ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsFlorida › St. Augustine

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in St. Augustine, FL

Browse auto insurance agents serving St. Augustine, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in St. Augustine, Florida is Perry Unwalla - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.8 stars across 423 reviews. Other highly rated options include Christopher Brown - GEICO Insurance Agent, Leigh Insurance Agency, The Bailey Group – An NFP Company. This directory lists 22 auto insurance agents serving St. Augustine.

Showing 22 auto insurance agents in St. Augustine, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Perry Unwalla - State Farm Insurance Agent3791 A1A S Suite A(904) 461-5400
2Christopher Brown - GEICO Insurance Agent224 State Rte 312(904) 506-6500
3Leigh Insurance Agency1797 Old Moultrie Rd STE 111(904) 826-0799
4The Bailey Group – An NFP Company1200 Plantation Island Dr S UNIT 210(904) 461-1800
5Tim Huber Insurance28 Clark St(904) 824-2555
6Direct Auto Insurance2467 US-1(904) 794-2357
7Britni Burkins: Allstate Insurance125 Nix Boat Yard Rd(904) 797-2660
8Ancient City Insurance2800 N 5th St #301(904) 827-1915
9Oldest City Insurance212 San Marco Ave Suite D(904) 824-7283
10Brightway Insurance, The Casey Agency108 Sea Grove Main St suite b(904) 217-7547
PU
3791 A1A S Suite A
Perry Unwalla - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Perry Unwalla - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the St. Augustine, Florida, area and provides auto insurance policies to local drivers. As an auto insurance agent, the company helps clients select coverage options that meet their individual needs and budgets. The agency assists with policy management, claims filing guidance, and coverage review for vehicles of all types. It handles liability, collision, and comprehensive insurance services for drivers throughout the region and its surrounding communities.

CB
224 State Rte 312
Christopher Brown - GEICO Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Christopher Brown - GEICO Insurance Agent provides a full range of auto insurance services, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. The office also offers routine policy reviews and assistance with claims filing to help clients maintain proper protection. Serving the St. Augustine, FL area, the agency works with drivers to find suitable plans for standard vehicles and recreational automobiles. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants.

LI
1797 Old Moultrie Rd STE 111
Leigh Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Homeowners, vehicle owners, and local drivers in St. Augustine can consult Leigh Insurance Agency for their auto insurance needs. This agency works with clients to identify appropriate personal coverage plans and assists in comparing relevant policy options. They explain the typical factors influencing local rates and help navigate common claims procedures. The agency’s services extend to covering drivers throughout St. Johns County and the neighboring community of Ponte Vedra Beach, ensuring regional access for area motorists.

BG
1200 Plantation Island Dr S UNIT 210
The Bailey Group – An NFP Company
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

The Bailey Group – An NFP Company in St. Augustine, FL, helps clients choose between a single policy purchase for immediate protection or an ongoing insurance relationship that adjusts as their driving habits change. Coverage offerings typically include liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist plans tailored to Florida's unique no-fault insurance laws. Local agents assist with comparing deductibles and policy limits to meet state requirements while managing personal risk. Service appointments for policy reviews or updates are handled on a scheduled or as-needed basis by appointment.

TH
28 Clark St
Tim Huber Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Tim Huber Insurance serves the St. Augustine, Florida area and surrounding communities, handling auto insurance policies for local drivers. The agency works with clients to secure coverage that meets Florida’s specific liability and comprehensive requirements. Typical jobs involve reviewing a driver’s personal vehicle use, mileage, and driving history to match an appropriate policy. The agent takes a straightforward approach by explaining coverage options clearly and then comparing quotes from multiple carriers to find a suitable balance of protection and cost for each individual situation.

DA
2467 US-1
Direct Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Direct Auto Insurance helps clients in St. Augustine, Florida, obtain essential vehicle coverage and manage liability protection. The agency specializes in offering commercial add-ons such as hired and non-owned auto policies, which extend comprehensive protection for business usage of personal vehicles. Brokers here guide drivers through comparative quotes and explain state minimum requirements, deductibles, and uninsured motorist options. The office serves customers from local offices, warehouses, and food service operations needing fleet or individual commercial auto policies.

BB
125 Nix Boat Yard Rd
Britni Burkins: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Britni Burkins: Allstate Insurance provides auto insurance policies to drivers in the St. Augustine, FL area. The agency guides clients in selecting liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. It also offers add-ons including roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement to enhance a standard policy. Commercial insurance options are available for businesses, covering vehicles used for offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

AC
2800 N 5th St #301
Ancient City Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Ancient City Insurance specializes in helping customers find appropriate levels of liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage for personal vehicles. It also handles policy adjustments, claims support, and routine coverage reviews for drivers throughout St. Augustine, FL. The agency works with individuals to maintain continuous protection against financial losses from accidents, theft, or weather-related damage. Seasonal concerns such as hurricane season or the increased tourist traffic on local roads often prompt clients to review their existing policies for adequate protection against these specific risks.

OC
212 San Marco Ave Suite D
Oldest City Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL

Oldest City Insurance provides auto insurance coverage for residents throughout St. Augustine and nearby commuter routes, ensuring local drivers meet Florida’s minimum requirements. Commercial policies are also available for small businesses and independent contractors needing liability protection on the road. Service extends to surrounding communities in St. Johns County, helping clients adjust their coverage as vehicles or driving habits change. Between regular policy reviews, the agency handles claim filings and updates with the same attention, encouraging repeat business when a client’s circumstances shift.

BI
108 Sea Grove Main St suite b
Brightway Insurance, The Casey Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
BI
1 Spencer St
Benchmark Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 829-2296
benchmarkins.com
FI
101 E Town Pl #225
Fender Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 639-4333
fenderagency.com
TB
61 Cordova St
Thompson Baker Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 824-1631
thompsonbaker.com
TP
320 High Tide Dr Suite 100F
Twin Palms Insurance Group, The Ward Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 643-9002
twinpalms.us
HW
400 N Ponce De Leon Blvd
Herbie Wiles Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 829-2201
herbiewiles.com
KI
2528 US-1 South
Knox Insurance Network
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 797-2000
knoxinsnetwork.com
WI
811 FL-206 E, #6
Whitco Insurance Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 827-7806
yacht-ins.com
AS
296 State Rte 312
AAA St. Augustine Insurance and Travel
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 825-0298
locator.acg.aaa.com/fl/st-augustine/aaa-st-augustine-insurance-and-travel
JT
2825 Lewis Speedway # 107
Janet Tillman - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 824-8111
janettillman.com
BA
661 A1A Beach Blvd
Beck Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 417-7717
beckagency.org
BI
2801 N 3rd St Unit B
Brightway Insurance, St. Augustine
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 217-7496
brightway.com/agencies/FL/St-Augustine/0033
OT
700 Plantation Island Dr S Suite 104
Old Town Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St. Augustine, FL
(904) 429-9444
oldtowninsuranceservices.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in St. Augustine Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in Florida is among the highest in the nation typically ranging from 1800 to 3500 dollars per year for full coverage. Minimum liability policies can cost between 600 and 1200 dollars annually. Actual rates depend on factors such as your driving record age vehicle type and location within St. Augustine. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in St. Augustine

An auto insurance agent in St. Augustine Florida can help you navigate the state specific coverage requirements. Florida law mandates Personal Injury Protection (PIP) of at least 10000 dollars and Property Damage Liability (PDL) of at least 10000 dollars. A local agent understands the unique risks of driving in historic St. Augustine including heavy tourist traffic and coastal weather conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What auto insurance coverage is required by law in Florida?

Florida law requires all drivers to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) of at least 10000 dollars and Property Damage Liability (PDL) of at least 10000 dollars. Bodily Injury Liability is not required but is highly recommended to protect your assets.

How can an auto insurance agent in St. Augustine help me?

An agent can review your driving history vehicle type and budget to find policies that meet Florida legal requirements. They can also explain optional coverages like collision comprehensive and uninsured motorist protection that are important in a tourist heavy area like St. Augustine.

Does my credit score affect my auto insurance rates in Florida?

Yes Florida insurers are allowed to use credit based insurance scores to determine premiums. A higher credit score can lead to lower rates while a lower score may increase your cost. An agent can help you find companies that offer competitive rates for your credit profile.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.