ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Middleton

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Middleton, WI

Browse home insurance agents serving Middleton, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Middleton, Wisconsin is The Health Insurance Store, rated 5.0 stars across 1,125 reviews. Other highly rated options include Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent, Compliance Insurance, Baer Insurance Services, Inc.. This directory lists 19 home insurance agents serving Middleton.

Showing 19 home insurance agents in Middleton, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1The Health Insurance Store7447 University Ave Suite 204(608) 210-2500
2Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent6924 University Ave(608) 831-2886
3Compliance Insurance8383 Greenway Blvd 6th Floor, Ste 600(608) 836-1001
4Baer Insurance Services, Inc.9701 Brader Way Suite 101(608) 830-5800
5AVID Risk Solutions2501 Parmenter St #200a(608) 827-4525
6Schwarz Insurance Agency6605 University Ave Suite 202(608) 831-9660
7Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance1468 N High Point Rd # 101(608) 831-1800
8Daniel Olson American Family Insurance1833 Parmenter St(608) 836-4200
9Michael Donnelly: Allstate Insurance6661 University Ave Ste 108(608) 729-0147
10Brian Kelly Agency, LLC American Family Insurance6700 University Ave(608) 831-2525
HI
7447 University Ave Suite 204
The Health Insurance Store
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

The Health Insurance Store serves the Middleton, Wisconsin area and provides home insurance agent services. The agency works with local homeowners to obtain suitable property coverage that protects against common risks like fire, theft, and weather damage. Policies are tailored to meet individual dwelling and personal property needs. The company also assists clients in securing liability protection for their residences and exploring additional endorsements for valuable items. The Health Insurance Store handles standard homeowners policies and standalone dwelling fire insurance options.

AA
6924 University Ave
Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middleton, WI, provides a full range of home insurance coverage, including protection for the dwelling structure, personal belongings, and liability. Service plans include assistance with policy adjustments and claims filing to help clients manage unexpected property damage or theft. The agent serves various property types in the local area, such as single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

CI
8383 Greenway Blvd 6th Floor, Ste 600
Compliance Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Compliance Insurance serves homeowners throughout Middleton, Wisconsin, providing tailored home insurance policies that protect single-family houses and residential properties. The agency assists clients in evaluating dwelling coverage, personal property protection, and liability options to fit their needs. By explaining deductible choices and policy limits, they help customers secure appropriate plans for their circumstances. Residents in the nearby town of Waunakee and surrounding areas of Dane County also access these coverage services from Compliance Insurance.

BI
9701 Brader Way Suite 101
Baer Insurance Services, Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Serving the greater Middleton area and surrounding Dane County communities, Baer Insurance Services, Inc. specializes in residential home insurance policies for local homeowners. The company addresses coverage for a home’s structure, personal belongings, and liability protection against common property risks. To handle a typical policy request, the agency first reviews a client’s property specifics and coverage needs, then presents multiple quotes from different insurers to help the homeowner make an informed choice.

AR
2501 Parmenter St #200a
AVID Risk Solutions
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

A home insurance agent such as AVID Risk Solutions in Middleton, WI, offers both one-time policy reviews and recurring annual service to ensure coverage remains adequate. They help homeowners evaluate dwelling and liability protection against common regional risks like severe storms or fire. Their work focuses on matching policy limits to property value and personal assets. Service can be arranged as a one-time consultation, scheduled for a renewal review each year, or available as needed when a home purchase or major renovation occurs.

SI
6605 University Ave Suite 202
Schwarz Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

As the Wisconsin winter fades, homeowners in Middleton confront the lingering marks of snow and ice on their property. Schwarz Insurance Agency assists those seeking home insurance coverage to protect against the season's common damages, such as roof leaks or frozen pipe bursts. This local agent provides guidance for policies that address typical regional risks like hail or wind storms. New clients receive a thorough inspection of their home’s exterior and interior prior to a policy being discussed, ensuring an accurate assessment of specific coverage needs.

JE
1468 N High Point Rd # 101
Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance works with property owners in Middleton, WI, to structure homeowners policies that address a house's structure and its contents. For broader protection, the agency underwrites additional coverages such as personal liability, umbrella policies, and endorsements for valuable items like jewelry or collectibles. It also writes insurance for income-producing commercial properties including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

DO
1833 Parmenter St
Daniel Olson American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Daniel Olson American Family Insurance provides residential home insurance services in the Middleton, Wisconsin area, alongside commercial coverage for local business properties. The agency helps homeowners structure policies that protect their dwelling and personal belongings from common regional risks. By working with clients to review coverage limits and deductibles during the policy term, the team ensures each plan remains aligned with changing property values or life circumstances. Regular follow-up contact between annual renewals allows for adjustments to be made whenever a home improvement or new asset is acquired.

MD
6661 University Ave Ste 108
Michael Donnelly: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
BK
6700 University Ave
Brian Kelly Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Brian Kelly Agency, LLC American Family Insurance serves the Middleton, WI area as a dedicated home insurance agent. The agency helps local homeowners assess their property coverage needs, offering guidance on standard policies that protect dwellings and personal belongings against common regional risks. Clients can receive assistance in adjusting deductibles and understanding policy limits to better fit their budget. For added protection, the agency can arrange personal liability umbrella coverage to extend beyond typical home insurance limits.

DP
6926 University Ave
Dan Pechauer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 831-3393
danpechauer.com
PI
8333 Greenway Blvd Ste 200
Progressive Insurance - Claims Office
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(800) 776-4737
progressive.com/claims
PI
2421 Parmenter St
Petersburg Insurance Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 824-7267
c4ins.com
SI
9701 Brader Way
Success Insurance Now
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 291-4098
RI
1818 Parmenter St #300
Riesen Insurance Agency, LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 225-3523
teamriesen.com
BI
6629 University Ave
Badger Insurance Associates of Madison Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 831-3797
badgerinsurance.com
SI
1800 Deming Way
Sentry Insurance – Middleton Regional Office
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(800) 473-6879
sentry.com
GN
6810 University Ave
Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency, Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 831-3168
greeneniesen.com
GI
2501 Parmenter St #200a
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Home Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 827-4525
locations.ajg.com/us/wi/middleton/2501-parmenter-street

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Middleton Cost?

Typical home insurance costs in Wisconsin range from 800 to 1,500 dollars per year for a standard homeowners policy. Factors like the age of your home its replacement cost and your deductible affect the premium. In Middleton proximity to lakes or flood zones may increase rates. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Middleton

Home insurance agents in Middleton Wisconsin help homeowners protect their property against risks like severe weather and liability. Wisconsin law requires insurers to offer specific coverage for sewer backup and water damage in standard policies. A local agent can explain these options and tailor a policy to your home and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Middleton do?

A home insurance agent helps you compare policies from different insurers and choose coverage that fits your needs. They explain policy terms and assist with claims. In Wisconsin agents must be licensed by the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance.

Is home insurance required in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin law does not require homeowners insurance by statute. However mortgage lenders almost always require it as a condition of the loan. An agent can help you meet lender requirements and avoid a lapse in coverage.

What is the typical cost for home insurance in Middleton Wisconsin?

Average home insurance premiums in Wisconsin are around 900 to 1,200 dollars per year for a standard policy. Costs vary based on home value location age and claims history. An agent can provide quotes specific to your property.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.