensuring continuous protection for local properties. Coverage typically includes dwelling, personal property, and liability protection tailored to regional risks like storms or fire. Professional agents guide residents in selecting appropriate limits for their specific homes. Service runs on an as-needed basis for new policies or adjustments, with recurring renewals scheduled annually.

FI
660 N High St Ste 201
Farmers Insurance - Nicole Glass
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Spring storms in central Ohio can leave homes with unexpected roof or siding damage, and Farmers Insurance agent Nicole Glass helps Worthington homeowners address these concerns through personalized coverage reviews. She works with clients to match policies to their property’s specific risks, such as frozen pipes or wind damage common to this area. After discussing deductibles and liability limits, Glass schedules an initial home inspection to identify any existing conditions that may need addressing before finalizing a new policy.

FI
951 N High St Suite A
Farmers Insurance - Jeremy Ferguson
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

As a local home insurance agent, Farmers Insurance - Jeremy Ferguson in Worthington, OH specializes in helping homeowners secure tailored coverage for their property. It also offers general services such as advising on policy options to protect dwellings and personal belongings. Families planning for unexpected events receive guidance on liability and loss-of-use protection. During severe Ohio winters, the agent assists clients with reviewing policies for ice dam damage and water backup coverage, ensuring their homes remain secure through freezing temperatures.

BI
951 N High St #204
Bixler Insurance Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Bixler Insurance Agency LLC, located in Worthington, OH, works with homeowners to secure residential property coverage tailored to individual needs. The agency also assists business owners in the area with commercial insurance policies for their operations. Serving clients throughout central Ohio, the team provides guidance on policy options and risk management. Between regular renewal periods, they handle policy adjustments and follow up on claims or coverage questions as needed.

MI
1311 Worthington Woods Blvd
Montana Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

Montana Insurance in Worthington, OH, helps clients evaluate and select homeowners coverage tailored to their property needs. They commonly assist with adding specialty endorsements for flood protection and valuable personal property riders. Their work includes guiding homeowners through policy details and claims filing procedures in the local area. They serve residential customers along with commercial sectors such as offices, warehouses, and food service establishments requiring liability and property coverage for their operations.

FA
5921 N High St
France & Associates Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH

France & Associates Inc, based in Worthington, Ohio, is known for providing personalized home insurance policies that align with local property needs and budgets. The agency serves homeowners by assessing coverage options for structure, contents, and liability. Typical service support includes helping clients compare standard and broad form policies to match their dwelling type and risk level. For added protection, the agency offers specialized endorsements for valuable personal property, such as jewelry or fine art.

GF
5701 N High St #200
Good Friends Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 500-9722
goodfriendsinsurance.com
AB
77 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 108
Arnett Brown Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 885-2515
statefarm.com/agent/us/oh/worthington/arnett-brown-jr-tctvc1ys000
EM
515 Pittsfield Dr
E & M Risk Management Agency, LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 396-6853
eandmrisk.com
BG
225 St Antoine St
Bart Greene Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 888-1788
TC
6877 N High St
Thompson-Cunningham Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 885-8536
thompsoncunningham.com
BS
37 E Wilson Bridge Rd #220
Brian Smith Insurance Agency - Horace Mann
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 484-1489
agents.horacemann.com/BrianSmith
CI
808 N High St
Chadwell Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Worthington, OH
(614) 888-3067
chadwellagency.com

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Worthington Cost?

The average annual home insurance premium in Ohio is around 1,000 dollars but rates in Worthington can range from 800 to 1,500 dollars depending on coverage limits and deductibles. Older homes or those with outdated electrical or plumbing systems may cost more to insure. This is general information not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Worthington

Home insurance agents in Worthington Ohio help homeowners find policies that meet state requirements and protect against common risks like wind hail and fire. Ohio law does not require home insurance but mortgage lenders typically mandate it. Agents can explain Ohio-specific coverage options such as water backup and replacement cost endorsements.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does home insurance cover in Worthington Ohio?

Standard policies cover dwelling other structures personal property and liability. Ohio is prone to severe storms so wind and hail coverage is important. Flood insurance is separate and not included in standard policies.

How do I choose a home insurance agent in Worthington?

Look for an agent licensed in Ohio who has experience with homes in central Ohio. Ask about their knowledge of local risks like tornadoes and winter freeze damage. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find suitable coverage.

What factors affect home insurance cost in Worthington?

Cost depends on your homes age location construction type and claims history. Ohio law allows insurers to use credit scores in pricing. Discounts may be available for bundling with auto insurance or installing security systems.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.