ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsFlorida › Marco Island

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Marco Island, FL

Browse auto insurance agents serving Marco Island, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Marco Island, Florida is Progressive Auto Center / Valvoline Express Care, rated 4.3 stars across 150 reviews. Other highly rated options include Forsythe Insurance Services, Troy Baker: Allstate Insurance, Progressive Auto Center. This directory lists 16 auto insurance agents serving Marco Island.

Showing 16 auto insurance agents in Marco Island, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Progressive Auto Center / Valvoline Express Care740 Bald Eagle Dr(239) 642-4944
2Forsythe Insurance Services995 N Collier Blvd(239) 393-4100
3Troy Baker: Allstate Insurance901 N Collier Blvd(239) 642-1035
4Progressive Auto Center720 Bald Eagle Dr(239) 642-4944
5First American Title Insurance Company1118 N Collier Blvd(239) 394-4888
6Insurance Solutions of SW Fl1721 San Marco Rd # D(239) 642-0200
7First Title & Abstract Inc606 Bald Eagle Dr(239) 262-6455
8Integrity Insurance International Inc.950 N Collier Blvd STE 301(239) 393-3407
9A.R.A. Insurance, Inc.583 Tallwood St Suite 102(239) 394-0888
10Michele Sanchez Insurance Agency950 N Collier Blvd UNIT 426(239) 682-8567
PA
740 Bald Eagle Dr
Progressive Auto Center / Valvoline Express Care
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Progressive Auto Center / Valvoline Express Care serves Marco Island, Florida, as a local auto insurance agent. It helps customers navigate insurance options to find appropriate coverage for their vehicles. The agency works with different carriers to obtain quotes and provides guidance on policy choices tailored to individual driving needs. It also assists with policy changes and coverage questions. In this area, the company handles new policy enrollment and claims support for auto insurance clients.

FI
995 N Collier Blvd
Forsythe Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Forsythe Insurance Services provides auto insurance policies tailored for standard and high-risk drivers in the Marco Island area. It assists clients in selecting appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. Regular policy reviews and claims support are included to help maintain adequate protection. The agency serves drivers of single-family homes, apartments, and local businesses including retail and restaurants.

TB
901 N Collier Blvd
Troy Baker: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Homeowners, business owners, and property managers on Marco Island turn to Troy Baker: Allstate Insurance for their auto insurance agent services. This agency provides personal and commercial auto policies to help protect vehicles and drivers against unforeseen losses. Assistance with policy reviews and claims filing helps clients manage their coverage needs. Residents and businesses requiring personalized insurance guidance can rely on this local partner for their auto protection needs. The agency also serves automobile owners in neighboring Naples and the broader Collier County area.

PA
720 Bald Eagle Dr
Progressive Auto Center
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Progressive Auto Center serves Marco Island and the surrounding communities of Southwest Florida, handling personal auto insurance policies for local drivers. It assists clients with coverage options suited to regional needs and average commute patterns. Common policy types include liability, collision, and comprehensive plans. The agency approaches each job by first reviewing a driver’s current coverage and then explaining available choices to fit their specific situation. It works directly with each customer to compare deductibles and limits before finalizing the policy.

FA
1118 N Collier Blvd
First American Title Insurance Company
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

First American Title Insurance Company serves Marco Island, Florida, as an auto insurance agent handling both single-purchase policies for specific vehicles and ongoing plans with periodic renewals. They provide standard coverage options like liability, collision, and comprehensive protection tailored to local driving conditions, including risks from coastal weather patterns and tourist-heavy traffic. Their services operate on either a one-time or scheduled basis, depending on whether clients need a short-term single policy or a long-term plan with regular billing cycles.

IS
1721 San Marco Rd # D
Insurance Solutions of SW Fl
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Offering tailored coverage options for standard and high-risk vehicles, Insurance Solutions of SW Fl serves as an auto insurance agent located in Marco Island, FL. It evaluates individual driving habits and vehicle types to recommend appropriate liability and comprehensive policies. Working with multiple major carriers, the agency also assists clients with bundling home and auto policies for streamlined management. As hurricane season approaches, it helps local drivers review their deductibles and flood coverage to ensure adequate protection against storm-related damage.

FT
606 Bald Eagle Dr
First Title & Abstract Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

As Marco Island’s seasonal population swells each winter, residents and visitors alike require reliable auto insurance coverage that protects their vehicles against Florida’s unique weather and traffic challenges. First Title & Abstract Inc located in Marco Island helps local drivers navigate policy options for liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. The team conducts a thorough review of each client’s driving history and vehicle details before scheduling a convenient in-person or virtual consultation to begin the coverage assessment.

II
950 N Collier Blvd STE 301
Integrity Insurance International Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Located in Marco Island, Florida, Integrity Insurance International Inc. provides auto insurance coverage for personal and commercial vehicles. Its specialty add-ons include roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement, which protect drivers against unexpected travel disruptions. The agency focuses on tailoring liability, collision, and comprehensive policies to individual budgets and driving habits. It can serve commercial sectors such as offices, warehouses, and food service operations by securing both fleet and single‑vehicle coverage, ensuring businesses remain protected against liability and property damage while their vehicles are on the road.

RI
583 Tallwood St Suite 102
A.R.A. Insurance, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

A.R.A. Insurance, Inc. serves residents of Marco Island, Florida, with personalized auto insurance policies tailored to local driving needs. The agency also offers commercial coverage for area businesses and can assist drivers throughout the surrounding region. Clients receive clear explanations of their coverage options from a dedicated agent. The office works to ensure customers are properly protected and often follows up to adjust policies when life circumstances change between regular renewal visits.

MS
950 N Collier Blvd UNIT 426
Michele Sanchez Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL

Michele Sanchez Insurance Agency in Marco Island, FL, is known for providing personal auto insurance policies to area drivers. It assists clients in selecting coverage that meets state requirements and protects against common road risks. The agency works with local residents to explain liability, collision, and comprehensive options for their vehicles. As an auto insurance agent, it offers tailored solutions suited to different driving needs and budgets. For added protection, it can arrange roadside assistance service to include with any policy.

AI
601 E Elkcam Cir
Artisan Insurance Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 235-9520
artisaninsuranceinc.com
GT
950 N Collier Blvd STE 205
Greg Thomas Insurance Agency is Now Proudly Partnered with Acentria Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 642-5560
gregthomasinsurance.com
FI
886 Park Ave #101-102
Forsythe Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 393-4100
forsythe-insurance.com
MF
847 N Collier Blvd
Marco Financial Services Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 394-1291
AI
606 Bald Eagle Dr
Advanced Insurance Underwriters
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 393-4100
advancedins.com
LI
740 N Collier Blvd # 103
Lutgert Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Marco Island, FL
(239) 394-7575
lutgertinsurance.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Marco Island Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in Florida is higher than the national average, often ranging from 1500 to 3000 dollars per year for minimum coverage. Full coverage policies can cost between 2500 and 5000 dollars annually depending on your driving record, vehicle type, and coverage limits. Marco Island residents may see slightly different rates due to local risk factors. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Marco Island

An auto insurance agent in Marco Island Florida can help you meet state requirements and find coverage for your vehicle. Florida law requires all drivers to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) of at least 10000 dollars and Property Damage Liability of 10000 dollars. A local agent understands the unique driving conditions on the island and can explain how your policy works in this coastal area.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Florida?

Florida law requires 10000 dollars in Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and 10000 dollars in Property Damage Liability (PDL). PIP covers your medical expenses regardless of fault, while PDL covers damage you cause to another persons property. An agent can help you decide if higher limits are right for your situation.

Do I need uninsured motorist coverage in Marco Island?

Uninsured motorist coverage is not required by Florida law but is strongly recommended. It covers your injuries if you are hit by a driver without insurance. An agent on Marco Island can explain how this coverage works and help you choose appropriate limits.

How does my auto insurance work if I drive to the beach or park on the island?

Your auto insurance policy generally covers your vehicle anywhere in Florida, including Marco Island beaches and parking areas. However, flood damage from storm surge or high tides is typically not covered by standard auto policies. An agent can discuss optional comprehensive coverage for such risks.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.