ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsNew Jersey › Hackettstown

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Hackettstown, NJ

Browse home insurance agents serving Hackettstown, New Jersey. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Hackettstown, New Jersey is Medicare With Adam, rated 5.0 stars across 26 reviews. Other highly rated options include Assurance Innovations, Jim Malay - State Farm Insurance Agent, Plymouth Rock Assurance. This directory lists 13 home insurance agents serving Hackettstown.

Showing 13 home insurance agents in Hackettstown, NJListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Medicare With Adam108 High St(908) 747-1529
2Assurance Innovations2045 NJ-57 STE 7(908) 223-7262
3Jim Malay - State Farm Insurance Agent915 County Rd 517 b21(908) 852-4070
4Plymouth Rock Assurance490 Schooleys Mountain Rd(908) 850-8266
5Mutual Insurance Company NJ2 Autumn Ln(908) 944-9782
6Black River Title & Settlement, LLC486 Schooleys Mountain Rd Bldg 2B(908) 975-3023
7Stuber Insurance Agency115 Mill St(908) 852-4444
8Generazio Associates, Inc. InsuranceLower Level, 108 High St Suite A(973) 429-8101
9Craig Carcuffe - Prudential Financial490 Schooleys Mountain Rd building 3a suite 1(908) 850-8266
10Otterstedt Insurance Agency313 High St #1(908) 852-5555
MW
108 High St
Medicare With Adam
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Medicare With Adam serves homeowners in the Hackettstown, New Jersey area, offering home insurance agent services. The company helps clients obtain policies that protect residential property and personal belongings. It works with individuals to review coverage options and find suitable plans for single-family homes and condominiums. Annual policy reviews are handled to confirm adequate protection against common regional risks. In Hackettstown, it also provides guidance on securing additional coverage for valuable personal items.

AI
2045 NJ-57 STE 7
Assurance Innovations
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Assurance Innovations offers homeowners comprehensive property insurance solutions, including liability coverage and protection against fire, theft, and weather-related damage. It provides annual policy reviews to ensure clients receive adequate coverage as property values change. Standard maintenance plans help customers address common risks like plumbing failures or roof leaks before they escalate. The company serves single-family homes, apartments, retail shops, and locally owned restaurants throughout Hackettstown, New Jersey.

JM
915 County Rd 517 b21
Jim Malay - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Jim Malay - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Hackettstown, New Jersey, and the wider Warren County area, assisting homeowners in nearby communities with protecting their property. This regional home insurance agent handles policies covering dwelling coverage, personal belongings, liability protection, and additional living expenses after a covered loss. For each client’s circumstances, Jim Malay reviews the specific risks common to this region’s older homes and seasonal weather patterns, then customizes a package of coverages that squarely addresses those needs while staying within the client’s budget.

PR
490 Schooleys Mountain Rd
Plymouth Rock Assurance
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Plymouth Rock Assurance serves homeowners seeking reliable property protection in Hackettstown, New Jersey. The agency assists clients in securing coverage for their houses and personal belongings against common regional risks. It also helps local property managers and small business owners find appropriate insurance solutions. Services include policy reviews, risk assessment advice, and claims guidance. Residents of Hackettstown benefit from this local expertise, and the agency extends its coverage assistance to neighboring Washington, New Jersey, as well.

MI
2 Autumn Ln
Mutual Insurance Company NJ
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

A home insurance policy is a long-term service, paid in regular installments, rather than a one-time transaction. Mutual Insurance Company NJ, located in Hackettstown, provides this recurring coverage to protect local homeowners against property damage and liability claims. Their agents help clients choose the appropriate level of protection specific to the area. Service for policyholders is ongoing, with periodic renewals and the option to request assistance whenever needed. This commitment to continuous support ensures coverage can be adjusted on a scheduled or as-needed basis.

BR
486 Schooleys Mountain Rd Bldg 2B
Black River Title & Settlement, LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Black River Title & Settlement, LLC specializes in helping Hackettstown homeowners secure comprehensive coverage for their properties, including protection for both the structure and personal belongings. The agency also provides guidance on liability coverage and additional living expenses, ensuring clients have a thorough policy tailored to their specific needs. As winter approaches, its agents routinely assist with reviewing policies for adequate protection against snow-related damages and frozen pipe claims that frequently occur in this area.

SI
115 Mill St
Stuber Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Homeowners in Hackettstown often face sudden weather shifts that can stress a policy's limits, and Stuber Insurance Agency responds by reviewing coverage details specific to the area's seasonal risks. As a local home insurance agent, the company helps residents compare protection options for property value and personal assets, explaining common exclusions like flood or ice-dam back-up before a claim arises. The process for a new client typically begins with a walk-through inspection of the home's exterior and major systems to support accurate coverage recommendations.

GA
Lower Level, 108 High St Suite A
Generazio Associates, Inc. Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Generazio Associates, Inc. Insurance offers specialized expertise in structuring appropriate homeowners insurance policies, protecting your residence and personal property from covered losses. They also serve clients throughout Hackettstown, New Jersey, by addressing a range of general insurance needs. When autumn storms bring heavy winds and falling branches, they can assist you in reviewing your current coverage to ensure it adequately addresses potential tree damage and related home repairs.

CC
490 Schooleys Mountain Rd building 3a suite 1
Craig Carcuffe - Prudential Financial
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Craig Carcuffe - Prudential Financial provides residential home insurance services for property owners in the Hackettstown area. Commercial coverage policies are also available for local businesses operating in the region. The agency assists clients with assessing dwelling values and selecting appropriate protection plans. Follow-up consultations are offered to review policy changes or address coverage questions between regular seasonal visits.

OI
313 High St #1
Otterstedt Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ

Otterstedt Insurance Agency helps homeowners in Hackettstown, New Jersey find coverage that matches their property and budget. The agency specializes in customized add-ons such as flood, liability, and valuable-item protection. Standard homeowners policies protect against common risks like fire, theft, and weather damage, while optional endorsements fill gaps for high-value possessions or unique structures. Beyond residential work, the agency serves commercial sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments that require tailored business property and general liability insurance.

FF
Hackettstown, NJ 07840
Farm Family Insurance: Hass Mark
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ
(908) 689-8111
americannational.com
LG
1500 County Rd 517 #307
LTC Genie Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ
(800) 422-9443
ltcgenie.com
IC
129 Wingate Dr
Insurance Claims Assistance
Home Insurance Agent · Hackettstown, NJ
(877) 741-4201
icaclaims.org

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Hackettstown Cost?

The average cost of home insurance in New Jersey is around 1,200 to 1,800 dollars per year for a standard policy. Rates in Hackettstown may vary based on your homes age, location, and coverage limits. Older homes or those in flood zones may cost more. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Hackettstown

A home insurance agent in Hackettstown New Jersey can help you find a policy that meets your needs. New Jersey law requires insurers to offer certain coverages like dwelling protection and personal liability. Local agents understand the specific risks for homes in Warren County such as weather damage and fire risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Hackettstown do?

A home insurance agent helps you compare policies from different insurers. They explain coverage options like dwelling, personal property, and liability. They also assist with claims and policy changes.

Is home insurance required in New Jersey?

New Jersey does not legally require home insurance. However mortgage lenders almost always require it. Without insurance you risk financial loss from fire, storm, or theft.

How can I find a home insurance agent in Hackettstown?

You can search online for local independent agents or contact major insurers directly. The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance also provides a list of licensed agents in your area.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.