ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsFlorida › Tallahassee

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Tallahassee, FL

Browse auto insurance agents serving Tallahassee, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Tallahassee, Florida is McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 1,256 reviews. Other highly rated options include Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services, Acceptance Insurance, Direct Auto Insurance. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Tallahassee.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Tallahassee, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency2367 Centerville Rd(850) 329-6996
2Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services2880 Apalachee Pkwy(850) 412-1099
3Acceptance Insurance1210 Capital Cir SE Ste A(850) 204-4051
4Direct Auto Insurance650 W Tennessee St(850) 222-5964
5Woodham Insurance2286 Wednesday St STE 1(850) 597-9503
6Fuqua Insurance Agency1836 Hermitage Blvd(850) 386-2300
7Bridges Insurance Agency1913 Capital Cir NE(850) 354-8900
8Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee1225 S Monroe St(850) 224-6250
9Premier Insurance Agency113 S Monroe St(850) 749-4611
10Tyre Insurance Agency1114 N Adams St(850) 385-2093
MH
2367 Centerville Rd
McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency serves the Tallahassee, Florida, metro area by providing auto insurance coverage to local drivers. The agency works with clients to find policies that meet state requirements and protect against liability and vehicle damage. Customers can discuss their specific driving needs during personalized consultations. The agency assists with policy selection, coverage questions, and claims support for accidents in the Tallahassee region. It handles both liability-only and full-coverage auto insurance policies for area residents.

WI
2880 Apalachee Pkwy
Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services provides auto insurance policies to help protect drivers against financial loss from accidents, theft, and liability claims. The agency offers policy reviews, claims assistance, and guidance on adjusting coverage limits to suit changing needs. Routine account maintenance includes updating vehicle information and helping clients understand available deductibles. Year-round support ensures timely responses for policy adjustments. The agency also services insurance needs for single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

AI
1210 Capital Cir SE Ste A
Acceptance Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Acceptance Insurance in Tallahassee, Florida, offers both one-time auto insurance policies for short-term needs and recurring coverage for ongoing vehicle protection. Their policies typically include liability, collision, and comprehensive options to meet state requirements. Drivers can also add uninsured motorist coverage for added security. Service runs on either a one-time basis for single-payment terms or a scheduled recurring plan with regular installment payments.

DA
650 W Tennessee St
Direct Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Direct Auto Insurance in Tallahassee, Florida, specializes in liability and comprehensive coverage options for local drivers. It generally assists clients with policy comparisons, claims filing support, and payment plan setup to meet state requirements and personal needs. The agency works with drivers facing various credit histories or driving records. As hurricane season approaches, it helps residents review flood and comprehensive coverage adjustments tailored to Tallahassee’s severe weather risks, ensuring protection before storms arrive.

WI
2286 Wednesday St STE 1
Woodham Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Woodham Insurance, located in Tallahassee, FL, assists customers in distinguishing between one-time auto insurance quotes for single vehicles and recurring policy options that provide ongoing protection. Coverage offerings are tailored to address standard liability as well as more comprehensive plans for personal vehicles in the local area. Service appointments are available on an as-needed basis, allowing drivers to schedule consultations or file claims according to their own convenience and immediate requirements.

FI
1836 Hermitage Blvd
Fuqua Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Fuqua Insurance Agency serves Tallahassee, Florida, and the surrounding communities throughout Leon and nearby counties. The agency handles auto insurance policies, including coverage for liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. By assessing each driver’s unique needs and risk profile, it works to match them with appropriate plans from standard carriers. A typical job begins with a consultation to review current coverage, followed by a comparison of available options to present a tailored solution.

BI
1913 Capital Cir NE
Bridges Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Bridges Insurance Agency specializes in auto insurance coverage, including liability, collision, and comprehensive policies tailored for drivers in Tallahassee, FL. It also offers general personal insurance services to help clients manage risk and meet state requirements. The agency assists customers with policy adjustments for various life situations, such as adding a new teenage driver to a family plan. When hurricane season approaches, Bridges Insurance Agency helps local drivers review their policies for adequate protection against storm-related vehicle damage.

QI
1225 S Monroe St
Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee serves homeowners, businesses, and vehicle owners throughout the capital region. The agency connects local drivers with auto insurance policies tailored to their individual coverage needs. Agents assist clients in understanding liability, collision, and comprehensive options to meet Florida’s requirements. The office provides personalized guidance for selecting appropriate deductibles and policy limits. Vehicle owners can also obtain help with bundling policies for potential savings. The agency serves the entire Tallahassee metro area, including the neighboring community of Woodville.

PI
113 S Monroe St
Premier Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

As Florida’s unpredictable storm season raises new concerns about vehicle protection, Premier Insurance Agency in Tallahassee helps local drivers adjust their auto coverage to meet shifting weather and road risks. Navigating the area’s changing liability requirements demands clear guidance, which the agency provides by assessing each driver’s unique commute and vehicle usage. Their process begins with a thorough review of current policy limits, followed by a detailed inspection of the car’s condition and safety features before recommending any adjustments.

TI
1114 N Adams St
Tyre Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

With the arrival of hurricane season in Tallahassee, many residents review their auto insurance policies for adequate coverage. Tyre Insurance Agency assists drivers by explaining liability limits and comprehensive options suited for Florida’s unpredictable weather. The agency helps clients compare plans from multiple carriers, ensuring they understand deductibles and uninsured motorist protection. For those seeking personalized guidance, the first step is scheduling a complimentary policy review or obtaining a free initial assessment of their current coverage needs.

AI
1426 Capital Cir NW
Acceptance Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 204-3913
locations.acceptance.com/tampa-insurance-florida-33613
KT
113 S Monroe St 1st floor
Kingdom Tree Insurance Group
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 339-9520
ktinsurancegroup.com
GI
2522 Capital Cir NE STE 4
GreatFlorida Insurance: Tara Smith
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 523-0605
tallahassee.greatflorida.com
DA
2013 N Monroe St
Direct Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 688-1216
local.directauto.com/florida/tallahassee/2013-n-monroe-st
MI
1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201
McKee Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 224-6055
mckeeagency.com
AO
2066 Summit Lake Dr
Auto-Owners Insurance Tallahassee Regional Office
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(888) 700-5177
auto-owners.com
IC
3365 N Monroe St
The Insurance Center
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 562-4770
insurance-centerfl.com
AI
2500 Apalachee Pkwy ste c
Affiliated Insurance Agencies
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 877-6660
AI
1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201
Acentria Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 668-6162
acentria.com
AL
1520 Killearn Center Blvd
Assurance Low-Cost Car Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(561) 783-3303
24autoinsurance.website/florida/154-assurance-low-cost-car-insurance-tallahassee-fl

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Tallahassee Cost?

Auto insurance costs in Tallahassee vary by driver age, driving record, vehicle type, and coverage levels. On average, Florida drivers pay around 1,800 to 2,500 dollars per year for full coverage, but rates can be higher in Tallahassee due to local accident rates and weather risks. Minimum liability coverage typically costs 500 to 1,000 dollars per year. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Tallahassee

An auto insurance agent in Tallahassee can help you find coverage that meets Florida law requirements. Florida requires all drivers to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) of at least 10,000 dollars and Property Damage Liability (PDL) of at least 10,000 dollars. An agent can explain these minimums and help you add optional coverages like collision or comprehensive for better protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Florida?

Florida law requires at least 10,000 dollars in Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and 10,000 dollars in Property Damage Liability (PDL). PIP covers your medical bills regardless of fault, and PDL covers damage you cause to another persons property. These minimums do not cover damage to your own vehicle.

How do I find a licensed auto insurance agent in Tallahassee?

You can search the Florida Department of Financial Services website to verify an agent license. Many agents in Tallahassee are independent and can compare quotes from multiple carriers. You can also ask for referrals from local friends or family.

Does Florida require uninsured motorist coverage?

Florida does not require uninsured motorist (UM) coverage, but insurance companies must offer it to you in writing. If you reject UM coverage, you must sign a waiver. UM coverage can help pay for your injuries if a driver without insurance hits you.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.