ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsFlorida › Winter Garden

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Winter Garden, FL

Browse auto insurance agents serving Winter Garden, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Winter Garden, Florida is Bryan Fifer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 1,098 reviews. Other highly rated options include Shannon Till - State Farm Insurance Agent, Blake Price - State Farm Insurance Agent, Craig Martin - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 19 auto insurance agents serving Winter Garden.

Showing 19 auto insurance agents in Winter Garden, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Bryan Fifer - State Farm Insurance Agent3724 Winter Garden Vineland Rd(407) 614-2622
2Shannon Till - State Farm Insurance Agent1620 Daniels Rd #110(407) 656-4000
3Blake Price - State Farm Insurance Agent14230 W Colonial Dr Suite 110(407) 573-6666
4Craig Martin - State Farm Insurance Agent14416 Shoreside Way #140(407) 656-1040
5Heather Thies - State Farm Insurance Agent15835 Shaddock Dr #150(407) 354-1320
6Mike Broschart - State Farm Insurance Agent14230 W Colonial Dr Ste 110(407) 298-2700
7Shane Swan - State Farm Insurance Agent14416 Shoreside Way Suite 140(407) 452-0124
8NL Insurance Solutions Inc13640 W Colonial Dr ste 150(407) 654-6500
9Direct Auto Insurance14187 W Colonial Dr(407) 656-2274
10Central Florida Insurance Advisors213 S Dillard St(352) 575-2342
BF
3724 Winter Garden Vineland Rd
Bryan Fifer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Bryan Fifer - State Farm Insurance Agent provides auto insurance coverage tailored to the specific needs of drivers in Winter Garden, Florida. Policyholders can work with the agent to review and adjust their coverage limits, deductibles, and available protection options. The agency also offers regular policy check-ins and support for filing claims. It serves customers insuring various property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants in the local area.

ST
1620 Daniels Rd #110
Shannon Till - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Shannon Till - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Winter Garden, Florida area, offering auto insurance policies designed to meet local driving needs. The agency helps customers assess their coverage requirements based on vehicle use and personal circumstances. Filing a claim after an accident can be managed efficiently through the office. Policy reviews are available to adjust deductibles or add comprehensive and collision coverage for peace of mind. Personal liability protection and uninsured motorist coverage are also common services handled here.

BP
14230 W Colonial Dr Suite 110
Blake Price - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Blake Price - State Farm Insurance Agent in Winter Garden, FL, serves homeowners, renters, businesses, and property managers seeking reliable auto insurance coverage. The agency helps clients by offering personalized reviews of policy options to meet individual driving needs and budget goals. It provides ongoing support for claims and policy changes tailored to the local Winter Garden area. Its coverage extends to nearby communities throughout West Orange County and the greater Orlando metro region.

CM
14416 Shoreside Way #140
Craig Martin - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Craig Martin - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Winter Garden, Florida and the surrounding communities of Central Florida. An auto insurance agent, the company handles personal auto policies, helping clients select appropriate coverage levels for their vehicles. The operation manages new policy applications, policy updates, and claims assistance for its customers. To address a typical client need, it begins by reviewing the driver's current coverage and discussing factors like driving history and vehicle type before presenting suitable protection options.

HT
15835 Shaddock Dr #150
Heather Thies - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Heather Thies - State Farm Insurance Agent in Winter Garden, Florida, is known for offering personalized auto insurance coverage to local drivers. Its services range from basic liability policies to comprehensive plans that protect against accidents, theft, and weather-related damage. The agency works closely with clients to help them understand their policy limits and deductibles. For an added layer of protection, it specializes in including roadside assistance coverage, which provides help with flat tires, lockouts, and towing needs.

MB
14230 W Colonial Dr Ste 110
Mike Broschart - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Unlike one-time transactions at a claims office, Mike Broschart - State Farm Insurance Agent in Winter Garden, FL focuses on an ongoing relationship with clients. Their core work involves assessing risk to recommend personalized auto coverage from available policies, ensuring drivers meet local requirements and liability protections. This continuous service includes policy reviews when life events like a new car occur or addresses a sudden rate change. Routine consultations are held on a scheduled basis, with additional assistance available as needed for any adjustments or questions between renewal periods.

SS
14416 Shoreside Way Suite 140
Shane Swan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

As an auto insurance agent, Shane Swan - State Farm Insurance Agent in Winter Garden, FL specializes in helping drivers find liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. It also works with clients to bundle auto policies with renters or life insurance for broader protection. Whether a customer is insuring a new car, an older vehicle, or a teen driver, the agency offers personalized policy reviews to match local driving needs. During hurricane season in Florida, it assists customers in ensuring their policies provide adequate coverage for storm-related vehicle damage.

NI
13640 W Colonial Dr ste 150
NL Insurance Solutions Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

With winter weather sometimes bringing unpredictable driving conditions in Winter Garden, reviewing adequate coverage becomes essential for local motorists. NL Insurance Solutions Inc serves residents seeking auto insurance policies tailored to individual driving habits and vehicle types. Their agents take time to explain liability limits, collision deductibles, and uninsured motorist protection clearly before any commitment. During an initial consultation, they inspect the vehicle’s registration and driving history to present suitable options matching the client’s budget and coverage needs.

DA
14187 W Colonial Dr
Direct Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Direct Auto Insurance serves Winter Garden and the greater Orange County area, offering standard auto coverage and liability protection for local drivers. This agency assists clients in meeting Florida’s minimum insurance requirements while providing guidance on policy limits and deductibles. Customers can obtain quotes tailored to their personal vehicles and driving history. The office handles policy adjustments for life changes such as adding a new car or updating an existing plan. It also processes roadside assistance and rental reimbursement options for eligible policies.

CF
213 S Dillard St
Central Florida Insurance Advisors
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL

Central Florida Insurance Advisors assists drivers in Winter Garden with standard auto policies. The agency can arrange liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, as well as additional options such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement. Its work involves securing protection based on each client’s driving patterns and vehicle type. Commercial auto insurance is available for businesses operating fleets, including offices, warehouses, and food service locations.

HI
1165 E Plant St #6
Hillcrest Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 656-2211
hillcrestinsurance.com
AI
502 S Woodland St
Abney Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 877-6110
abneyagency.com
TG
1218 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Suite # 112
Tiago Guimaraes Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(843) 343-9603
tiagoguimaraesinsurance.com
SI
Raintree Building, 310 S Dillard St STE 150
Sunline Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 933-7866
sunlineinsagency.com
SI
5736 Hamlin Groves Tr #162
Sheldon Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 792-0686
sheldonpalmesinsurance.com
BI
1218 Winter Garden Vineland Rd #128
Budget Insurance Offices, Inc. - Winter Garden
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 877-0878
budgetinsurancewintergarden.com
LH
1023 S Dillard St #4B
Lorenzo Hayward - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 654-9131
lorenzohayward.com
BB
13335 W Colonial Dr
B&S BROKERS INSURANCE
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(407) 205-5166
bsbrokersinsurance.com
BI
1201 Winter Garden Vineland Rd #4B
Bacci Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Winter Garden, FL
(321) 946-8297
baccinsure.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Winter Garden Cost?

The average cost of full coverage auto insurance in Florida is around 2,000 to 3,000 dollars per year, though rates vary widely based on your driving history, age, and location in Winter Garden. Minimum liability coverage typically costs between 600 and 1,200 dollars annually. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Winter Garden

Auto insurance agents in Winter Garden Florida help drivers find coverage that meets state requirements. Florida law mandates a minimum of 10,000 dollars in Personal Injury Protection and 10,000 dollars in Property Damage Liability. Local agents can also guide you on additional coverage options like uninsured motorist protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Florida?

Florida requires drivers to carry 10,000 dollars in Personal Injury Protection and 10,000 dollars in Property Damage Liability. These minimums are set by state law and do not cover damage to your own vehicle.

How do I choose an auto insurance agent in Winter Garden?

Look for an agent licensed in Florida who has experience with local driving conditions. Ask about their knowledge of Florida insurance laws and their ability to compare quotes from multiple carriers.

Can an auto insurance agent help me lower my premium?

Yes, an agent can review your driving record, vehicle type, and available discounts. They may suggest higher deductibles or bundling policies to reduce your monthly cost.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.