ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Neenah, WI

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Neenah, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Neenah, Wisconsin is Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 564 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance, Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent, Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 15 landlord insurance agents serving Neenah.

Showing 15 landlord insurance agents in Neenah, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent1065 S Lake St(920) 722-6021
2Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance996 S Green Bay Rd(920) 725-3951
3Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent1108 Breezewood Ln(920) 722-4277
4Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent1395 W American Dr E(920) 722-4457
5Sean the Health Insurance Guy1760 American Dr(920) 215-1150
6Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance1220 S Commercial St(920) 725-2110
7Sturtevant & Associates, LLC500 N Commercial St Suite A(920) 969-1956
8Alliance Insurance Centers1977 American Dr #200(920) 886-3510
9Elite Insurance Agency1580 Lyon Dr(414) 206-3018
10Lighthouse Insurance Agency, LLCMarketplace Building, 124 W Wisconsin Ave #230(920) 722-7210
DM
1065 S Lake St
Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Neenah, Wisconsin area, specializing in landlord insurance for property owners. The agency helps clients protect rental properties and income streams through tailored coverage options. Policies address common risks faced by local landlords, including property damage and liability protection. The agency handles policy adjustments for multi-unit dwellings and seasonal rental properties in the region.

HA
996 S Green Bay Rd
Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance provides a range of landlord insurance services tailored to property owners in Neenah, WI. Their offerings include coverage for property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income. Standard service plans can help landlords manage routine maintenance claims efficiently. The company also assists with policy adjustments to reflect changing property values or tenant situations. It serves various property types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

JC
1108 Breezewood Ln
Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners, property managers, and small business owners who rent out residential or commercial properties in the Neenah, Wisconsin, area. The agency provides landlord insurance policies that can help protect rental structures, liability exposures, and lost rental income from covered claims. Clients work directly with the agent to review coverage options and tailor policies to their specific property needs. The agency additionally covers landlords and rental property owners in the nearby Appleton metro area.

BM
1395 W American Dr E
Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Serving Neenah and the surrounding Fox Valley communities, Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent handles landlord insurance policies for residential and small commercial property owners. It provides coverage options designed to protect rental properties from property damage, liability claims, and potential loss of rental income. The agency helps landlords assess individual property risks by reviewing each rental’s unique characteristics. During a typical job, the agent conducts a detailed consultation to match policy features with the specific exposure and coverage needs of the property.

SH
1760 American Dr
Sean the Health Insurance Guy
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Located in Neenah, WI, Sean the Health Insurance Guy assists property owners with landlord insurance coverage. Landlord insurance differs from standard homeowners policies by protecting rental properties and liability exposures. Coverage options typically address dwelling damage, lost rental income, and personal liability for tenant injuries. Property owners may choose a one-time policy for a single rental property or utilize a scheduled, recurring service for multiple units requiring periodic policy review. Service is offered on both a one-time basis for individual needs and a recurring scheduled basis for ongoing portfolio management.

ES
1220 S Commercial St
Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance specializes in crafting customized landlord insurance policies tailored to protect rental property investments in Neenah, WI. Its general service work includes helping property owners secure coverage for dwelling damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income. The agency uses its expertise to address regional challenges such as winter freeze-related pipe bursts or summer storm damage to roofs and structures, ensuring landlords have proper financial safeguards for seasonal property risks.

SA
500 N Commercial St Suite A
Sturtevant & Associates, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

As the spring thaw creates new worries about leaky pipes and roof damage for rental property owners in the Fox Valley region, Sturtevant & Associates, LLC in Neenah, WI helps landlords secure proper coverage for their residential and small commercial buildings. This agency focuses specifically on policies that protect against tenant-related risks, lost rental income, and liability claims common to Wisconsin property owners. Their process begins by scheduling a thorough on-site inspection to identify unique exposures and confirm accurate property valuations before tailoring a quote.

AI
1977 American Dr #200
Alliance Insurance Centers
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Alliance Insurance Centers works with property owners in the Neenah, WI area to secure appropriate coverage for rental properties. The agency specializes in landlord insurance, which can include protection for dwelling structures and liability related to tenant injuries. It also assists with add-ons such as coverage for loss of rental income or damage from vandalism. The company serves various commercial sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

EI
1580 Lyon Dr
Elite Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Elite Insurance Agency in Neenah, Wisconsin, is known for providing property protection policies for residential and small commercial rental properties. Its services include coverage for physical damage from fire, weather, and vandalism, in addition to liability protection for landlord exposures in the local market. The agency helps clients assess replacement costs and policy deductibles tailored to individual rental portfolios. A specialty service it can add on includes loss of rental income coverage to compensate for vacancy during repairs.

LI
Marketplace Building, 124 W Wisconsin Ave #230
Lighthouse Insurance Agency, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
EM
48 Jewelers Park Dr Suite 200
Ellington Mutual Insurance Co
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 779-4515
ellingtonmutual.com
FI
1370 S Commercial St
Farmers Insurance - Diane Masey
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 729-9001
agents.farmers.com/wi/neenah/diane-masey
HM
48 Jewelers Park Dr Suite 200
Homestead Mutual Insurance Company
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 836-3577
homesteadmutual.com
RI
55 Jewelers Park Dr Suite 105
R&R Insurance Services, Inc. - Neenah
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 955-1040
myknowledgebroker.com
JI
24 Jewelers Park Dr
Jm Insurance Services LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(800) 339-9124
jmiservices.com

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Neenah Cost?

Typical landlord insurance premiums in Wisconsin range from 15 to 30 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single-family rental in Neenah, annual costs often fall between 800 and 1,500 dollars, depending on coverage levels and property value. Higher liability limits and additional endorsements for flood or sewer backup will increase the premium. This is general information and not insurance advice. Always consult a licensed agent for a quote specific to your property.

About landlord insurance agents in Neenah

Landlord insurance agents in Neenah, Wisconsin help rental property owners secure coverage for buildings, liability, and loss of rental income. Wisconsin law does not require landlords to carry insurance, but mortgage lenders often mandate it. Local agents understand the risks specific to the Fox Valley region, including winter weather damage and tenant liability issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a landlord insurance agent in Neenah do?

A landlord insurance agent helps you find a policy that covers your rental property, including dwelling protection, liability coverage, and loss of rental income. They can explain Wisconsin-specific policy options and help you compare quotes from different carriers.

Is landlord insurance required by Wisconsin law?

Wisconsin does not have a state law requiring landlords to carry insurance. However, most mortgage lenders require a landlord insurance policy as a condition of the loan. An agent can help you meet lender requirements while protecting your investment.

What factors affect the cost of landlord insurance in Neenah?

Costs depend on the propertys location, age, construction type, rental amount, and coverage limits. In Neenah, proximity to Lake Winnebago and flood zones can also impact premiums. An agent can provide quotes tailored to your specific property.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.