ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsColorado › Colorado Springs

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Colorado Springs, CO

Browse home insurance agents serving Colorado Springs, Colorado. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Colorado Springs, Colorado is Tyler Ayers - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 1,234 reviews. Other highly rated options include State Farm: Dan Lewis South, Matt Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent, Peter Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 49 home insurance agents serving Colorado Springs.

Showing 49 home insurance agents in Colorado Springs, COListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Tyler Ayers - State Farm Insurance Agent4031 Tutt Blvd(719) 368-6276
2State Farm: Dan Lewis South1614 S Academy Blvd #110(719) 434-3944
3Matt Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent6660 Delmonico Dr # C(719) 598-1881
4Peter Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent2803 E Bijou St(719) 633-0300
5Brightway Insurance, The Kolk Agency3210 E Woodmen Rd STE 210(719) 599-3600
6Rusty Fanning - State Farm Insurance Agent330 N Tejon St(719) 694-2165
7Kevin Good - State Farm Insurance Agent11550 Ridgeline Dr #114(719) 599-8200
8A Plus Insurance121 S Tejon St UNIT 1107(719) 392-4000
9Jeff Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent1230 Tenderfoot Hill Rd STE 200(719) 445-0070
10Premier Group Insurance Karen Frausto2811 E Fountain Blvd(719) 662-3895
TA
4031 Tutt Blvd
Tyler Ayers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Tyler Ayers - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Colorado Springs, Colorado area by offering home insurance policies. The agency helps local homeowners protect their property against common regional risks, including hail and wildfire damage. Policies can also cover personal belongings inside the home and provide liability protection for accidents occurring on the insured property. Customized coverage options are available to meet individual needs. The agency specifically handles home insurance quotes and policy reviews for homes in the Colorado Springs area.

SF
1614 S Academy Blvd #110
State Farm: Dan Lewis South
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

State Farm: Dan Lewis South provides a full range of home insurance services, including coverage consultations and policy adjustments tailored to individual needs. The agency offers annual policy reviews to help ensure adequate protection and assists clients with filing and managing claims when damage occurs. Service plans focus on updating coverage as property values change and as homeowners complete renovations. This Colorado Springs agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

MF
6660 Delmonico Dr # C
Matt Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Matt Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent in Colorado Springs provides home insurance policies to local homeowners and property managers, helping them protect their residences and rental properties against common regional risks such as hailstorms and wildfires. The agency also assists families in covering repair costs and personal belongings through comprehensive dwelling coverage. Customers can meet with the office to review their existing plans or to request a quote for a new policy. The agent also serves clients in Fountain and the surrounding El Paso County communities.

PM
2803 E Bijou St
Peter Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Serving Colorado Springs and the surrounding communities, Peter Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent provides home insurance coverage for local homeowners. This office handles policies that protect against common property damage and liability risks, tailoring protection plans to match each customer’s residential needs. To evaluate a typical home insurance job, it conducts a thorough consultation to identify specific coverage requirements and then selects an appropriate policy.

BI
3210 E Woodmen Rd STE 210
Brightway Insurance, The Kolk Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Brightway Insurance, The Kolk Agency in Colorado Springs, CO provides homeowners with the option of a one-time policy purchase or an ongoing service relationship that reviews coverage as needs change. The agency offers standard property protection, including dwelling, personal property, and liability coverage tailored to local conditions such as hailstorms or wildfire risks. Service operates on an as-needed basis, accommodating policy adjustments and claims assistance whenever clients require support.

RF
330 N Tejon St
Rusty Fanning - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Rusty Fanning - State Farm Insurance Agent in Colorado Springs, CO, offers comprehensive home insurance policies tailored to protect both the structure and personal belongings of area residents. The agency also provides general coverage options that can bundle home and auto plans for streamlined service. Clients receive guidance on understanding replacement cost versus actual cash value for their property. The office additionally helps homeowners address specific concerns such as storm damage from local thunderstorms or melting snow affecting roofs and basements.

KG
11550 Ridgeline Dr #114
Kevin Good - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Kevin Good - State Farm Insurance Agent in Colorado Springs provides residential home insurance services for local homeowners, tailoring coverage options to protect individual property needs. Commercial insurance solutions are also available for area business owners seeking liability and asset protection. The agency serves clients throughout Colorado Springs and the surrounding El Paso County communities. Agents offer personalized policy reviews and will follow up with customers between regular visits to adjust coverage as circumstances evolve or to answer insurance related questions.

PI
121 S Tejon St UNIT 1107
A Plus Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

A Plus Insurance connects homeowners in Colorado Springs with policies that protect their property and belongings actively. The agency frequently helps clients review coverage extensions, such as scheduled personal property riders for valuables and sewer backup protection. Specializing in residential insurance, the agency also works alongside risk management professionals to serve commercial sectors. Their client list routinely includes small to mid-size businesses, such as local offices, warehouses, and food service operations requiring tailored liability and property coverage.

JS
1230 Tenderfoot Hill Rd STE 200
Jeff Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Jeff Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent provides home insurance coverage for residential properties in Colorado Springs and the surrounding area. Commercial insurance policies are also available to protect local businesses and their assets. The agency serves customers throughout El Paso County and nearby communities. Clients are encouraged to schedule regular policy reviews to discuss changes in coverage needs or to update existing plans, ensuring continued protection and follow-up service between annual renewal visits.

PG
2811 E Fountain Blvd
Premier Group Insurance Karen Frausto
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO

Premier Group Insurance Karen Frausto in Colorado Springs, Colorado, is known for providing homeowners with comprehensive property protection tailored to local risks. The agency’s service range covers standard dwelling and personal liability coverage, as well as policies for condo units and rental properties. Agents in this category help clients with claims support and risk assessment related to regional weather events or neighborhood conditions. For added peace of mind, the agency can arrange scheduled personal property endorsements for high-value items like jewelry or electronics.

AI
2407 W Colorado Ave
ALINK Insurance Services - Colorado Springs, CO
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 473-6262
alink2insurance.com
NF
6799 Bismark Rd Suite A
Nick Fransioli - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 694-8915
pikespeakinsurance.com
FI
1255 Lake Plaza Dr Ste 135
Farmers Insurance - Jacob Morgan
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 576-2638
agents.farmers.com/co/colorado-springs/jacob-morgan
CI
5527 N Union Blvd Ste 101
Colorado Insurance Services: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 573-1136
agents.allstate.com/colorado-insurance-services-colorado-springs-co.html
II
4905 N Union Blvd STE 202
Inszone Insurance Services
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 645-8212
completecoverageins.com
RM
7615 Austin Bluffs Pkwy UNIT 200
Reeves Maddox - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 418-3939
reevesmaddox.com
BI
1860 Dublin Blvd STE A
Brukhouse Insurance Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 258-8071
brukhouse.com
WI
9235 N Union Blvd Ste 150-385
Westco Insurance LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 726-0318
westcoins.com
RI
685 Citadel Dr E #365
RightQuote
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 591-2036
rqthatswho.com
IC
2055 Anglo Dr suite 200
Insurance Centers of America
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 528-5400
icainsurance.com
MA
726 Cheyenne Meadows Rd
Melissa Andrews: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 540-9100
agents.allstate.com/melissa-andrews-colorado-springs-co-18948256.html
JN
1975 Research Pkwy #200
Jeff Novotny at Comparion Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(720) 302-9942
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/colorado/colorado-springs-0933/jeffnovotny
PG
634 S Academy Blvd
Premier Group Insurance of Colorado Springs
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 368-6182
SC
6799 Bismark Rd e
Southern Colorado Insurance Center
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 329-4441
scicteam.com
JM
2746 E Bijou St
Jordan Mertens Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 382-7496
amfam.com/agents/colorado/colorado-springs/jordan-mertens
DS
106 N Circle Dr
Donny Saunders: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 635-5053
agents.allstate.com/donny-saunders-colorado-springs-co.html
JD
2812 W Colorado Ave Ste 100
Jeremy Dixon: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 597-7122
agents.allstate.com/jeremy-dixon-colorado-springs-co.html
CI
1975 Research Pkwy #200
Comparion Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 531-9777
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/colorado/colorado-springs-0933
BI
6 S Tejon St Ste 460
Brightway Insurance, The Fast Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 895-1222
brightway.com/agencies/CO/Colorado-Springs/0582
PP
3515 N Chestnut St
Pawel Posorski - GEICO Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 960-5490
geico.com/insurance-agents/colorado/colorado-springs/pawel-posorski
FI
12325 Oracle Blvd #111
Farmers Insurance - Rebecca Manke
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 249-8795
agents.farmers.com/rmanke
EI
102 S Tejon St #1100
Elite Insurance Services
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 302-1110
insure-elite.com
KM
2708 W Colorado Ave A
Kelly Muse - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 329-1818
kellymuse.com
IH
1331 W Colorado Ave
The Insurance House
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 633-1690
insurancehouseco.com
AI
500 N Circle Dr #206
American Insurance Exchange, Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 636-3948
aie1.com
FI
1976 S Murray Blvd #130
Freeway Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(303) 231-8098
locations.freeway.com/auto-insurance-colorado-springs-co-80910
SI
7222 Commerce Center Dr Suite 220
Springs Insurance Brokers
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 268-1300
springsinsurancebrokers.com
CC
6755 Earl Dr Suite 206
Colorado Community Insurance Services
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 362-3390
colocommunity.com
CG
334 Main St
Carlos Gonzalez, Jr. - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 900-7431
guardianofthecommunity.com
IH
5180 N Union Blvd STE 105
The Insurance House
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 548-8008
insurancehouseco.com
SI
4465 Northpark Dr suite 445
Synergy Insurance Advisors
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(303) 495-2900
synergyinsuranceadvisors.com
AI
1155 Kelly Johnson Blvd Suite 440
Alliance Insurance of the Rockies
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 687-6364
allianceoftherockies.com
MC
1212 Motor City Dr
Mt. Carmel Insurance Agency, LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 444-4545
mtcarmelinsure.com
ER
4711 Opus Dr #201
Edward Reed American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 540-8400
amfam.com/agents/colorado/colorado-springs/edward-reed
OD
707 S Tejon St #200
O'Donnell Agency Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 635-1199
thecustomerfirst.biz
DT
705 Main St
Danette Trujillo American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 392-0808
amfam.com/agents/colorado/colorado-springs/Danette-Trujillo
SI
1223 Lake Plaza Dr ste a
Shelter Insurance - Kristi McLaughlin
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 884-2106
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/KRISTIMCLAUGHLIN
LI
13540 Northgate Estates Dr Suite 210
Legacy Insurance Services LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 593-5814
legacyinsurancebroker.com
TS
635 Southpointe Ct STE 100
Timothy Spellman Insurance Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Colorado Springs, CO
(719) 374-5777
timothy-spellman-insurance-agency-llc-2.ueniweb.com

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Colorado Springs Cost?

The average cost of home insurance in Colorado Springs is around $1,800 to $2,500 per year for a standard policy. Premiums vary based on your homes age location construction type and coverage limits. Factors like proximity to wildfire zones and your claims history also affect the price. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Colorado Springs

Home insurance agents in Colorado Springs help homeowners find policies that protect against common local risks like hail storms and wildfires. Colorado law requires insurers to offer coverage for wind and hail damage as part of standard policies. Working with a local agent can help you understand specific coverage needs for the Pikes Peak region.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does home insurance typically cover in Colorado Springs?

Standard home insurance policies in Colorado cover damage from fire wind hail and theft. Most policies also include liability protection if someone is injured on your property. Flood and earthquake damage are usually not covered and require separate policies.

Do I need additional coverage for hail damage in Colorado?

Yes hail damage is a common risk in Colorado Springs. Colorado law requires insurers to offer wind and hail coverage as part of your policy. You may want to review your deductible for hail claims as some policies have separate higher deductibles for this type of damage.

How can a local agent help me with Colorado insurance laws?

A local agent can explain Colorado specific rules such as the 15 day grace period for premium payments and the requirement for insurers to provide a written explanation for any coverage denial. They can also help you understand how the Colorado FAIR Plan works if you have trouble finding coverage in high risk areas.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Colorado Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.