ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeSupplemental Insurance AgentsIndiana › Michigan City

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Michigan City, IN

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Michigan City, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Michigan City, Indiana is Crowel Agency, Inc., rated 4.8 stars across 500 reviews. Other highly rated options include Freeway Insurance, Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Michigan City.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Michigan City, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Crowel Agency, Inc.348 Dunes Plaza(219) 874-3800
2Freeway Insurance5174 Franklin St(219) 841-8002
3Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent605 Franklin St Suite A(219) 874-6360
4Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent405 Johnson Rd(219) 879-2329
5Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent2103 Franklin St(219) 879-4408
6Douglas Bradley II - State Farm Insurance Agent301 US-20 Suite 8(219) 872-0554
7General Insurance Services421 Franklin St(219) 879-4581
8Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.1905 Franklin St(219) 879-4343
9Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance1812 US-20(219) 879-5357
10Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance450 St John Rd Ste 109(219) 878-1884
CA
348 Dunes Plaza
Crowel Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Crowel Agency, Inc. serves the Michigan City, Indiana area as a supplemental insurance agent. The company assists clients by offering policies that help cover expenses not addressed by primary health insurance. Many local residents seek these plans to manage out-of-pocket costs from medical events. The agency helps individuals and families navigate plan options to find suitable coverage. Supplemental insurance can provide financial support during recovery periods. Crowel Agency, Inc. handles hospital indemnity plans and critical illness coverage in this community.

FI
5174 Franklin St
Freeway Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Freeway Insurance serves the Michigan City, Indiana, area as a supplemental insurance agent. The agency provides policies designed to cover gaps left by primary health or Medicare plans. These plans often include benefits for unexpected medical costs and everyday health needs. A local agent can help residents review their existing coverage and identify where additional protection may be useful. Common services offered through this office include enrollment assistance for accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans to help with out-of-pocket expenses.

NJ
605 Franklin St Suite A
Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Nolan Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Michigan City, IN provides a range of supplemental insurance services that help cover expenses not included by primary health plans. The agency offers support with policy management, including processing claims, answering coverage questions, and adjusting plans as clients' needs change over time. Its service approach focuses on clear communication and ongoing assistance to help policyholders understand their benefits. The agency serves individual homeowners, tenants in apartment complexes, and property owners of retail stores and restaurants throughout the local area.

AM
405 Johnson Rd
Andrew Mitchell - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Andrew Mitchell, a State Farm Insurance Agent in Michigan City, Indiana, serves homeowners, local business owners, and property managers seeking supplemental insurance coverage. The agency provides policies that help fill gaps in primary health, life, or property plans, offering financial protection for unexpected expenses like accidents or critical illnesses. Clients in Michigan City benefit from personalized consultations to identify suitable options for their individual or business needs. The office also extends its services to residents and small businesses in neighboring Long Beach and the surrounding La Porte County area.

CP
2103 Franklin St
Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Connie Patricks - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Michigan City, Indiana, and the surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance policies to cover gaps left by primary health plans. The agency helps clients manage out-of-pocket costs by offering options for accidents, critical illness, and hospital confinement. Each client’s individual needs are assessed to recommend tailored coverage. The company approaches a typical job by first reviewing existing coverage, then explaining specific policy features to ensure the client understands how the supplemental plan would apply in common medical situations.

DB
301 US-20 Suite 8
Douglas Bradley II - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Douglas Bradley II, a supplemental insurance agent in Michigan City, Indiana, helps clients distinguish between one-time policies, such as accident plans, and recurring coverage options like hospital indemnity that pay for each day of a stay. Supplemental insurance is designed to fill gaps left by primary health plans. This local agency offers service on an as-needed basis, allowing policyholders to request assistance when evaluating their coverage or filing a claim.

GI
421 Franklin St
General Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

With winter heating costs pressing many Michigan City households, supplemental insurance can help cover gaps beyond primary health plans. General Insurance Services offers senior-focused policies addressing dental and vision needs while providing prescription drug gap coverage. Residents exploring their options can discuss specific chronic condition coverage or accident protection with an agent who explains benefit limits clearly. The process includes an initial needs review to identify missing or duplicate protections in their existing coverage. A no-obligation inspection of their current policies and income variables determines which supplementary plans may apply.

SI
1905 Franklin St
Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Snyder Insurance Agency, Inc. works with individuals and small businesses in Michigan City, Indiana, to address gaps in standard health coverage. This supplemental insurance agent specializes in offering additional policies that can help cover deductibles, copays, and other out-of-pocket expenses not included in primary plans. The agency focuses on providing clarity for clients seeking to reduce unexpected medical costs. Its services are available to offices, warehouses, and food service operations seeking tailored coverage options for their employees.

RP
1812 US-20
Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Ryan Prendergast: Allstate Insurance in Michigan City, IN offers supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps left by major medical plans, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. It also serves clients with general insurance needs, including auto, home, and life policies. The agency helps local residents manage out-of-pocket costs from deductibles and copays. During open enrollment periods or after a sudden health event, it provides guidance on enrolling in additional coverage to prevent financial strain from unexpected medical expenses.

MC
450 St John Rd Ste 109
Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN

Located in Michigan City, IN, Matt Curtis: Allstate Insurance serves local residents needing supplemental policies to help cover gaps in primary health coverage. For commercial clients, the agency also provides tailored supplemental insurance options for businesses and their employees. Services are available throughout Michigan City and the surrounding communities. After an initial policy is set, the agency proactively follows up to review coverage needs and can help with adjustments, ensuring clients receive ongoing support between their regular scheduled visits.

WA
106 S Woodland Ct Suite #3
Warren Attar - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 210-4293
warrenattar.com
MI
5385 Johnson Rd
Michiana Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 879-6482
michianainsurance.com
IF
5416 Johnson Rd
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0607
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
DI
124 S Woodland Ct # D
Dolson Insurance agency inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 879-4524
dolsoninsuranceagency.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Shula Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/agents/Matt-Shula-LaPorte-MichiganCity-IN
BI
1551 S Woodland Ave
Best Insurance IN
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 232-6841
AT
2004 US-20
Aaron Theophilus Agency Inc. American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 878-9727
amfam.com/agents/indiana/michigan-city/aaron-theophilus
HM
1703 1/2 Franklin St
Health Markets
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 291-4449
healthmarkets.com
IF
107 W Coolspring Ave
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance - Matt Shula Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-0608
infarmbureau.com/offices/shula-agency
1S
3905 Franklin St
1st Source Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Michigan City, IN
(219) 872-1565
1stsource.com/personal/insurance

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Michigan City Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services in Indiana are typically commission-based so you pay no direct fee to the agent. Medigap Plan G premiums in Michigan City range from about $120 to $250 per month depending on age and health. Costs for dental or vision add-ons start around $30 per month. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Michigan City

Supplemental insurance agents in Michigan City Indiana help residents find Medigap plans and other gap coverage. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed by the state Department of Insurance. Local agents understand the specific needs of LaPorte County residents.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Michigan City?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you buy policies that cover costs not paid by Medicare or other primary insurance. They can explain Medigap plans and dental or vision add-ons.

Do I need a supplemental insurance agent in Indiana?

You do not legally need an agent but working with one can simplify comparing plans. Indiana has a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you turn 65.

How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Michigan City?

Look for an agent licensed in Indiana with experience in Medicare supplements. Ask about the carriers they represent and check their standing with the Indiana Department of Insurance.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.