ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Wauwatosa, WI

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin is Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance, rated 4.9 stars across 176 reviews. Other highly rated options include Ron Grumley: Allstate Insurance, Spring Burgess-Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent, Camilla Jarman American Family Insurance. This directory lists 13 supplemental insurance agents serving Wauwatosa.

Showing 13 supplemental insurance agents in Wauwatosa, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance10125 W North Ave #2426(262) 649-2063
2Ron Grumley: Allstate Insurance8112 W Bluemound Rd Ste 104(414) 761-0996
3Spring Burgess-Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent1233 N Mayfair Rd Ste 104(414) 263-1440
4Camilla Jarman American Family Insurance6325 W North Ave(414) 475-6226
5Robert Mallow American Family Insurance12201 W Burleigh St #4(414) 302-1000
6Dan Schani Insurance Agency10425 W North Ave #226(414) 732-2542
7Augustine Agency LLC American Family Insurance11616 W North Ave D(414) 755-8890
8Unisource Insurance Associates, LLC10425 W North Ave #226(414) 774-7040
9Tosa Insurance Agency, LLC7206 W North Ave(414) 454-8672
10Magnolia Insurance Group11220 W Burleigh St #100(262) 208-3108
SI
10125 W North Ave #2426
Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC, doing business as Cream City Insurance, serves the Wauwatosa metro area and Milwaukee County. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company helps clients fill coverage gaps left by primary health plans. It works with individuals to manage out-of-pocket expenses from medical events. Common policies address accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity needs. The agency can assist with enrolling in dental and vision plans.

RG
8112 W Bluemound Rd Ste 104
Ron Grumley: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Ron Grumley: Allstate Insurance provides a range of supplemental insurance options, including accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity policies, to help clients manage out-of-pocket medical costs. Regular policy reviews are offered to ensure coverage adapts to changing health needs and life circumstances. The agency serves the Wauwatosa, WI area, catering to individual policyholders in single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants.

SB
1233 N Mayfair Rd Ste 104
Spring Burgess-Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Spring Burgess-Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners, renters, and small business owners in the Wauwatosa area. The agency focuses on supplemental insurance solutions, offering policies that help cover gaps left by standard health or property plans. Clients can discuss personal needs with an agent to find suitable options for life, health, or accident protection. The office provides straightforward guidance on available supplemental products. It also serves neighboring communities such as Brookfield across the west metro region.

CJ
6325 W North Ave
Camilla Jarman American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Serving Wauwatosa, WI, and its surrounding communities, Camilla Jarman American Family Insurance helps clients select supplemental insurance policies to cover gaps left by major medical plans. The agency handles options for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage, aiming to manage unexpected out-of-pocket costs. To match a policy to individual needs, the agent first reviews a client’s existing health coverage and daily financial exposures before presenting tailored benefit structures.

RM
12201 W Burleigh St #4
Robert Mallow American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Robert Mallow American Family Insurance in Wauwatosa, WI offers supplemental insurance agents who distinguish between one-time policy options and recurring coverage plans. Supplemental insurance helps fill gaps left by primary health plans, providing financial support for events like accidents or critical illnesses. The agency assists clients in understanding the value of both term and permanent coverage types. Service appointments are available on a scheduled or as-needed basis, accommodating individual needs for policy reviews or new enrollments.

DS
10425 W North Ave #226
Dan Schani Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Dan Schani Insurance Agency offers supplemental insurance, covering gaps left by major medical plans in Wauwatosa. Its general service work helps clients navigate policy options for dental, vision, or accident coverage. The agency focuses on providing affordable, targeted protection that complements existing health plans. As the end of the year approaches, it assists residents in reviewing their current benefits to enroll in plans that address upcoming deductible periods.

AA
11616 W North Ave D
Augustine Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

As winter approaches in Wauwatosa, residents often review their existing coverage to ensure they are prepared for seasonal risks. Augustine Agency LLC American Family Insurance assists local individuals and families by offering supplemental insurance agent services designed to fill gaps in standard health or life policies. These plans can help cover out-of-pocket costs from unexpected medical events or accidents. An initial consultation typically begins with a straightforward review of a client's current benefits and personal circumstances to identify potential coverage needs.

UI
10425 W North Ave #226
Unisource Insurance Associates, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Unisource Insurance Associates, LLC in Wauwatosa, WI assists local clients with their primary health coverage needs. The company specializes in supplemental insurance products that help fill gaps left by standard plans. These offerings provide additional financial support for specific medical events or routine care. Professionals may secure coverage for offices, warehouses, and food service operations to protect against income loss and unexpected healthcare costs.

TI
7206 W North Ave
Tosa Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Tosa Insurance Agency, LLC serves residents in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, helping individuals select supplemental insurance to fill gaps in their primary health coverage. The agency also assists local businesses with commercial supplemental insurance products tailored to their workforce needs. Their service area encompasses Wauwatosa and the surrounding Milwaukee County communities. Clients working with Tosa Insurance Agency can expect personalized guidance through annual enrollment periods and the option to schedule follow-up consultations between regular plan review visits to adjust coverage as circumstances change.

MI
11220 W Burleigh St #100
Magnolia Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI

Magnolia Insurance Group in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, is known for helping clients select supplemental insurance policies that fill gaps in their primary health coverage. Its service range includes Medicare supplement plans and dental insurance for individuals seeking more predictable healthcare costs in the Wauwatosa area. The company typically offers a straightforward application process for qualified residents. During an initial consultation, a supplemental insurance agent can add hospital indemnity coverage to ready cash benefits during inpatient stays.

BI
10721 W Capitol Dr Ste 221
Bell Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI
(414) 988-8111
linkedin.com/in/BellInsuranceAgencyLLC
LN
10425 W North Ave #226
Lori Nondahl Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI
(262) 613-2257
unisourceinsurance.com
DW
933 N Mayfair Rd # 201
Den-Wu SR22 Insurance Agency Wisconsin
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Wauwatosa, WI
(262) 310-7433

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Wauwatosa Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Wisconsin vary by plan type age and carrier. Medigap Plan G premiums in Wauwatosa typically range from 120 to 250 dollars per month for a 65 year old. Plan N may cost 90 to 180 dollars per month. Rates can increase over time due to inflation and claims experience. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Wauwatosa

Supplemental insurance agents in Wauwatosa help residents find Medigap and other gap coverage policies. Wisconsin law provides special enrollment protections under Wis. Stat. 632.745 for Medicare supplement plans. These agents can guide you through plan options that work with your existing coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Wauwatosa?

A supplemental insurance agent in Wauwatosa helps you find policies that cover costs not paid by Medicare or your primary health plan. They are licensed in Wisconsin and understand local insurance rules.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin you have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you are both 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting.

Do Wisconsin agents offer free quotes for supplemental insurance?

Yes most supplemental insurance agents in Wauwatosa provide free quotes and consultations. They can compare plans from different carriers to find coverage that fits your needs and budget.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.