ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Buffalo, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Buffalo, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Buffalo, New York is Willoughby Insurance, rated 4.8 stars across 996 reviews. Other highly rated options include Medicare Management of WNY, Sheridan Benefits, Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 31 medicare insurance agents serving Buffalo.

Showing 31 medicare insurance agents in Buffalo, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Willoughby Insurance1523 Main St(716) 885-8100
2Medicare Management of WNY8645 Main St(716) 833-0252
3Sheridan Benefits6700 Main St(716) 580-3773
4Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent615 Elmwood Ave(716) 783-9460
5Jody Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 809-9169
6Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent1335 Hertel Ave(716) 873-3771
7Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 677-2734
8Lawley361 Delaware Ave(716) 849-8618
9Donna Medina at Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 730-4909
10The Decker Agency, Inc.37 Elmwood Ave(716) 883-1455
WI
1523 Main St
Willoughby Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Willoughby Insurance serves the Buffalo, New York metro area as a Medicare insurance agent. It helps local seniors navigate their options during initial enrollment and annual open enrollment periods. The agency assists clients in understanding the differences between Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Advantage options. It also provides guidance on Part D prescription drug plans. By reviewing each individual's healthcare needs and budget, the agency aims to simplify the process of selecting appropriate coverage. It handles plan comparisons and the necessary application paperwork for Medicare Advantage and Part D enrollment.

MM
8645 Main St
Medicare Management of WNY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Medicare Management of WNY provides a full range of Medicare insurance services, including plan comparisons and enrollment assistance for individual clients. The company offers ongoing support and annual plan reviews to help policyholders adapt their coverage as their healthcare needs change. Its agents work with various Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans available in the Buffalo, NY, area. Medicare Management of WNY services individual properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants.

SB
6700 Main St
Sheridan Benefits
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Homeowners and individuals in Buffalo, New York who need guidance on Medicare plans can turn to Sheridan Benefits for help. This Medicare insurance agency assists clients in understanding and comparing coverage options for their healthcare needs. Emphasizing personalized service, they work to find suitable policies from available carriers. Sheridan Benefits also serves clients in the nearby Niagara Falls area, ensuring accessibility for those seeking dependable advice in Western New York.

DS
615 Elmwood Ave
Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Serving Buffalo and surrounding communities in Western New York, Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent handles Medicare insurance options for local residents. The agency assists clients with understanding their coverage choices and enrollment periods. It offers guidance on plan selection, including prescription drug and supplemental policies. The approach involves reviewing individual health needs, explaining plan differences in plain language, and helping clients gather necessary documentation to facilitate a smooth application process.

JL
400 Essjay Rd #300
Jody Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Jody Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency in Buffalo, NY specializes in Medicare insurance plans, offering guidance on initial enrollment and annual plan changes. It serves local seniors seeking clarification on coverage options and cost considerations. The agency assists with understanding plan differences and navigating paperwork. As the fall Medicare Open Enrollment period approaches, it helps clients evaluate their current coverage against new plan options to ensure they enroll before the December 7th deadline.

DH
1335 Hertel Ave
Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

As open enrollment season approaches in Buffalo, many residents seek clear guidance on their Medicare options. Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent offers straightforward consultations to help individuals evaluate plans that suit their healthcare needs and budget. The team explains coverage differences, including Part D prescription drug plans and Medicare Advantage choices, in easy-to-understand terms. A licensed agent begins each new client relationship by reviewing their current coverage and upcoming medical needs during a no-obligation initial assessment.

CI
400 Essjay Rd #300
Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

For those exploring coverage for the first time or adjusting existing plans, Comparion Insurance Agency in Buffalo, NY offers guidance on both one-time enrollment decisions and ongoing plan management. Their work focuses on helping clients understand Part D prescription drug coverage as well as Medicare Advantage and Medigap options. A licensed insurance agent reviews individual healthcare needs and explains local plan choices available in the Buffalo area. Service runs on a one-time basis for initial consultations, though clients may schedule follow-up appointments as needed during annual enrollment periods.

LA
361 Delaware Ave
Lawley
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Lawley helps individuals in Buffalo, New York navigate their Medicare options by explaining plan features and enrollment periods. The agency focuses specifically on Medicare insurance, including original Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans. It works with clients to review prescription drug coverage and out-of-pocket costs for their specific healthcare needs. Lawley can assist with coverage for medical offices, distribution warehouses, and food service establishments seeking employee or owner benefits.

DM
400 Essjay Rd #300
Donna Medina at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Donna Medina at Comparion Insurance Agency assists residents of Buffalo, New York, with their Medicare insurance needs. The agency also provides coverage options for commercial clients within the local area. Serving the greater Buffalo region, the office helps individuals navigate Medicare plan selections, including supplements and drug coverage. They focus on clearly explaining available choices to clients. Follow-up assistance is available between regular annual visits to address any changes in coverage needs or new plan questions.

DA
37 Elmwood Ave
The Decker Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
WI
726 Exchange St Ste 200
Walsh Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 853-3820
walshins.com
FS
16 Lake Ave
Father Son & Associates LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 823-1801
fsains.com
TD
1439 Main St
Toni DuBois Agency, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 931-5200
toniduboisagency.com
HI
2333 Elmwood Ave
Hoch Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 881-1975
hochinsuranceagency.com
VI
1459 Kensington Ave
VitalGuard Insurance, New York
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 577-9159
CG
354 Cayuga Rd
The Cesar Group Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 626-0066
thecesargroup.com
UH
205 Park Club Ln
Univera Healthcare
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 847-1480
univerahealthcare.com
EI
2190-2220 Wehrle Dr
Extrem Insurance Agency NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 577-9067
NY
8200 Main St
New York Insurance Agencies
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(347) 305-5413
WH
47 Court St
WellCare Health Plan
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 846-7900
wellcare.com
IH
511 Farber Lakes Dr
Independent Health
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 631-3001
independenthealth.com
HI
3960 Harlem Rd #12
Harrington Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 333-0030
harringtoninsuranceagency.com
AI
1798 Main Rd
Able Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 883-5212
HB
1 Seneca St floor 34
Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New York
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(844) 639-2441
bcbswny.com
CI
432 Amherst St
Cannizzaro Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 235-8882
cannizzaroinsurance.com
UI
90 Bryant Woods S
United Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 632-6118
WC
3625 Seneca St
William Coppola Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 675-9403
WI
2477 Union Rd
Wny Insurance Agency Llc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 771-0012
GH
2333 Elmwood Ave
Gary Hoch Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 881-1975
TP
1207 Delaware Ave
Thoughtful Plan - Medicare Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 379-3562
thoughtfulins.com/contact-us
NG
400 Essjay Rd #300
Nichole Goodman at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 730-4904
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/northeast-region/nichole-goodman

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Buffalo Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in New York typically do not charge you a fee for their services. Instead, they receive commissions from insurance companies when you enroll in a plan. These commissions are built into the plan premiums, so you pay the same price whether you use an agent or not. For Medicare Advantage plans, monthly premiums in Buffalo can range from $0 to over $100, depending on the plan and your location. Medigap plans in New York have standardized pricing, with monthly costs often between $100 and $300 for a 65-year-old. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Buffalo

Medicare insurance agents in Buffalo, New York help residents navigate Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D drug plans. These agents are licensed by the New York State Department of Financial Services and must follow state regulations on plan marketing and enrollment. Buffalo agents can explain how New York-specific rules, like the annual open enrollment period from October 15 to December 7, affect your choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Buffalo do?

A Medicare insurance agent in Buffalo helps you compare Medicare plans, enroll in coverage, and understand your options. They are licensed in New York and can assist with Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans. Agents do not charge you directly; they are paid by insurance companies.

Do I need a Medicare insurance agent in New York?

You are not required to use an agent, but many people find it helpful. New York has a guaranteed issue rule for Medigap plans, meaning you can enroll in a Medigap policy outside of open enrollment without medical underwriting. An agent can explain this rule and help you choose a plan that fits your needs.

How do I find a licensed Medicare agent in Buffalo?

You can search for licensed agents on the New York State Department of Financial Services website. Look for agents who specialize in Medicare and have a valid license in New York. Local senior centers or the Buffalo Area Agency on Aging can also provide referrals.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.