ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Anderson, IN

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Anderson, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Anderson, Indiana is Roger Roudebush - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 683 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mesha McCarty - State Farm Insurance Agent, Acceptance Insurance, Mike Gaskill - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Anderson.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Anderson, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Roger Roudebush - State Farm Insurance Agent421 W 53rd St(765) 649-2266
2Mesha McCarty - State Farm Insurance Agent1125 Broadway St(765) 642-9903
3Acceptance Insurance2213 S Scatterfield Rd Suite 5(765) 570-7000
4Mike Gaskill - State Farm Insurance Agent16 E 29th St(765) 640-8888
5Farmers Insurance - Jon Meeks722 E 8th St(765) 644-4663
6Shelter Insurance - Mary Guirguis426 E 14th St(765) 644-6937
7Howard Webb Insurance and Real Estate525 E 8th St(765) 644-8847
8McBee Insurance Agency1025 E 53rd St(765) 640-1400
9Evergreen Insurance1201 E 5th St Suite 205(765) 374-5103
10Shelter Insurance - Laura Sandlin1119 Meridian St Ste 100(765) 640-9630
RR
421 W 53rd St
Roger Roudebush - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Roger Roudebush - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Anderson, Indiana area as a supplemental insurance agent. This agency helps local residents and families by offering policies that fill gaps left by primary health or life coverage. The agent works to explain how supplemental plans can cover deductibles, copays, or other out-of-pocket expenses. Services include helping individuals compare and select hospital indemnity plans to manage unexpected medical costs. The office also assists clients with accident insurance policies for injury-related expenses.

MM
1125 Broadway St
Mesha McCarty - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Mesha McCarty - State Farm Insurance Agent in Anderson, IN provides supplemental insurance policies that help cover gaps left by primary health plans. These plans typically assist with out-of-pocket costs such as deductibles, copays, and hospital stays. Routine policy reviews and claims support are available to ensure coverage remains aligned with changing needs. This local agency serves a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

AI
2213 S Scatterfield Rd Suite 5
Acceptance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Acceptance Insurance provides a range of supplemental insurance agent services to individuals and businesses in Anderson, Indiana. It assists clients in selecting and maintaining policies that cover gaps in primary health, accident, or life coverage. The company helps manage policy renewals and claims support to ensure continuous protection for its customers. It services a variety of property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

MG
16 E 29th St
Mike Gaskill - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Mike Gaskill - State Farm Insurance Agent in Anderson, IN, serves homeowners and local business owners seeking supplemental insurance coverage for gaps in primary policies. The agency helps clients explore options like accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity plans to provide added financial protection. Services are tailored to each customer’s existing health or property insurance, offering a focused approach without unnecessary extras. Coverage is also extended to residents and businesses in nearby Pendleton and the greater Madison County area.

FI
722 E 8th St
Farmers Insurance - Jon Meeks
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Farmers Insurance - Jon Meeks serves Anderson and the surrounding communities in Madison County, handling supplemental insurance policies for individuals and families. It offers coverage options designed to fill gaps left by primary health or life insurance plans. Typical needs addressed include accident, hospital indemnity, and critical illness protection. A client meeting first reviews existing coverage to identify potential financial risks or coverage shortfalls. The agent then presents personalized plan comparisons to explain how different supplemental benefits work and recommends a solution based on an individual's specific situation and budget.

SI
426 E 14th St
Shelter Insurance - Mary Guirguis
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Shelter Insurance - Mary Guirguis in Anderson, Indiana, specializes as a supplemental insurance agent, offering policies that help cover gaps left by primary health plans. Its general services include guiding clients through Medigap, cancer, accident, and critical illness coverage options to ensure greater financial protection. As colder months increase the risk of seasonal accidents or illness, the agent’s supplemental plans can help manage unexpected medical costs arising from winter-related health concerns.

HW
525 E 8th St
Howard Webb Insurance and Real Estate
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

As the seasons change in Anderson, supplemental insurance needs often shift with new health and financial priorities. Howard Webb Insurance and Real Estate offers local guidance on filling the coverage gaps left by major medical plans, such as accident or critical illness policies. Their work focuses on matching residents with straightforward supplemental plans that help manage out-of-pocket costs. To begin this process, the agent first conducts a review of each client’s existing coverage to identify where extra protection is most needed before offering tailored policy options.

MI
1025 E 53rd St
McBee Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Residents of Anderson, Indiana, choose between one-time plans covering specific medical gaps and recurring policies for ongoing protection. McBee Insurance Agency specializes in supplemental insurance, which helps pay for expenses like deductibles or co-pays not fully covered by major medical plans. Area clients often use these offerings for income replacement during illness or injury recovery. Service appointments are arranged on an as-needed basis, allowing policyholders to request consultations or claim assistance whenever a particular need arises without a fixed schedule.

EI
1201 E 5th St Suite 205
Evergreen Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Evergreen Insurance assists individuals in Anderson, IN, in evaluating their existing health coverage and identifying potential gaps. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company specializes in policies that address additional costs not covered by primary medical plans, such as dental, vision, critical illness, or accident benefits. These options help clients manage out-of-pocket expenses after a procedure or unexpected event. The firm can serve a variety of commercial sectors, including office workers needing income protection, warehouse staff facing higher injury risks, and food service employees requiring tailored gap coverage.

SI
1119 Meridian St Ste 100
Shelter Insurance - Laura Sandlin
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN

Shelter Insurance - Laura Sandlin serves Anderson, Indiana, as a supplemental insurance agent. The agency provides residential supplemental coverage designed to fill gaps left by primary health plans, offering local support for claims and policy questions. Commercial supplemental options are also available for small businesses in the greater Madison County area. An agent handles initial enrollments and can follow up with clients between regular visits to review changing needs or assist with benefit claims, ensuring ongoing support throughout the policy year.

AA
3414 Main St
Acrisure Anderson, IN (Thompson Insurance & Financial Services)
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 644-6787
acrisure.com
MI
30 W 11th St
McGowan Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 400-5594
mcgowaninsgrp.com
LB
2009 E 10th St
Lon Brown Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 643-5555
lonbrownins.com
PC
2701 Enterprise Dr
Platinum Coverage Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(317) 446-9454
platinumcoverageinsurance.com
IF
4528 S Scatterfield Rd
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 649-0471
infarmbureau.com/offices/Madison/Anderson
MI
4911 IN-9
Masters Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 649-1170
insurewithmasters.com
PW
1309 Park Rd
Peck & Wood Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 644-2591
peckandwoodinsurance.com
BI
141 W 22nd St
Bright Insurance Services IN
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(317) 552-1314
PC
5952 Alexandria Pike
Prime Cover Insurance Indiana
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 642-9997
overdorffinancial.net/our-story
RI
1908 Mounds Rd
Rk Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Anderson, IN
(765) 643-4655

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Anderson Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in Anderson vary by plan type, age, and health status. A Medicare Supplement Plan G for a 65-year-old in Indiana typically ranges from $100 to $200 per month. Cancer or critical illness policies may cost $30 to $100 per month. Hospital indemnity plans often range from $50 to $150 per month. These are general estimates and your actual cost will depend on your specific situation. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Anderson

Supplemental insurance agents in Anderson, Indiana help residents fill gaps in their primary health coverage. These agents can explain plans like Medicare Supplement (Medigap) which must follow Indiana standardized benefit plans. Local agents also offer cancer, accident, and critical illness policies regulated by the Indiana Department of Insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the open enrollment period for Medicare Supplement in Indiana?

In Indiana, the Medicare Supplement open enrollment period lasts six months and starts when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time, insurers cannot deny you coverage or charge higher premiums due to pre-existing conditions.

Are supplemental insurance agents in Anderson licensed by the state?

Yes, all supplemental insurance agents in Indiana must hold a valid license from the Indiana Department of Insurance. You can verify an agents license status on the department website.

Can I switch supplemental insurance plans in Indiana at any time?

Switching plans depends on the type of policy. For Medicare Supplement plans, Indiana law does not guarantee a right to switch outside of open enrollment or special circumstances. For other supplemental policies, you may switch at renewal or during a free look period, but pre-existing condition waiting periods may apply.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.