ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsIndiana › Michigan City

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Michigan City, IN

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Michigan City, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Michigan City, Indiana is Crowel Agency, Inc., rated 4.8 stars across 500 reviews. Other highly rated options include Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent, Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 18 medicare insurance agents serving Michigan City.

Showing 18 medicare insurance agents in Michigan City, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Crowel Agency, Inc.348 Dunes Plaza(219) 874-3800
2Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent605 Franklin St Suite A(219) 874-6360
3Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent405 Johnson Rd(219) 879-2329
4Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent2103 Franklin St(219) 879-4408
5General Insurance Services421 Franklin St(219) 879-4581
6Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.1905 Franklin St(219) 879-4343
7Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance1812 US-20(219) 879-5357
8Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance450 St John Rd Ste 109(219) 878-1884
9Warren Attar - State Farm Insurance Agent106 S Woodland Ct Suite #3(219) 210-4293
10Michiana Insurance Services5385 Johnson Rd(219) 879-6482
CA
348 Dunes Plaza
Crowel Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Crowel Agency, Inc. serves the Michigan City, Indiana area as a Medicare Insurance Agent. The company helps individuals navigate their Medicare options, including plan enrollment and annual changes. Its agents assist clients in understanding the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. They also guide seniors through the complexities of prescription drug coverage with Part D plans. Crowel Agency handles both Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plan enrollments for local residents.

NJ
605 Franklin St Suite A
Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Michigan City, Indiana, and the surrounding county, offering Medicare insurance guidance. The office helps individuals navigate their healthcare options and enrollment periods. It provides consultations to assess each client’s coverage needs and budget. The agency also assists with plan comparisons and annual updates to existing policies, ensuring clients have suitable healthcare solutions. Medicare supplement plans and Part D prescription drug coverage are among the specific services this agency handles in the Michigan City area.

AM
405 Johnson Rd
Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Andrew Mitchell, operating as a State Farm Insurance Agent in Michigan City, Indiana, offers a range of Medicare insurance services to help clients navigate their healthcare coverage options. The agency provides guidance on selecting suitable Medicare plans and offers ongoing support for policy maintenance and annual review needs. Residents can receive assistance with understanding plan benefits and enrollment periods. This agent services the coverage needs of individuals living in single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants.

CP
2103 Franklin St
Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners and local business owners in Michigan City, Indiana, helping them navigate Medicare insurance options. The agency assists clients with understanding plan choices, coverage details, and enrollment processes for medical and prescription drug needs. They work to explain how Medicare coordinates with other insurance policies. Their services extend to residents in nearby communities such as Long Beach and the greater LaPorte County area.

GI
421 Franklin St
General Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

General Insurance Services in Michigan City, Indiana offers a range of Medicare Insurance Agent services tailored to individuals navigating their healthcare coverage options. The company assists clients with plan selection, enrollment, and annual review services to ensure ongoing alignment with changing medical needs and budgets. Their support includes explanation of Medicare parts, supplement plans, and prescription drug coverage details. The agency serves individuals residing in single-family homes, apartments, and retirement communities throughout the local area.

SI
1905 Franklin St
Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc. in Michigan City, IN helps clients understand the difference between Original Medicare’s flexibility and the predictable cost-sharing of Medicare Advantage plans, while also explaining standalone Part D prescription drug coverage. As a medicare insurance agent, they guide seniors through annual enrollment periods and special election periods to match plans with individual healthcare needs and budgets. Their service operates on both one-time consultations for initial enrollment and as-needed updates whenever a client’s coverage requires revision or a plan change.

RP
1812 US-20
Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance serves Michigan City and the surrounding communities in LaPorte County, handling Medicare insurance plan enrollment and annual open enrollment needs. The agency clarifies Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug coverage options. It determines suitability by reviewing each client’s medical needs and preferred healthcare providers. A typical job begins with a consultation to compare available plans before guiding the client through a straightforward application process.

MC
450 St John Rd Ste 109
Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

As a Medicare insurance agent in Michigan City, IN, Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance provides guidance on Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. It also assists with prescription drug coverage options and enrollment paperwork. The agent helps local seniors understand how federal changes to Medicare may affect their existing coverage each fall. During the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period, it specifically helps clients evaluate whether their current plans still meet their health needs and budget for the upcoming year.

WA
106 S Woodland Ct Suite #3
Warren Attar - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Warren Attar - State Farm Insurance Agent works as a Medicare insurance agent in Michigan City, IN. Specializing in Medicare coverage, the agency helps clients navigate plan options and enrollment periods. The business assists individuals in understanding their healthcare needs and selecting appropriate supplemental benefits. Its services extend to commercial sectors, providing insurance solutions for offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

MI
5385 Johnson Rd
Michiana Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

With Medicare enrollment periods prompting many local residents to review their coverage, Michiana Insurance Services in Michigan City, IN assists individuals in evaluating their options. They help clients understand the differences between Medicare Advantage plans and Medigap policies. Each discussion begins with a review of the person’s current coverage and health care needs. Following this initial assessment, they outline available Medicare plans that suit those specific requirements. An in-person inspection of the applicant’s identification and current Medicare card is conducted before any enrollment steps begin.

IF
5416 Johnson Rd
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0607
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
DI
124 S Woodland Ct # D
Dolson Insurance agency inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 879-4524
dolsoninsuranceagency.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Shula Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
BI
1551 S Woodland Ave
Best Insurance IN
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 232-6841
HI
516 Wabash St
Haddad Insurance Agency LLC.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 259-5755
agents.farmers.com/in/michigan-city/joseph-haddad
AT
2004 US-20
Aaron Theophilus Agency Inc. American Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 878-9727
amfam.com/agents/indiana/michigan-city/aaron-theophilus
HM
1703 1/2 Franklin St
Health Markets
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 291-4449
healthmarkets.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Matt Shula Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/offices/shula-agency

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Michigan City Cost?

Medicare insurance agent services in Michigan City are generally free to consumers because agents are paid commissions by insurance carriers. However, the plans they recommend have monthly premiums that can range from $0 for some Medicare Advantage plans to over $200 for certain Medigap policies in Indiana. Costs vary based on your age, health, and plan choice. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Michigan City

Medicare insurance agents in Michigan City, Indiana help residents navigate Medicare options including Part A, Part B, Part D, and Medicare Advantage plans. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed by the state Department of Insurance. Local agents can assist with annual enrollment periods and special enrollment periods specific to Indiana regulations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Michigan City do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you compare plans, enroll in coverage, and understand your options. They can explain the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans available in LaPorte County.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Indiana?

The Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Indiana follows federal rules for the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year.

Are Medicare insurance agents in Michigan City free to use?

Most Medicare insurance agents are paid by insurance companies through commissions, so their services are typically free to you. Indiana law requires agents to disclose how they are compensated before you enroll.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.