ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in New Albany, IN

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving New Albany, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in New Albany, Indiana is The Insurance Workshop | Medicare Insurance Advisors, rated 5.0 stars across 526 reviews. Other highly rated options include Countryside Insurance Agency Inc, Health Insurance by Design, Russ Thomas Insurance, Inc.. This directory lists 19 supplemental insurance agents serving New Albany.

Showing 19 supplemental insurance agents in New Albany, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1The Insurance Workshop | Medicare Insurance Advisors3837 Charlestown Rd(812) 920-0077
2Countryside Insurance Agency Inc1411 State St(812) 945-9123
3Health Insurance by Design1200 Bell Ln D(812) 948-1581
4Russ Thomas Insurance, Inc.2722 Charlestown Rd(812) 945-5484
5John English - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance379 Professional Ct(812) 944-8439
6Kochert Insurance4206 Charlestown Rd # 120(812) 952-2514
7Jason Kahl Agency LLC American Family Insurance2606 Charlestown Rd(812) 944-7875
8Jeff Schuld Agency, LLC American Family Insurance2606 Charlestown Rd(812) 949-7900
9The Bedrock Group204 Pearl St suite 302(502) 200-1516
10Shepherd Insurance5150 Charlestown Rd Ste 2(812) 949-7444
IW
3837 Charlestown Rd
The Insurance Workshop | Medicare Insurance Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

The Insurance Workshop | Medicare Insurance Advisors serves the New Albany, Indiana, metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. It specializes in helping clients navigate the complexities of Medicare, addressing coverage gaps with tailored plan options. The agency explains how supplement policies work alongside original Medicare to reduce out-of-pocket costs. It also provides guidance for annual enrollment periods, ensuring beneficiaries understand their changing needs. The firm handles prescription drug plan comparisons and Medigap policy selection for local residents.

CI
1411 State St
Countryside Insurance Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

Countryside Insurance Agency Inc in New Albany, IN offers a range of supplemental insurance solutions to fill coverage gaps left by primary health or disability policies. Their services include application assistance and policy reviews to help clients understand their options. They maintain active contact with clients to adjust plans as life circumstances change. The agency extends its services to single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and local restaurants, ensuring property and income protection for both residential and commercial properties.

HI
1200 Bell Ln D
Health Insurance by Design
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

Serving New Albany and the surrounding communities in southern Indiana, Health Insurance by Design handles supplemental insurance needs for individuals and families. The agency focuses on policies that help cover gaps left by major medical plans, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. Each client situation is assessed with a thorough review of existing coverage to identify specific risks. The agency then matches those needs with appropriate insurance options, presenting clear explanations of policy terms to ensure informed decisions.

RT
2722 Charlestown Rd
Russ Thomas Insurance, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

Homeowners, property managers, and business owners can discuss supplemental insurance policies with Russ Thomas Insurance, Inc. Located in New Albany, IN, this agency assists local clients with coverage options that fill gaps in standard health, accident, or property plans. The company provides guidance on supplemental products available throughout the region. It also serves nearby communities such as Jeffersonville and the greater Louisville metro area.

JE
379 Professional Ct
John English - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

John English of Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance in New Albany, IN, offers supplemental insurance with a choice between one-time policies that pay a fixed benefit upon a single qualifying event and recurring coverage that provides ongoing protection for repeated needs like hospital stays or outpatient procedures. These plans help cover gaps left by major medical insurance through benefits for specific conditions or services. Service arrangements are flexible, as clients may receive either scheduled check-ins for policy reviews or as-needed consultations when a covered event arises.

KI
4206 Charlestown Rd # 120
Kochert Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

With the changing seasons in New Albany, many residents start to evaluate their healthcare finances and look for additional coverage beyond major medical plans. Kochert Insurance offers supplemental insurance policies that help with out-of-pocket costs not covered by standard health insurance. These plans provide direct benefits for specific events, supporting local families and individuals when they face unexpected expenses. A common first step involves scheduling a straightforward consultation to review personal coverage needs and determine available options.

JK
2606 Charlestown Rd
Jason Kahl Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

Jason Kahl Agency LLC American Family Insurance in New Albany, IN specializes in offering supplemental insurance agent services that address gaps in standard health coverage, including critical illness, accident, and hospital indemnity plans. It also assists local residents with evaluating their existing policies to identify additional protection needs. As the region experiences unpredictable weather shifting typical seasonal illness patterns, the agency can help clients prepare for unexpected medical expenses arising from storms or suddenly severe flu seasons.

JS
2606 Charlestown Rd
Jeff Schuld Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

Based in New Albany, IN, Jeff Schuld Agency, LLC American Family Insurance serves local homeowners and renters with supplemental coverage. The agency also offers supplemental insurance options for commercial clients to protect their business assets and operations throughout the greater New Albany area. Their policies help fill gaps in standard health or property plans for unexpected medical events or home repairs. Clients can rely on the agency for ongoing policy reviews and follow-up service between their regular visits.

BG
204 Pearl St suite 302
The Bedrock Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN

The Bedrock Group in New Albany, IN, is known for aligning supplemental insurance policies with clients’ existing health coverage. The company assists individuals in selecting plans that help bridge gaps left by primary medical insurance, including benefits for hospital stays, critical illness, and accident recovery. Policy reviews are offered to ensure the coverage adapts to changing healthcare needs over time. A focused specialty that can be added on is a short-term care benefit designed to cover daily assistance during recovery from an injury or illness.

SI
5150 Charlestown Rd Ste 2
Shepherd Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
NI
1316 State St
Norwood Insurance Services new albany
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 945-2321
norwoodinsuranceservices.com
SI
2777 Charlestown Rd
Southern Indiana Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 941-8400
meers.net
CI
205 Bank St
CXE Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 720-3000
cxeinsurance.com
GM
428 Vincennes St
German Mutual Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 949-6117
germanmutualins.com
II
2684 Charlestown Rd
ISU Insurance & Investment Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 948-2272
isunewalbany.com
MI
800 Plaza Dr, 705 Mure De Ronce Dr
Medicare Insurance Ltd.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(930) 217-5812
mathildemcknight03.wixsite.com/medi-insurance-ltd
MI
143 W Market St Suite 2
Magnolia Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(502) 315-1000
insurancemagnolia.com
SL
415 Mt Tabor Rd
Safe Life Insurance Co
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(260) 345-7341
albanyhealthplans.com/contact
BL
3620 Blackiston Blvd Ste 100
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · New Albany, IN
(812) 850-7137
branches.bankerslife.com/in/new-albany/3620-blackiston-blvd

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in New Albany Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in Indiana vary by plan type, age, and health status. For example, a Medicare Supplement Plan G for a 65-year-old in New Albany can range from $120 to $200 per month. Dental or vision supplemental plans may cost $30 to $80 per month. These are estimates only. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in New Albany

Supplemental insurance agents in New Albany, Indiana help residents fill gaps in primary health coverage. These agents can explain options like Medicare Supplement plans, which must follow federal and Indiana state guidelines. Local agents understand the specific needs of Southern Indiana communities and can guide you through enrollment periods and plan choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in New Albany?

A supplemental insurance agent is a licensed professional who helps you buy extra coverage beyond your main health plan. In Indiana, these agents must hold a valid state insurance license and follow Indiana Department of Insurance rules.

When can I enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan in New Albany?

You can enroll during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, which starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. Indiana law guarantees you can buy any Medigap policy during this six-month window without medical underwriting.

Do supplemental insurance agents charge fees in Indiana?

Most supplemental insurance agents in Indiana are paid by commissions from the insurance company. You typically do not pay a separate fee for their services. Always ask about compensation before starting.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.