ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Bay Shore, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Bay Shore, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Bay Shore, New York is Sound Harbor Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 342 reviews. Other highly rated options include Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office, Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance, Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 16 medicare insurance agents serving Bay Shore.

Showing 16 medicare insurance agents in Bay Shore, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Sound Harbor Insurance91 E Main St Suite 3(631) 517-9211
2Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office1656-G 5th Ave(631) 231-3696
3Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance67 E Main St(631) 440-9226
4Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent87 Park Ave(631) 666-8350
5Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent1656 5th Ave A(631) 478-6669
6Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent1805 5th Ave Ste 14(631) 456-4603
7ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.1716 Sunrise Hwy(631) 665-6464
8Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd25 4th Ave(631) 434-6666
9C Walsh Agency28 W Main St(631) 251-6050
10Jay Tee Insurance1655 5th Ave A(631) 231-3200
SH
91 E Main St Suite 3
Sound Harbor Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Sound Harbor Insurance serves the Bay Shore area and the wider Suffolk County region, specializing in Medicare insurance guidance. The company assists individuals navigating their initial enrollment periods and annual plan selections. Its representatives help clients understand the differences between Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage plans. With a focus on matching coverage to individual healthcare needs, the agency provides ongoing support for plan renewals. It specifically handles Part D prescription drug plan comparisons and Medicare Supplement plan options.

FC
1656-G 5th Ave
Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

As a Medicare insurance agent, Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office provides guidance on enrollment, plan selection, and annual review options. It offers ongoing support to help clients evaluate their coverage needs and maintains service plans for plan adjustments throughout the year. The office assists clients in understanding their benefits, handling questions about claims, and facilitating necessary updates. It services individuals residing in single-family homes and apartments, as well as those operating small businesses such as retail stores and restaurants.

AM
67 E Main St
Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Residents and small business owners in Bay Shore, New York, turn to Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance for guidance on their Medicare insurance needs. The office helps clients understand plan options and enroll in appropriate Medicare coverage tailored to individual healthcare requirements. Each consultation focuses on explaining policy details to support informed decision-making during open enrollment periods. The agency provides knowledgeable assistance to individuals navigating the complexities of Medicare plans. Coverage assistance is also extended to homeowners and property managers in nearby Islip and throughout the broader Suffolk County region.

MS
87 Park Ave
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent serves clients in Bay Shore, New York, and the surrounding Long Island communities. The agency handles Medicare insurance plans, helping individuals navigate their coverage options during enrollment periods. It focuses on explaining the differences between Medicare Parts A, B, C, and D, as well as supplemental policies. The general approach it uses begins with a thorough review of each client's current healthcare needs and budget, then compares available plans to identify the most suitable choice for their specific situation.

BD
1656 5th Ave A
Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

For those exploring coverage in Bay Shore, NY, a distinction exists between a one-time enrollment consultation and ongoing support for policy adjustments. Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent assists with Medicare plans, helping individuals understand options that address their healthcare needs. This work involves clarifying benefits and guiding enrollment processes as circumstances change. Service is provided on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to request assistance when reviewing their plan or facing life events that could alter their coverage requirements.

DC
1805 5th Ave Ste 14
Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent in Bay Shore, NY offers personalized guidance on Medicare insurance plans, focusing on helping clients navigate their coverage options. As an insurance agent, Douglas assists individuals with understanding plan details, enrollment processes, and policy changes. The agency provides support for selecting supplement or advantage plans tailored to local medical needs. During the Annual Enrollment Period each fall, Douglas helps clients review and adjust their plans to ensure continued coverage and cost effectiveness.

AI
1716 Sunrise Hwy
ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

As seasonal enrollment periods approach on Long Island, many local seniors seek to adjust their Medicare coverage. ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC. provides guidance through plan options available in the area. Agents help clients compare current policies against new Advantage or supplement plans that may better fit changing health needs or budgets. The process begins with a straightforward inspection of each individual’s existing coverage and medical requirements to determine the most suitable path forward for the coming year. An initial assessment appointment is the first concrete step.

OM
25 4th Ave
Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd assists clients in Bay Shore, New York, with their healthcare coverage needs. The agency specializes in Medicare insurance offerings, helping individuals navigate plan options during enrollment periods and annual changes. They guide clients through the complexities of different Medicare parts and supplemental policies for comprehensive protection. Their services are available to offices, warehouses, and food service establishments in the local area.

CW
28 W Main St
C Walsh Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

C Walsh Agency provides Medicare insurance services to residents of Bay Shore, New York, and the surrounding communities. The agency assists clients with understanding their Medicare options, including plan comparisons and enrollment processes. Commercial coverage is also available for small business owners in the area who need group health insurance solutions. Service extends throughout Suffolk County and nearby Long Island markets. After initial enrollment, the agency schedules follow-up check-ins, ensuring clients can review their coverage again before the next plan year begins.

JT
1655 5th Ave A
Jay Tee Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Jay Tee Insurance in Bay Shore, NY, is known for guiding individuals through Medicare plan comparisons and enrollment. The company helps clients navigate Original Medicare, Supplement plans, and Part D prescription drug coverage options. As a local Medicare insurance agent, it provides explanations of coverage gaps and out-of-pocket costs. Working with the agent involves an assessment of current healthcare needs and preferred providers. An additional service includes annual plan reviews to ensure changing medical requirements are still met by the selected coverage.

UI
214 5th Ave
Universal Insurance Co
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(315) 239-3997
FC
194 N Fehr Way Suite D-3
First Choice Insurance New York
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 729-9572
IP
214 5th Ave
ICR Professional Services Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 224-1955
icrprofessionalservices.com
SI
90 Millpond Ln
SafeCity Insurance Agency NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(917) 310-3567
AI
1784 5th Ave Unit B
Alpine Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 435-0001
JD
1555 Sunrise Hwy #3c
J.D.A. Hurley Inc Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 665-6060
jdahurley.com

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Bay Shore Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in New York typically do not charge a direct fee for their services. They are paid commissions by insurance carriers. Medigap Plan G premiums in Suffolk County can range from $120 to $250 per month depending on age and carrier. Medicare Advantage plans often have $0 monthly premiums but may have copays for doctor visits and hospital stays. Costs vary based on the plan you choose and your health status. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Bay Shore

A Medicare insurance agent in Bay Shore, New York can help you compare Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans. New York state law allows for a guaranteed issue period for Medigap plans when you first enroll in Medicare Part B. Local agents understand the specific network options available in Suffolk County.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in Bay Shore?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. New York also has a special enrollment period for those who lose employer coverage. You can also make changes during the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7.

What types of Medicare plans are available in Bay Shore?

Bay Shore residents can choose Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage plans, and Medigap supplemental plans. New York requires Medigap insurers to offer plans to anyone under 65 who is eligible for Medicare due to disability. Plan options vary by carrier and ZIP code.

How do I find a Medicare insurance agent in Bay Shore?

You can search the New York State Department of Financial Services website for licensed agents. Local agents in Bay Shore often have knowledge of Suffolk County hospitals and doctor networks. You can also ask for referrals from friends or your primary care doctor.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.