ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsOhio › Columbus

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Columbus, OH

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Columbus, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio is Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 566 reviews. Other highly rated options include HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible, Buckeye Health Plan, Solid Insurance. This directory lists 33 medicare insurance agents serving Columbus.

Showing 33 medicare insurance agents in Columbus, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent2140 Riverside Dr ste b(614) 485-9077
2HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible38 Dillmont Dr(440) 503-5248
3Buckeye Health Plan4349 Easton Way #200(866) 246-4356
4Solid Insurance986 Morse Rd(614) 854-0000
5Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent2510 Billingsley Rd(614) 698-0028
6Sokol Eisenberg Insurance1620 E Broad St #103(614) 362-4262
7Elevate Insurance1156 Dublin Rd Suite 105(740) 531-5268
8Dan Coonfare Agency LLC1080 Fishinger Rd(614) 486-5400
9HealthMarkets Insurance - Kelly Parton4450 Kenny Rd(380) 444-5248
10Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC1500 W 3rd Ave #300F(614) 915-0977
KR
2140 Riverside Dr ste b
Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Columbus, Ohio metro area, providing guidance on Medicare insurance options. This agency helps local residents understand the differences between Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Advantage plans. Customers can receive assistance with plan selection and enrollment during open enrollment periods. The agent also offers annual policy reviews and helps compare the benefits of Part D prescription drug coverage.

HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible serves Columbus, Ohio, and the surrounding central Ohio communities, handling Medicare insurance plans for eligible individuals. It guides clients through Medicare Supplement, Advantage, and Part D drug coverage options available in the local market. Each appointment begins with a thorough review of the client’s current healthcare needs and budget, then compares plans to find a suitable fit.

BH
4349 Easton Way #200
Buckeye Health Plan
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Buckeye Health Plan provides Medicare insurance guidance to beneficiaries in Columbus, Ohio, helping them navigate plan options. The agency assists with enrolling in Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans, focusing on matching clients with suitable coverage for their medical needs. It offers annual plan reviews to ensure policies remain aligned with changing health requirements and budgets. The company serves individuals enrolled in Medicare, covering both those living in single-family homes and those residing in apartment complexes across the local area.

SI
986 Morse Rd
Solid Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Solid Insurance serves individuals and families across Columbus, Ohio who are exploring their Medicare coverage options for the first time or during enrollment periods. The agency helps clients compare Medicare Supplement plans, Medicare Advantage options, and Part D prescription drug coverage. Their agents provide personalized guidance to simplify the often complex selection process and ensure that each client finds a plan that fits their healthcare needs. They also extend their coverage assistance to residents in the nearby suburb of Worthington.

PL
2510 Billingsley Rd
Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent in Columbus helps clients distinguish between one-time enrollment under Original Medicare and recurring service plans through Medicare Advantage or Supplement policies. Coverage options are explained thoroughly to fit individual healthcare needs. Services are provided on an as-needed basis, accommodating schedule changes or questions that arise during the year, such as during open enrollment periods or life events that affect coverage.

SE
1620 E Broad St #103
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

As a Medicare insurance agent in Columbus, OH, Sokol Eisenberg Insurance specializes in helping clients navigate plan selection for medical and prescription drug coverage. It generally guides individuals through the annual enrollment process and explains the differences between Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans. A significant seasonal concern it helps with is the fall Open Enrollment Period, when clients must review their current coverage for potential changes in deductibles, out-of-pocket costs, or network providers.

EI
1156 Dublin Rd Suite 105
Elevate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

As the annual Medicare enrollment period approaches, many residents of Columbus examine their coverage options with care. Elevate Insurance assists local seniors and those turning sixty-five in understanding plan choices in the central Ohio area. They serve as a local medicare insurance agent, helping clients compare plans and navigate enrollment rules. The process begins with a free, no-obligation consultation to review individual healthcare needs and current prescriptions before exploring available options.

DC
1080 Fishinger Rd
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Dan Coonfare Agency LLC helps individuals understand their options for Medicare coverage in Columbus, Ohio. The agency specializes in Medicare insurance agent services, offering guidance on plans that work with prescription drug coverage and supplemental policies. Assistance is tailored to meet the needs of local residents looking for reliable coverage. It serves a variety of commercial sectors, including offices in the downtown area, warehouses in industrial zones, and food service operations throughout the city.

HI
4450 Kenny Rd
HealthMarkets Insurance - Kelly Parton
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

HealthMarkets Insurance - Kelly Parton serves residents in Columbus, Ohio, helping them navigate their health coverage options. The company also provides plans for local small businesses seeking employee benefits in the surrounding area. As a Medicare insurance agent, understanding the various supplement and advantage plans is essential for proper client guidance. Clients frequently return for annual enrollment period updates or to adjust coverage following changes in their health needs.

GI
1500 W 3rd Ave #300F
Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC is a dedicated medicare insurance agent serving clients in and around Columbus, Ohio. The agency helps individuals navigate Medicare options by explaining plan differences and enrollment periods. Their service range includes Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug coverage. Every recommendation is tailored to each client’s healthcare needs and budget. As a local agent, they provide ongoing support for annual plan reviews and beneficiary changes. To accommodate new Medicare enrollees, the agency also offers personalized guidance on how to avoid late enrollment penalties.

LG
1885 W 5th Ave
Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 451-2232
leavitt.com/midwest
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Phil Schopick - Call for a free consultation and virtual appointment
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 783-0381
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/pschopick
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Nanda Madadi
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 967-8500
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/nmadadi
EI
5354 N High St Suite 203
Eatmon Insurance Group ( Columbus Branch)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 502-2711
eatmonagency.com
FI
5898 Cleveland Ave
Ferrell Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 899-8867
progressiveagent.com/ferrell-insurance-agency-columbus
AW
3040 Riverside Dr #201
The Al Washington Ins Agy Ltd
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 564-9156
alwashingtoninsurance.com
CI
1201 Dublin Rd #151
CK Insurance Group, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 695-3330
ck-ins.com
HA
240 Collins Ave UNIT 2
Hyers & Associates Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(888) 901-5650
ohioinsureplan.com
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Mike Gatteri
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 568-1324
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mikegatteri
IA
686 Grandview Ave
Insurance Agents at AAA Grandview
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 488-2197
ohio.aaa.com/insurance.html
RI
1580 Fishinger Rd
Ray Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 459-1122
rayinsurance.com
MC
3100 Easton Square Pl Suite 300
Mount Carmel MediGold
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(866) 640-4101
thpmedicare.org/mount-carmel
HI
4766 N High St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Robert Crouch
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 324-2642
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/rcrouch
BI
3246 Noe Bixby Rd
Bepler Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 837-4379
beplerinsurance.com
MM
200 E Campus View Blvd STE 200
My Medicare Ohio
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(888) 644-6180
mymedicareohio.com
SI
120 Mill St
Schneider Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 471-8444
schneiderins.com
HI
38 Dillmont Dr Suite B8/B9
HealthMarkets Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 785-9405
agents.healthmarkets.com/Columbus
BA
170 S Yearling Rd #1868
Baum & Associates Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 237-7683
baum.webagent4u.com
BT
2369 E Main St
Bexley Title Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 236-0208
SE
815 Grandview Ave #200
Structured Employee Benefits of Ohio, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(800) 589-7326
sebohio.com
RI
2770 E Main St #1
Reed Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 236-1787
MR
5212 N High St
Medicare Resource Center
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 802-7302
medicareoh.com
CL
By Appt, 2815 E Main St
Chad Little Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 305-4495
chadlittleagency.com

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Columbus Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Ohio do not charge you a fee for their services. Their compensation comes from the insurance companies whose plans they sell. Plan premiums vary widely for example a Medigap Plan G in Columbus may cost between 120 and 250 dollars per month depending on your age and health status. Medicare Advantage plans often have a 0 dollar monthly premium but may have copays and deductibles. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Columbus

Medicare insurance agents in Columbus Ohio help residents compare Medicare Advantage Medigap and Part D plans. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed by the Ohio Department of Insurance and to follow state rules on plan marketing and enrollment. Local agents understand the specific network options available at OhioHealth and Wexner Medical Center.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Columbus do?

A Medicare agent helps you review your coverage needs compare plans from different carriers and enroll in a plan that fits your budget and health care preferences. They provide guidance on the differences between Original Medicare Medicare Advantage and Medigap.

When can I enroll in a Medicare plan in Ohio?

The Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Ohio also has an Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year. Special Enrollment Periods are available for certain life events like moving or losing other coverage.

Are Medicare agents in Ohio paid by me or by the insurance company?

Medicare agents are typically compensated by the insurance carrier not by you directly. Their commissions are built into the plan premiums. You should ask your agent to explain their compensation before you enroll.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.