ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeLandlord Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Sun Prairie

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Sun Prairie, WI

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin is First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company, rated 5.0 stars across 633 reviews. Other highly rated options include Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent, Homewood Insurance Agency, Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 19 landlord insurance agents serving Sun Prairie.

Showing 19 landlord insurance agents in Sun Prairie, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company1261 W Main St #101(608) 318-1200
2Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent233 E Main St(608) 834-0483
3Homewood Insurance Agency1262 W Main St(608) 837-3611
4Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent2824 Prairie Lakes Dr UNIT 203(608) 837-3783
5Farmers Insurance - Matthew Johnson1020 N Bristol St Ste 201(608) 770-0007
6Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance1015 W Main St(608) 271-9900
7Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent1210 Emerald Terrace(608) 837-2502
8Rusch Insurance703 Commercial Ave suite C(608) 724-1924
9Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates2273 McCoy Rd(608) 295-7582
10Amy Thompson American Family Insurance695 S Grand Ave UNIT 204(608) 837-6607
FC
1261 W Main St #101
First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company serves landlords in Dane County and the surrounding Sun Prairie, Wisconsin area. The firm provides insurance coverage tailored for owners of residential rental properties. Its agents help clients find protection for both single-family rental homes and small multi-unit apartment buildings. They also assist with policies that cover incidental business exposures common to being a landlord. Specific services offered in this area include securing vacant property insurance and designing liability coverage that addresses tenant-related risks.

AE
233 E Main St
Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie, WI, provides landlord insurance policies covering property damage, liability protection, and rental income loss. The agency offers assistance with policy reviews and updates to ensure ongoing coverage aligns with changing property conditions. Service includes guidance through the claims process when needed. The team works with owners of single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

HI
1262 W Main St
Homewood Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Homewood Insurance Agency serves landlords, property managers, and real estate investors across Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. It provides tailored coverage options designed to protect rental properties from common risks, including liability claims and property damage. The agency works to match each client with appropriate insurance policies that address the specific needs of residential or commercial rental units. Homewood Insurance Agency also extends its services to property owners in the neighboring communities throughout the Madison metropolitan area.

MR
2824 Prairie Lakes Dr UNIT 203
Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Serving Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, and the surrounding communities, Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent handles landlord insurance solutions for property owners. It covers policies that protect rental dwellings and liability exposures common to local landlords. The agency works with clients to review coverage needs for various residential properties. For a typical job, it begins by assessing property specifics and discussing risk protection options before providing a tailored coverage proposal.

FI
1020 N Bristol St Ste 201
Farmers Insurance - Matthew Johnson
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

For property owners in Sun Prairie, WI, Farmers Insurance - Matthew Johnson distinguishes between one-time landlord insurance policies for individual rental properties and recurring annual plans that blanket multiple units under continuous coverage. This service provides financial protection against property damage, liability claims, and lost rental income from tenant issues or unforeseen events. Landlords can secure coverage tailored to single-family homes, duplexes, or small apartment buildings within the area. Assistance runs on an as-needed basis for policy adjustments, claims support, or new property additions.

MT
1015 W Main St
Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Monica Titley with Allstate Insurance specializes in arranging landlord insurance policies tailored for property owners in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. The agency regularly works with local landlords to protect rental properties against common risks such as property damage and liability claims. It helps clients understand coverage gaps specific to rental dwellings and advises on appropriate policy structures. The office also assists with seasonal concerns like freeze-related pipe bursts during harsh Wisconsin winters, ensuring rental units remain protected through weather extremes.

GW
1210 Emerald Terrace
Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

As the spring thaw arrives in Sun Prairie, landlords often face maintenance surprises in their rental properties from freeze damage or roof leaks. Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent provides landlord insurance coverage to help protect these investments against unexpected repairs or liability claims from tenants. The agent works with property owners to explain how different policy options can cover buildings, lost rental income, and legal costs. The initial assessment begins with a review of each property's current structure and occupancy details.

RI
703 Commercial Ave suite C
Rusch Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Rusch Insurance works with property owners throughout the Sun Prairie area to secure coverage for rental dwellings. The company can add specialized endorsements addressing liability protection and damage from vandalism or weather events. Their policies are designed to cover the unique risks landlords face when leasing residential units. Additionally, Rusch Insurance can customize plans for commercial properties such as offices, warehouses, and food service establishments, ensuring each sector’s distinct operational exposures are addressed.

RM
2273 McCoy Rd
Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates in Sun Prairie, WI is known for providing landlord insurance policies tailored to residential and small commercial property owners. Its service range covers essential property protection, liability coverage, and loss-of-rent endorsements. The agency helps landlords manage risks associated with tenant-occupied dwellings in Wisconsin’s climate. For added flexibility, the company can customize a policy that includes ordinance or law coverage for older buildings undergoing repairs after a covered claim.

AT
695 S Grand Ave UNIT 204
Amy Thompson American Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Amy Thompson American Family Insurance assists residential landlords in Sun Prairie, WI with property coverage needs. The agency also offers policies for commercial rental properties and serves clients throughout the broader local area. As a landlord insurance agent, the business helps owners protect their investments from common rental risks. Comprehensive insurance plans may cover damage to buildings or liability from tenant injuries. The company provides follow-up service and supports landlords between regular policy reviews to adjust coverage as properties or tenants change.

TR
1777 W Main St Ste 112
Tyler Riekena - COUNTRY Financial Representative
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 834-2060
advisors.countryfinancial.com/usa/wi/sun-prairie/tyler-riekena
TI
804 Liberty Blvd #203
TRICOR Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 837-2484
tricorinsurance.com/sun-prairie-insurance-office
LC
600 W Main St C
Larry Cutler American Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 837-3307
amfam.com/agents/wisconsin/sun-prairie/larry-cutler
SO
100 Wilburn Rd Suite 103
Susan Olson Insurance & Financial Solutions
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 825-7882
talentcpa.com
RM
425 W Main St #104
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Mitch Deprey
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 318-5801
ruralmutual.com/agent/mitch-deprey-sun-prairie
ST
2810 Hoepker Rd
State
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(715) 600-5320
SP
1344 Swordleaf Ln
Sun Parries Insurance CO
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 291-9029
SI
916 Windsor St
Skyhigh Insurance agency WI
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 506-1332
TI
1015 W Main St
Titley Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 234-4300
titleyinsurance.com

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie Cost?

Typical landlord insurance in Wisconsin costs between 15 and 25 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single family rental in Sun Prairie expect annual premiums from 800 to 1500 dollars depending on property value and coverage limits. Multi unit properties cost more. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Sun Prairie

Landlord insurance agents in Sun Prairie Wisconsin help property owners protect their rental investments. Wisconsin law does not require landlord insurance but most mortgage lenders do. Local agents understand the specific risks for properties in Dane County and can tailor policies to your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Wisconsin?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. In Wisconsin policies often include protection against tenant lawsuits and weather related damage like hail or snow.

Is landlord insurance required in Sun Prairie Wisconsin?

Wisconsin state law does not require landlord insurance. However most mortgage lenders and property management companies in Sun Prairie do require it. Check your loan agreement for specific requirements.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Sun Prairie?

Look for an agent licensed in Wisconsin who has experience with rental properties. Ask about coverage for vacancy periods and liability limits. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find the right policy for your property.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.