ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Appleton, WI

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Appleton, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Appleton, Wisconsin is Thiel Insurance Group, LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 783 reviews. Other highly rated options include Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance, Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent, Comparion Insurance Agency. This directory lists 22 landlord insurance agents serving Appleton.

Showing 22 landlord insurance agents in Appleton, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Thiel Insurance Group, LLC620 N Richmond St(920) 739-6241
2Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance150 W Northland Ave(920) 730-1100
3Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent2711 N Mason St(920) 739-3003
4Comparion Insurance Agency2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400(920) 749-9799
5Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton ClaimsW6207 Aerotech Dr(920) 993-8550
6McHugh Family Insurance1400 N Rankin St(920) 364-9400
7Vizance2501 E Enterprise Ave Suite 301(920) 733-4944
8Packerland Insurance Advisors1011 N Lynndale Dr Ste 1B(920) 315-8412
9Monday and Associates, Inc.2500 N Richmond St(920) 306-6948
10Diedrich Family Insurance Agency225 N Richmond St #106(920) 733-7331
TI
620 N Richmond St
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC serves the Appleton, Wisconsin area and the surrounding county as a dedicated landlord insurance agent. The company assists property owners in securing coverage tailored to rental real estate. It works with clients to manage risks associated with residential and commercial rental properties. Policy options typically include protection for dwelling structures, liability coverage, and loss of rental income. Specific services handled in this area include guidance on property damage policies and advice for covering short-term rental exposures.

BB
150 W Northland Ave
Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance in Appleton, WI provides landlord insurance agent services, including property coverage and liability protection for rental properties. The company helps manage policies to address maintenance risks and tenant-related issues. Its agent’s work focuses on securing coverage options that align with local rental regulations and common landlord concerns. Brett Beaulieu: Allstate Insurance serves a range of properties such as single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

MH
2711 N Mason St
Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Matt Holtebeck - State Farm Insurance Agent in Appleton, Wisconsin serves local homeowners, small businesses, and property managers seeking landlord insurance. The agency helps rental property owners protect their investments with tailored coverage options for single-family homes, duplexes, and multi-unit buildings in the area. Policyholders receive guidance on liability protection, property damage, and loss of rental income. This office also serves clients in nearby Neenah within the Fox Cities metro region.

CI
2323 E Capitol Dr Ste 400
Comparion Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Comparion Insurance Agency in Appleton, Wisconsin serves landlords across the Fox Cities and surrounding communities, handling property insurance for rental homes, duplexes, and small apartment buildings. It helps local rental property owners address coverage needs such as dwelling protection and liability from tenant injuries. The agency typically approaches each client's situation by evaluating specific property risks and recommending appropriate coverage limits based on the type and condition of the rental.

AO
W6207 Aerotech Dr
Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton Claims
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Auto-Owners Insurance Appleton Claims offers landlords policies that can be selected as one‑time protection for a single property or recurring annual coverage for a portfolio of rentals. Coverage typically safeguards against property damage, liability from tenant injuries, and lost rental income during repairs. Serving Appleton, WI, this agent helps property owners tailor plans to local rental market conditions. Service appointments are available on an as‑needed basis for adjusting coverage or filing a new claim.

MF
1400 N Rankin St
McHugh Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Offering specialized coverage for residential rental properties, McHugh Family Insurance provides tailored landlord insurance policies in Appleton, Wisconsin. The agency works with local property owners to secure protection for single-family homes, duplexes, and small apartment buildings. Every policy can address building structure liability and potential loss of rental income. Common risks, such as tenant damage and weather-related claims, are covered through their standard offerings. As winter approaches, the agency also helps insureds understand how ice dams or frozen pipes may affect their property claims.

VI
2501 E Enterprise Ave Suite 301
Vizance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

As the winter freeze threatens properties in Appleton, WI, landlords often require specialized coverage to protect against burst pipes and ice dam liabilities. Vizance provides such landlord insurance policies tailored for local rental properties. Their agents focus on aligning policy limits with area building costs and vacancy risks. The process begins with a thorough assessment of the property, including a review of its current condition and rental history during an initial consultation.

PI
1011 N Lynndale Dr Ste 1B
Packerland Insurance Advisors
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Packerland Insurance Advisors serves Appleton, WI property owners, specializing in residential landlord insurance policies to protect rental homes. This coverage is complemented by commercial options designed for multi-unit buildings and larger rental properties. The agency extends its landlord insurance services throughout the broader Appleton area. When typical annual policy reviews occur, the company provides straightforward consultations to ensure coverage remains aligned with changing property needs. This consistent, reliable approach supports repeat service from existing clients who return between regular visits for policy adjustments or to discuss newly acquired rental units.

MA
2500 N Richmond St
Monday and Associates, Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Monday and Associates, Inc. provides landlord insurance agency services in the Appleton, Wisconsin area. Their work centers on property protection policies for residential and commercial rental properties, including specialized coverage for liability, loss of rental income, and property damage. They also serve clients needing landlord-specific endorsements like ordinance or law coverage and vandalism protection. Their clientele includes owners of office buildings, warehouses, and food service establishments.

DF
225 N Richmond St #106
Diedrich Family Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI

Diedrich Family Insurance Agency in Appleton, Wisconsin, is known for specializing in landlord insurance coverage for residential property owners. It offers policies that protect rental homes and duplexes from common risks such as fire damage and liability claims. The agency assists local landlords with tailoring a policy to match their specific income property needs. Additionally, Diedrich can help secure coverage for lost rental income when a property becomes uninhabitable after a covered loss. As a specialty service add-on, it can also include ordinance or law coverage for rebuilding to meet current codes.

VH
2500 N Richmond St
Van Handel Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-1440
vanhandelagency.com
TI
2100 S Kensington Dr #7
Total Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 731-3200
totalinsuranceappleton.com
JO
5700 W Grande Market Dr ste a
Jeff Oswald Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 202-8088
oswaldinsuranceagency.com/companies.html
TS
3325 N Ballard Rd
Trust Safe Insurance Agency WI
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 666-2783
HI
N365 Rogers Ln
Hurley Insurance Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 687-0687
erieinsurance.com
AA
4351 W College Ave
Ansay & Associates, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 560-7000
ansay.com
RM
2009 S Memorial Dr
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Adam Dockerty
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(608) 575-2847
ruralmutual.com/agent/adam-dockerty
SI
421 W Northland Ave
Smart Insurance Agency WI
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 696-9714
RM
3033 W Spencer St
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Jamie Lukes
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 832-0262
ruralmutual.com/agent/jamie-lukes
CI
611 N Lynndale Dr # 165
Calder Insurance Agency LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 735-9191
calderinsuranceappletonwi.com
KI
1000 W Wisconsin Ave #2
Koehn Insurance Agency, Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 739-7111
koehninsurance.com
BW
225 N Richmond St #106
Bob Walter Agency LLC: Diedrich Wendy
Landlord Insurance Agent · Appleton, WI
(920) 733-7331
diedrichagency.com/about

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Appleton Cost?

In Wisconsin landlord insurance typically costs 15 to 25 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single family rental in Appleton you might pay 800 to 1500 dollars per year. Costs depend on property age location and coverage limits. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Appleton

Appleton landlords need insurance that covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. Wisconsin law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often do. A local agent can help you understand policy options specific to Wisconsin weather risks like hail and snow load.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Wisconsin?

Standard landlord insurance covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. It does not cover tenant personal property. You may need additional coverage for flood or earthquake damage.

Is landlord insurance required by Wisconsin law?

Wisconsin law does not require landlord insurance. However your mortgage lender will likely require it. Many landlords also require tenants to carry renters insurance.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Appleton?

Look for an agent who specializes in rental properties and understands Wisconsin insurance regulations. Ask about coverage for vacant units and liability protection for slip and fall claims.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.