ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeRenters Insurance AgentsFlorida › Middleburg

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Middleburg, FL

Browse renters insurance agents serving Middleburg, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Middleburg, Florida is Katherine Baustert - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 308 reviews. Other highly rated options include Rich Morris - State Farm Insurance Agent, Felisha Foote: Allstate Insurance, Brightway Insurance, The Herd Agency. This directory lists 12 renters insurance agents serving Middleburg.

Showing 12 renters insurance agents in Middleburg, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Katherine Baustert - State Farm Insurance Agent2219 County Rd 220 Suite 301(904) 276-2112
2Rich Morris - State Farm Insurance Agent2067 Palmetto St(904) 282-9898
3Felisha Foote: Allstate Insurance2640 Blanding Blvd Ste 206(904) 406-7838
4Brightway Insurance, The Herd Agency14 Swimming Pen Dr Suite 2(904) 469-1900
5Direct Auto Insurance1580 Branan Field Rd(904) 406-7730
6Brightway Insurance - Middleburg2755 Blanding Blvd Ste. 110(904) 291-4663
7Liberty DSI1646 Corsair Ln #601(904) 264-0500
8Roberts Insurance of Middleburg2361 Blanding Blvd(904) 282-7665
9Jenny Lynne & Co4213 Co Rd 218(904) 291-3655
10Lyndel Hale Agency - Insurance2751 Blanding Blvd Suite 106(352) 612-4154
KB
2219 County Rd 220 Suite 301
Katherine Baustert - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Katherine Baustert - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Middleburg, Florida area and surrounding communities, specializing in renters insurance coverage. She assists local residents with protecting their personal belongings against events such as theft and fire damage. The agency provides tailored policies that include liability protection for accidents occurring within a rented home or apartment. Her office offers renters insurance with added options for identity theft protection and coverage for temporary living expenses.

RM
2067 Palmetto St
Rich Morris - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Rich Morris - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middleburg, FL, provides a range of personal property protection tailored for tenants and homeowners. The agency offers customized policies covering personal belongings against theft, fire, and water damage, along with liability coverage for accidents on rented premises. Maintenance plans typically include guidance on policy updates following life changes, such as moving or acquiring new valuables. This agent services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

FF
2640 Blanding Blvd Ste 206
Felisha Foote: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Felisha Foote: Allstate Insurance serves local homeowners, renters, and property managers seeking personal property and liability protection in Middleburg, Florida. The agency provides guidance on selecting appropriate coverage limits for apartments and single-family rentals. Understanding that each living situation requires different policy options, the team works to find suitable plans for clients. Conveniently assisting residents throughout the surrounding Clay County areas, the agency also covers neighboring Orange Park and the greater Jacksonville metro region for renters insurance needs.

BI
14 Swimming Pen Dr Suite 2
Brightway Insurance, The Herd Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Brightway Insurance, The Herd Agency serves Middleburg, Florida, and the nearby communities of Clay County and the Jacksonville metropolitan area. As a local renters insurance agent, it handles policies that protect personal belongings, provide liability coverage, and offer additional living expenses after a covered loss. It addresses common household risks like theft, fire, water damage from burst pipes, and accidental guest injuries. To manage a typical job, the agency first reviews a client’s living situation and landlord requirements, then compares basic coverage options from available carriers to find a suitable plan.

DA
1580 Branan Field Rd
Direct Auto Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Direct Auto Insurance serves the Middleburg, Florida area, offering renters insurance policies to local residents. It helps tenants protect their personal belongings from unexpected events like theft or fire. Coverage typically includes liability protection for accidents that occur within a rented home. Renters insurance is a practical way for individuals to safeguard their finances against damage to furniture, electronics, and clothing. The company handles personal property protection and assists clients with understanding deductibles and liability limits.

BI
2755 Blanding Blvd Ste. 110
Brightway Insurance - Middleburg
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

In booking renters insurance, customers distinguish between a one-time policy quote and recurring service needs such as policy renewals or claims assistance. Brightway Insurance - Middleburg, based in Middleburg, FL, serves local renters by offering coverage options that protect personal belongings and provide liability protection within the area. The agency helps clients compare available plans to find suitable terms for their apartments or rental homes. Their service runs on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to schedule appointments when they require support with a new policy or an existing coverage issue.

LD
1646 Corsair Ln #601
Liberty DSI
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Liberty DSI provides renters insurance policies for residents in and around Middleburg, Florida. Its service plans include assisting clients with policy selection, coverage explanation, and claims support. The company focuses on helping tenants protect personal belongings against common risks such as theft or fire damage. It also offers guidance on liability coverage and loss-of-use benefits when needed. Liberty DSI services single-family home rentals, apartments, condominiums, retail spaces, and restaurants throughout the local area.

RI
2361 Blanding Blvd
Roberts Insurance of Middleburg
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

Roberts Insurance of Middleburg specializes in renters insurance policies, covering personal property and liability protection. The agency works with clients throughout Middleburg, Florida, to tailor coverage that meets individual needs for apartments, condominiums, or rental homes. It assists tenants in understanding policy details, including protection against theft, fire, and accidental damage. During the summer hurricane season, Roberts Insurance of Middleburg helps renters ensure their policies provide adequate flood and windstorm coverage, addressing the specific risks faced by residents living in a coastal area.

JL
4213 Co Rd 218
Jenny Lynne & Co
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL

As the summer storm season intensifies in Middleburg, Jenny Lynne & Co helps renters understand how their policies protect belongings from local weather threats and unforeseen accidents. This agency focuses on guiding clients through coverage options that address common household risks and liability concerns distinct to the area. Every rental situation is unique, so the process begins with a thorough walk-through of the property and a discussion of personal inventory to identify specific needs before any policy paperwork is started.

LH
2751 Blanding Blvd Suite 106
Lyndel Hale Agency - Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL
EI
2494 Blanding Blvd #9
Erwin Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL
(904) 282-7212
erwininsurance.com
FB
2000 Henley Rd
Farm Bureau Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middleburg, FL
(904) 282-0644
floridafarmbureau.com

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Middleburg Cost?

In Florida renters insurance typically costs between 15 and 30 dollars per month for 10,000 to 30,000 dollars of personal property coverage. Middleburg rates may be slightly higher due to flood and hurricane exposure. Actual cost depends on your coverage amount deductible and claims history. This is general information not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Middleburg

Renters insurance agents in Middleburg Florida help tenants protect their personal property against theft fire and other covered losses. Florida law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in Clay County now include it as a lease condition. An agent can explain how Florida windstorm and flood risks may affect your policy options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need renters insurance if I live in an apartment in Middleburg?

Florida law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in Middleburg now require it in the lease. Even if not required an agent can help you avoid paying out of pocket for damage to your belongings.

What does a renters insurance agent in Middleburg do?

A renters insurance agent helps you compare policies from different carriers and explains coverage limits deductibles and exclusions. They also assist with filing claims and updating your policy after a move or major purchase.

How quickly can I get renters insurance in Middleburg Florida?

Most agents can issue a renters insurance policy within 24 hours or even the same day. Coverage typically starts as soon as you pay the first premium and sign the application.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.