ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Mentor, OH

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Mentor, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Mentor, Ohio is Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile, rated 4.8 stars across 193 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bosu Insurance Group, Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc, Caswell and Associates LLC. This directory lists 21 medicare insurance agents serving Mentor.

Showing 21 medicare insurance agents in Mentor, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile7538 Mentor Ave(440) 901-5596
2Bosu Insurance Group8619 Mentor Ave(440) 954-9500
3Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc7464 Mentor Ave(440) 525-3923
4Caswell and Associates LLC9179 Mentor Ave unit h(440) 255-8400
5Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc8810 Tyler Blvd(216) 486-4170
6Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD7352 Center St(440) 255-3411
7Debbie George - State Farm Insurance Agent7340 Center St(440) 255-3444
8Corsaro Insurance Group8039 Broadmoor Rd(440) 946-4950
9Platinum Insurance7200 Center St Suite 328(833) 299-2100
10AAA Mentor Insurance and Member Services6980 Heisley Rd(440) 974-0990
FI
7538 Mentor Ave
Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile serves the Mentor, Ohio, area as a local medicare insurance agent. The company helps clients evaluate their health coverage options during annual enrollment periods. It provides guidance on navigating plan choices, ensuring individuals understand their benefits and out-of-pocket costs. As a local resource, this agency assists with comparing Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans available in Lake County.

BI
8619 Mentor Ave
Bosu Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Bosu Insurance Group provides Medicare insurance guidance to residents in Mentor, Ohio, assisting with plan comparisons during enrollment periods. Its services include explaining coverage options under Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans. The agency helps clients review annual changes and navigate plan adjustments to maintain appropriate healthcare access. Bosu Insurance Group services clients residing in single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

BI
7464 Mentor Ave
Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Serving Mentor, Ohio, and the surrounding Lake County communities, Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc. specializes in helping individuals navigate Medicare insurance plans. The agency assists clients in understanding their coverage options, including Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. Each client’s unique health care needs and budget are carefully reviewed to identify suitable choices. The typical job is handled through a step-by-step consultation process, starting with a personal needs assessment and ending with the presentation of multiple plan comparisons for informed client decision-making.

CA
9179 Mentor Ave unit h
Caswell and Associates LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Caswell and Associates LLC serves local residents and families in Mentor, Ohio, who are seeking guidance on Medicare insurance options. The agency assists clients with understanding plan choices, enrollment periods, and coverage details. This includes help for those new to Medicare or those reassessing existing plans. The agents explain plan differences clearly and help individuals find appropriate coverage for their healthcare needs. Caswell and Associates also provides its Medicare insurance agent services to clients throughout nearby communities in the greater Lake County area, including Willoughby and Painesville.

FC
8810 Tyler Blvd
Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Some clients seek a one-time review of their current Medicare coverage, while others need ongoing annual plan comparisons and enrollment updates. Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc in Mentor, OH helps individuals understand their Medicare Advantage and supplement options. The agency explains how each plan type affects out-of-pocket costs and provider access. They support both new enrollees and those eligible to switch during special periods. This service structure operates on an as-needed basis, with no obligation for recurring appointments.

SI
7352 Center St
Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

As Medicare open enrollment approaches each fall, residents of Mentor and surrounding communities review their prescription drug and medical plan options. Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD offers local guidance through the complexities of plan comparisons and budget adjustments for the coming year. They review both coverage details and network participation to match each client’s current needs. The initial step is a complimentary benefits assessment conducted at their Ohio office, where clients bring a list of current medications and preferred providers.

DG
7340 Center St
Debbie George - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Debbie George - State Farm Insurance Agent in Mentor, OH, specializes in Medicare insurance guidance, helping clients navigate plan options and enrollment periods. The agency also offers general insurance services to address broader personal coverage needs. Assistance is tailored to individuals transitioning onto Medicare or adjusting existing plans. During the annual open enrollment period from October to December, the office focuses on reviewing current coverage and helping beneficiaries select plans that align with their healthcare and budget requirements.

CI
8039 Broadmoor Rd
Corsaro Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Corsaro Insurance Group serves Medicare clients in Mentor, OH, addressing personal health coverage needs for area residents. The business also offers commercial insurance plans for local enterprises. Serving the broader Mentor area, the agency provides guidance through Medicare’s enrollment periods and plan options. Clients can expect assistance with initial selections as well as ongoing support, including scheduled follow-up meetings or annual reviews between regular visits to adjust coverage as circumstances change.

PI
7200 Center St Suite 328
Platinum Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Platinum Insurance in Mentor, Ohio, is known for guiding residents through their Medicare options. Their services range from explaining initial enrollment to reviewing existing coverage for changes. This Medicare insurance agent helps clients navigate Plan A and Plan B components as well as Medicare Advantage plans and Part D prescription drug plans. An additional service they provide includes consulting on Medicare Supplement policies to help cover deductibles and copayments not addressed by Original Medicare.

AM
6980 Heisley Rd
AAA Mentor Insurance and Member Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

AAA Mentor Insurance and Member Services in Mentor, OH provides guidance on Medicare insurance options for local residents. The agency specializes in navigating Medicare supplements, Advantage plans, and Part D prescription drug coverage to help individuals find suitable health coverage. Their services are available to a wide range of clientele, including those managing solo professional practices, corporate office environments, large warehouse facilities, and food service industry operations.

LS
9167 Mentor Ave
Lake Shore Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 701-6900
lakeshoreinsurance.com
MI
6982 Spinach Dr
Mutsko Insurance Services, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 255-5700
mutskoinsurance.com
SI
9354 Mentor Ave #15th
Sposito Insurance Agency Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 255-1766
spositoagency.com
SH
7523 Tyler Blvd
Smart Home Insurance Agency Mentor
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 252-0241
TB
7234 Center St
Trust Bloom Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 201-9915
getohi.com
AI
9930 Johnnycake Ridge Rd suite #1E
Anchor Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 354-4933
anchorinsurancegroup.com
RS
8339 Tyler Blvd
Risk Strategies
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 205-7400
HP
7850 Mentor Ave
Health Plan Superstore
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 508-6757
healthplansuperstore.com
HI
7015 Center St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Dat Thanh Nguyen
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(404) 775-0828
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/dnguyen
KC
9169 Mentor Ave
KAZ Company (Eastern Branch)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 946-3944
medicareplansneo.com
YM
7537 Mentor Ave
Your Medicare Options
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 306-8349
yourmedicareoptions.net/contact-us

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Mentor Cost?

Medicare Part A is usually premium free for most beneficiaries who paid Medicare taxes. Part B has a standard monthly premium of $174.70 in 2024 for most enrollees. Medigap plans in Ohio can cost between $50 and $300 per month depending on the plan type and your age. Part D prescription drug plans have premiums that range from about $10 to $100 per month. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Mentor

Medicare insurance agents in Mentor Ohio help residents compare plans and enroll in coverage that fits their needs. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed by the Ohio Department of Insurance and follow strict rules about marketing and enrollment periods. Working with a local agent can make it easier to understand Medicare Advantage Medigap and Part D options available in Lake County.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in Mentor Ohio?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Ohio residents also have a General Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31 each year if they missed their initial window.

What Medicare plans are available in Mentor Ohio?

Mentor residents can choose between Original Medicare Medicare Advantage plans Part D prescription drug plans and Medigap supplement plans. Plan availability varies by carrier and your specific zip code in Lake County.

Do Medicare agents in Ohio charge a fee for their help?

Licensed Medicare insurance agents in Ohio typically do not charge clients directly. They receive commissions from the insurance companies whose plans they sell. You should confirm this arrangement with any agent before working with them.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.