ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Sheboygan

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Sheboygan, WI

Browse home insurance agents serving Sheboygan, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Sheboygan, Wisconsin is Acuity Insurance, rated 4.2 stars across 1,611 reviews. Other highly rated options include Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance, Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart, Aim Group Inc.. This directory lists 20 home insurance agents serving Sheboygan.

Showing 20 home insurance agents in Sheboygan, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Acuity Insurance2800 S Taylor Dr(800) 242-7666
2Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance3626 Erie Ave(920) 457-1950
3Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart909 N 8th St UNIT 105(920) 547-5724
4Aim Group Inc.526 N 8th St(920) 457-9112
5J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance2204 Wilson Ave Ste 2(920) 452-3661
6Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance2109 Erie Ave #101(920) 458-7141
7Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance2108 Kohler Memorial Dr Ste 200(920) 458-2101
8Nicla Insurance506 N 8th St(920) 452-8461
9Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance601 Center Ave(920) 459-9919
10Heinen & Associates1601 N 8th St(920) 458-9724
AI
2800 S Taylor Dr
Acuity Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Acuity Insurance serves Sheboygan County in Wisconsin as a home insurance agent. This company assists local homeowners in securing dwelling and personal property coverage tailored to the area. Policies are designed to protect against common regional risks such as severe storms and winter freeze damage. Agents also help clients evaluate liability protection and additional living expenses coverage. Specific services handled in this area include standard homeowner policies and customized endorsements for high-value personal possessions.

SB
3626 Erie Ave
Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance provides home insurance policies that cover dwelling damage, personal property protection, and liability coverage for incidents occurring on the insured property. The agency offers customizable plans, allowing clients to adjust deductibles and add endorsements for specific risks like sewer backup or identity recovery. It assists with bundling home and auto policies for potential discounts. Policyholders receive support for filing claims and reviewing coverage needs during annual check-ins. The agency serves single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

AI
909 N 8th St UNIT 105
Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Homeowners and property owners in and around Sheboygan, Wisconsin work with Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart for residential home insurance coverage. This agency assists clients in protecting their houses, personal property, and liability through customized policies. The services include help with understanding deductibles, coverage limits, and available endorsements. Residents seeking a local agent for new policies or policy reviews can schedule consultations. Jerry Bodart also provides insurance services for nearby communities such as Kohler, covering similar property protection needs throughout the broader Sheboygan County area.

AG
526 N 8th St
Aim Group Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Serving Sheboygan and the surrounding communities of eastern Wisconsin, Aim Group Inc. handles residential insurance for homeowners seeking coverage for their property and belongings. The company works with clients to understand the unique risks posed by local weather and lakefront conditions. For a typical job, it assesses each property’s specific exposures and then presents a selection of policy options to match the homeowner’s budget and protection needs.

JM
2204 Wilson Ave Ste 2
J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, offers personal home insurance as a recurring service option, alongside one-time policy reviews for existing homeowners. Coverage protects against damage from fire, wind, hail, and theft, with standard liability and additional living expense provisions. The agency guides clients in selecting appropriate deductibles and coverage limits for their specific property needs. For the local Sheboygan area, this home insurance agent provides service primarily on a scheduled renewal basis, with as-needed consultations for policy adjustments or claims support.

GK
2109 Erie Ave #101
Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

As a home insurance agent in Sheboygan, Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance specializes in dwelling, personal property, and liability coverage for single-family homes. The agency also assists with broader personal insurance needs including renters and condo policies throughout the area. Clients are guided through policy options that address common regional risks, such as severe winter storms or the potential for ice dam damage to roofs and gutters.

AG
2108 Kohler Memorial Dr Ste 200
Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

When harsh winter storms pound the Lake Michigan shoreline in Sheboygan, homeowners often worry about roof damage and frozen pipes. Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance addresses these seasonal risks by tailoring home insurance coverage to local weather patterns and property types. The agency works with clients to review policy details, including dwelling limits and personal property protections. Coverage often extends to liability and additional living expenses if a home becomes uninhabitable. An initial property assessment or virtual inspection typically begins the process of identifying appropriate coverage needs for each residence.

NI
506 N 8th St
Nicla Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Nicla Insurance assists homeowners in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, with securing coverage for their primary residences and vacation properties. Their specialty add-ons can include protections for valuable personal property, such as jewelry or fine art, along with liability extensions for home-based businesses. Policyholders are guided through the selection of deductibles and replacement cost options. Beyond residential clients, the agency also tailors commercial policies for local offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

AW
601 Center Ave
Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance provides residential home insurance services in Sheboygan, Wisconsin. The agency also offers commercial coverage options for local business properties throughout the greater Sheboygan area. Policies are written to protect structures and personal belongings from common regional risks. Clients are encouraged to schedule follow-up appointments between regular policy reviews for coverage adjustments or to discuss new needs as their property evolves.

HA
1601 N 8th St
Heinen & Associates
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Heinen & Associates in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, is known for providing home insurance policies that protect local households against common perils. The company offers standard coverage options for dwelling, personal property, and liability, helping residents secure financial protection for their homes. It also assists clients in understanding policy details to ensure adequate coverage for the area. For an added specialty, Heinen & Associates can arrange separate flood insurance policies for properties in designated flood zones.

KI
1019 Michigan Ave
Key Insurance Services Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-8400
keyinsuranceinc.com
BI
801 N 8th St
Brandl Insurance Agency Sheboygan
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 457-3743
brandlinsurance.com
IM
1403 Broadway Ave
Insurance and Mortgage Services, Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
insmort.com
CT
1732 S 8th St
Chris Toutloff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-7732
statefarm.com/agent/us/wi/sheboygan/chris-toutloff-pcn691ys000
BI
1424 Union Ave
Boll Insurance Agency, inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 457-7386
bollinsuranceagency.net
AI
1539 N 33rd Pl a
AAA Insurance - Adventure Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 783-6890
locator.acg.aaa.com/wi/sheboygan/aaa-insurance-adventure-insurance-agency
MI
833 Pennsylvania Ave
McClone Insurance - Sheboygan
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-6174
mcclone.com/sheboygan
AA
902 Michigan Ave
Ansay & Associates LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 457-9035
ansay.com
TI
1414 N Taylor Dr #105
Trempe Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 452-9483
trempeinsuranceagency.com
CH
3005-3008 N 15th St
Circle Home Insurance Sheboygan
Home Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 688-6681
all-home-insurance.com/l

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Sheboygan Cost?

Typical home insurance costs in Wisconsin range from 800 to 1,500 dollars per year for a standard policy. Sheboygan rates may be slightly higher due to lake effect weather risks. Factors like your homes replacement cost and coverage limits will affect the final price. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Sheboygan

Home insurance agents in Sheboygan Wisconsin help homeowners find policies that cover damage from fire wind and hail. Wisconsin law requires insurers to offer replacement cost coverage on dwelling policies. Agents can explain local risks like Lake Michigan storms and guide you through the process of selecting deductibles and liability limits.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Sheboygan do?

A home insurance agent helps you compare policies from different carriers. They explain coverage options such as dwelling protection personal property and liability. They also assist with filing claims and updating your policy after home improvements.

Is home insurance required in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin state law does not require homeowners insurance. However mortgage lenders almost always require it. Even if you own your home free and clear an agent can help you decide on coverage to protect your investment.

What factors affect home insurance cost in Sheboygan?

Costs depend on your homes age construction type location and claims history. Proximity to Lake Michigan can increase wind and hail risk. Your credit score and chosen deductible also influence your premium.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.