ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsIndiana › Indianapolis

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Indianapolis, IN

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Indianapolis, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Indianapolis, Indiana is Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group, rated 5.0 stars across 1,155 reviews. Other highly rated options include Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent, Danita Fields - State Farm Insurance Agent, Easy Street Insurance. This directory lists 55 medicare insurance agents serving Indianapolis.

Showing 55 medicare insurance agents in Indianapolis, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group7212 Shadeland Ave # 201(317) 350-1598
2Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent4010 E Southport Rd(317) 783-1367
3Danita Fields - State Farm Insurance Agent6835 E Southport Rd Ste C(317) 616-0136
4Easy Street Insurance8000 S Meridian St(317) 882-9602
5Steffey Insurance Agency3091 E 98th St SUITE 125(317) 334-3743
6Wenclewicz Insurance7202 Shadeland Ave # 207(317) 288-5099
7Breneman Insurance Group5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A(317) 786-2200
8Access Auto Insurance8249 Pendleton Pike(317) 890-4900
9Conner Insurance8445 Keystone Crossing #200
10HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117(317) 418-8271
SW
7212 Shadeland Ave # 201
Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group provides Medicare insurance guidance and plan selection services to clients throughout the Indianapolis area. It helps individuals evaluate their healthcare needs and navigate the complexities of Medicare parts and supplements. The company assists with annual enrollment changes and ongoing policy reviews to ensure coverage remains suitable. Its services benefit a wide range of clients, including those living in single-family homes, apartments, and similar residential properties.

SO
4010 E Southport Rd
Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Serving Indianapolis and surrounding central Indiana communities, Steve Oleksiw - State Farm Insurance Agent provides Medicare insurance agent services. This office handles questions about Medicare plans, including parts, supplements, and prescription drug coverage. Clients need to turn 65 or have specific disabilities to enroll. The agent’s approach involves reviewing individual health needs and budget, then comparing available plan options to find suitable coverage. Each consultation takes time to clarify confusing enrollment periods and coverage details, ensuring clients understand their choices before making a decision.

DF
6835 E Southport Rd Ste C
Danita Fields - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

With Medicare, clients can choose between one-time plan comparisons for immediate enrollment needs or scheduled annual reviews to adjust coverage as their health or budget shifts. Danita Fields - State Farm Insurance Agent, based in Indianapolis, IN, assists with Medicare supplements and Advantage plans, explaining how each option coordinates with Original Medicare. Service includes educational sessions on plan differences, premiums, and out-of-pocket costs. Appointments are available on an as-needed basis for policy changes or new enrollments.

ES
8000 S Meridian St
Easy Street Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As the annual Medicare Open Enrollment period approaches each fall in Indianapolis, Easy Street Insurance helps local residents navigate their coverage options. As a medicare insurance agent, this company assists clients in understanding the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. They also explain how Part D prescription drug coverage works and guide individuals through the enrollment process. Before making any recommendations, the agent typically conducts a thorough review of a client’s current healthcare needs and budget to find suitable matches for available plans.

SI
3091 E 98th St SUITE 125
Steffey Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Steffey Insurance Agency assists residents in the Indianapolis area with choosing Medicare insurance coverage that aligns with their individual healthcare needs. The agency also offers guidance on commercial insurance options for local businesses. Their service area encompasses the broader Indianapolis metropolitan region. The agents work with clients to understand policy details, ensuring clear explanations of available plan benefits. They encourage clients to schedule follow-up appointments for annual enrollment reviews so their coverage can be refined during regular visits between plan years.

WI
7202 Shadeland Ave # 207
Wenclewicz Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Wenclewicz Insurance helps individuals in Indianapolis navigate their Medicare options, focusing on supplemental plans and Part D prescription drug coverage. The agency assists clients in understanding the complexities of enrollment periods and plan choices available locally. As a Medicare insurance agent, the company works with those seeking to coordinate benefits with existing health coverage. It serves a range of commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments in the Indianapolis area.

BI
5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A
Breneman Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Breneman Insurance Group is a local Medicare insurance agent in Indianapolis that helps individuals navigate their options during enrollment periods. The company works with clients to compare Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans, explaining deductibles, copays, and coverage gaps in straightforward terms. It assists those turning sixty-five and people with disabilities newly eligible for Medicare. Services include a complimentary annual review of existing policies to identify potential savings. For clients seeking more hands-on guidance, the agency can also coordinate dental and vision plan add-on options.

AA
8249 Pendleton Pike
Access Auto Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Access Auto Insurance offers Medicare plan comparison and enrollment assistance to clients in Indianapolis, Indiana. The agency helps individuals navigate initial coverage options and annual plan changes. It provides straightforward guidance on Part D drug plans and Medicare Advantage selections. Its work focuses on finding suitable supplemental policies for local residents. As the annual Open Enrollment Period approaches each fall, the agency assists seniors in reviewing their current plans to avoid coverage gaps.

CI
8445 Keystone Crossing #200
Conner Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
HI
3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117
HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As the annual Medicare enrollment period approaches, many Indianapolis seniors carefully review their coverage options to ensure their health needs are met. HealthMarkets Insurance – Staci Lepsky provides guidance through Medicare Advantage, supplement, and Part D plans for residents in the area. The agency helps clients compare available policies and explains how each plan coordinates with original Medicare. An initial consultation begins with a no-obligation review of the individual’s current coverage and health requirements.

MI
345 Massachusetts Ave # 250
McGowan Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 464-5000
mcgowaninsgrp.com
JF
5455 W 86th St Suite 240
Josh Fields - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 875-0013
insurewithjoshfields.com
CI
4955 W Washington St D
CMR Insurance & Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 953-1850
cmrinsurance.net
PH
9765 Randall Dr
Premier Health Advisors
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 819-0140
mypremierhealthadvisors.com
MM
6329 Hollister Dr
McClain Matthews Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 298-7500
mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com
1I
4030 S Emerson Ave Suite B
A-1 Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 787-4995
a1insureit.com
NI
8435 Keystone Crossing #160
Nefouse Indiana Group Health Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 846-8615
nefousehealthinsurance.com
SH
4725 S Arlington Ave
Stacey Hamilton - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 780-0088
staceyhamilton.net
II
2818 N High School Rd
IAL Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 480-4111
ialinsurance.com
CI
350 Massachusetts Ave
Core Insurance Solutions
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 358-6780
coreinsurancesolns.com
JC
9423 Pendleton Pike
Jim Crinklaw - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 897-6129
jimcrinklaw.com
HI
1232 W 86th St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Michael Wehner
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(614) 270-9921
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mwehner
JI
5700 N College Ave
Jeremiah Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 506-2717
jeremiahinsuranceinc.com
BH
5135 S Emerson Ave ste o
Bart Hile - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 784-5044
myindyinsurance.com
JS
25 S Girls School Rd
Jim Shirey - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 248-8343
jimshireyinsurance.com
IB
5645 N Post Rd # C
Insurance By George
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 544-5207
insurancebygeorge.com
AS
3500 Depauw Blvd Suite 1054
Andrew Sandlin - HealthMarkets Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(574) 536-3947
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/asandlin
SM
8465 Keystone Crossing Suite 115 #1151
Senior Med Partners LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 809-5112
seniormedpartners.com
SN
7022 W 10th St Ste B
Scott Nichols - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 243-3509
scottknichols.com
JC
9165 Otis Ave #225
Jay Cox, CRFA - Your Medicare Advocate
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 559-2140
personalbenefitsservice.com
JR
6128 W 25th St
Jeff A. Rieser Agency, Inc American Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 280-0449
amfam.com/agents/indiana/indianapolis/jeffery-rieser
VI
5004 W 16th St
VP Insurance Agency, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 248-0070
vpinsuranceagency.com
GC
6451 Oaklandon Rd Ste C
Greg Clark - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 823-5877
gregclark.biz
HI
5730 N College Ave
HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Geighes
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 413-3280
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/cgeighes
MF
1060 N Capitol Ave Suite 3-101
Matthews Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 777-0857
mfinsurance.biz
SI
2323 E 58th St
Strategic Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 590-0943
stratins.com
BA
5236 Elmwood Ave
Barrett & Associates Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 783-9397
insurewithbarrett.com/about-us
SI
9333 N Meridian St #100
Shepherd Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 846-5554
shepherdins.com
VI
5631 W 44th St
VLauray Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 403-0311
vlaurayinsurance.com
PI
128 N Delaware St
Premium Insurance Service IN
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 210-5025
PA
5905 S Emerson Ave #400
Protect All Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 353-1121
UG
7440 Woodland Dr
UnitedHealthcare - Golden Rule Insurance Company
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 273-8115
uhone.com
JC
2915 N High School Rd
J C Smith Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 244-2707
jcsmithinsurance.com
II
9165 Otis Ave #238
IAmerica Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 250-7184
iamericainsurance.com
EG
5460 Victory Dr #100
Emerald Group Indy, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 353-3071
emeraldindy.com/contact-us
HA
1455 E Southport Rd Ste D
Hickman & Associates Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 788-7390
RI
10444 Indian Lake Blvd N
Robinson Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 610-9096
HC
6830 Indian Lake Rd
Harry Cangany & Associates
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 826-2460
cangany.com
IM
5061 E 71st St
Indy Medicare Specialist
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 331-6190
MI
2915 N High School Rd #106
Mateo Insurance Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 332-8082
mateoinsurance.com
SF
5135 S Emerson Ave ste o
State Farm Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 784-5044
statefarm.com/agent
MI
5730 W 74th St
Midwest Insurance Marketers of America, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 328-0800
mwima.com
SI
9165 Otis Ave #210
Simplified Insurance Solutions, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(888) 340-7633
simplifiedinsurancesolution.com
IH
5868 E 71st St Suite E-593
Indy Health Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 296-8881
indyhealthagent.com/indiana-health-insurance
MH
5120 Waybridge Ln
Medicare Health Plans Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 679-8935
medicarehealthplansagent.com

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Indianapolis Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Indianapolis do not charge you directly for their services. The insurance company pays the agent a commission from your premium. Medicare Part B premiums in 2024 start at $174.70 per month for most beneficiaries. Medicare Advantage plans may have $0 monthly premiums but include cost-sharing. Medigap plan premiums vary by age and carrier, typically ranging from $100 to $300 per month in Indiana. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Indianapolis

Medicare insurance agents in Indianapolis help residents navigate Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed and follow specific marketing guidelines set by the Indiana Department of Insurance. Local agents understand the network options available at major hospitals like IU Health and Community Health Network.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Indianapolis do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you compare plans, enroll in coverage, and understand your options. They can explain the differences between Medicare Advantage and Medigap policies available in Marion County.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Indiana?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Indiana also has an Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year.

Are Medicare insurance agents in Indianapolis free to use?

Yes, licensed agents are typically paid by insurance carriers, not by you. Their services are free to beneficiaries. Always confirm that the agent is appointed with the plans they present.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.