ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Santa Fe, NM

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Santa Fe, New Mexico. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Santa Fe, New Mexico is Orale Insurance Agency, rated 4.9 stars across 465 reviews. Other highly rated options include Melissa Sandoval: Allstate Insurance, Stephen Gillespie - State Farm Home & Auto Insurance Agent, Quezada Jacobs Family Agency, LLC: Allstate Insurance. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Santa Fe.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Santa Fe, NMListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Orale Insurance Agency1251 S St Francis Dr # 2(505) 819-0225
2Melissa Sandoval: Allstate Insurance3454 Zafarano Dr Ste A-1(505) 820-1442
3Stephen Gillespie - State Farm Home & Auto Insurance Agent510 N Guadalupe St suite k(505) 982-3604
4Quezada Jacobs Family Agency, LLC: Allstate Insurance1547 S St Francis Dr(505) 557-2067
5Farmers Insurance - Mariana Archuleta3201 Zafarano Dr Suite E(505) 913-0912
6Farmers Insurance - Lloyd Nichols1301 S St Francis Dr ste b(505) 983-2805
7George Gandy Insurance1730 Cerrillos Rd(505) 983-8406
8Silas T Garcia Agency & Associates LLC811 St Michaels Dr Suite 101(505) 982-9863
9Agape Insurance Services1301 S St Francis Dr Ste D(505) 930-5638
10Blue Fox Insurance Agency LLC1301 S St Francis Dr Ste D(505) 933-6486
OI
1251 S St Francis Dr # 2
Orale Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Orale Insurance Agency serves the Santa Fe, New Mexico metro area, offering supplemental insurance policies that fill gaps left by primary health coverage. These plans help local residents manage out-of-pocket expenses such as deductibles and copayments for medical services. The agency provides coverage for accidents, hospital stays, and critical illnesses. Its professionals guide clients through plan options to address unexpected healthcare costs. Specific services it handles include accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans.

MS
3454 Zafarano Dr Ste A-1
Melissa Sandoval: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Melissa Sandoval: Allstate Insurance provides supplemental insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The agency focuses on offering products that help cover gaps in primary health or property coverage, such as accident or hospital indemnity plans. Services include policy explanations, enrollment assistance, and ongoing support for claims and plan adjustments. The agency serves a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

SG
510 N Guadalupe St suite k
Stephen Gillespie - State Farm Home & Auto Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Serving Santa Fe and the surrounding communities of northern New Mexico, this agency works as a supplemental insurance agent, offering policies that help fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans. It handles specialized plans for accidents, critical illness, and hospital indemnity, as well as home and auto insurance through State Farm. Its typical approach involves a personal consultation to assess an individual’s existing coverage and financial situation. It then recommends specific supplemental plans to tailor protection against unexpected out-of-pocket costs.

QJ
1547 S St Francis Dr
Quezada Jacobs Family Agency, LLC: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Homeowners, renters, and individual policyholders in Santa Fe, New Mexico turn to Quezada Jacobs Family Agency, LLC: Allstate Insurance for supplemental insurance agent services. This agency helps clients fill gaps in existing coverage with additional policies that provide further financial protection against unexpected expenses. Services are tailored to address common local needs, including accident and critical illness plans. By working with major insurers, they offer options to strengthen standard homeowners or health plans. The agency also serves the surrounding communities of Eldorado and the greater Santa Fe metropolitan area.

FI
3201 Zafarano Dr Suite E
Farmers Insurance - Mariana Archuleta
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Farmers Insurance - Mariana Archuleta in Santa Fe, NM, differs from agents offering one-time transactions by providing ongoing policy management, including annual reviews to adjust supplemental coverage as needs change. The agency focuses on Medicare supplements, accident, and critical illness plans to bridge gaps in primary health insurance. Clients benefit from local consultation and claim assistance for these recurring, flexible policies. Service runs on an as-needed or scheduled basis, allowing policyholders to request support or set regular check-ins throughout the year.

FI
1301 S St Francis Dr ste b
Farmers Insurance - Lloyd Nichols
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Farmers Insurance - Lloyd Nichols in Santa Fe, NM provides supplemental insurance policies that cover gaps left by major medical plans, including accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity options. The agency also offers general services such as reviewing existing coverage and explaining how supplemental plans integrate with primary insurance. During the winter months, residents often seek help with policies that protect against unexpected medical costs from slips or cold-related illnesses that Medicare or standard plans may not fully cover.

GG
1730 Cerrillos Rd
George Gandy Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

George Gandy Insurance serves residents of Santa Fe, New Mexico, and surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance policies that help cover expenses left by major medical plans. By working with various carriers, it offers clients options for gap coverage, including plans for hospital stays, accidents, or critical illnesses. To complete a typical job, the agent reviews each client’s existing coverage and personal needs, then presents clear plan comparisons to help them choose a suitable supplemental policy.

ST
811 St Michaels Dr Suite 101
Silas T Garcia Agency & Associates LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

As the summer monsoon season approaches in Santa Fe, residents often review their coverage against unexpected storm damage or health episodes. Silas T Garcia Agency & Associates LLC serves as a supplemental insurance agent, helping clients close gaps in their primary health or Medicare plans. Policies available may assist with out-of-pocket costs, hospital stays, or accident-related expenses common in an active outdoor community. The initial step is a free review of existing coverages to identify specific gaps and provide a tailored plan comparison.

AI
1301 S St Francis Dr Ste D
Agape Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Agape Insurance Services works with individuals to identify gaps left by their primary health coverage. The company focuses on supplemental insurance add-ons that help cover expenses not addressed by major medical plans. Residents and business operators in Santa Fe often use such policies for accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity benefits. By closing gaps in coverage, these plans provide additional financial protection during unexpected health events. Agape Insurance Services can serve local commercial sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

BF
1301 S St Francis Dr Ste D
Blue Fox Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM

Blue Fox Insurance Agency LLC in Santa Fe provides supplemental insurance services to residential clients in the local area. The agency also arranges supplemental coverage for commercial customers throughout Santa Fe and the surrounding region. These policies help fill gaps left by standard health or life plans, offering additional financial protection for everyday medical or income needs. The company continues serving clients by handling policy adjustments and questions between regular visits, ensuring coverage remains suited to changing circumstances.

JH
1570 Pacheco St STE C3
James H Russell Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 983-7357
progressiveagent.com/agents/new-mexico/santa-fe/james-h-russell-agency-inc
FI
522 W Cordova Rd
Finest Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 552-4946
ludivinabraz921363.wixsite.com/finest-insurance-age
DI
805 St Michaels Dr
Daniels Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 982-4302
danielsinsuranceinc.com
IN
150 Washington Ave Suite 201
Insurance New Mexico
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 717-3479
insurancenewmexico.net
ZI
810 Calle Mejia Ste 106
Zia Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 983-7329
RG
1231 S St Francis Dr Building A Suite A
Rio Grande Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 984-8216
riograndeins.com
HI
2905 Rodeo Park Dr E Building 6, Suite 100
HUB International
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 982-4296
hubinternational.com/offices/us/new-mexico/santa-fe
BB
2074 5th St
BlueCross BlueShield Santa Fe, NMC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 365-0160
santafehealthplans.com/contact
SF
3624 B Mimbres Ln
Santa Fe Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 424-3792
santafeinsurancegroup.com
OI
2019 Galisteo St STE C2
Ortega Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Santa Fe, NM
(505) 982-2526
ortegains.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Santa Fe Cost?

Typical costs for a Medigap plan in Santa Fe range from about 100 to 300 dollars per month depending on your age, gender, and the plan letter you choose. Some insurers use attained-age pricing while others use issue-age pricing, which can affect long-term premiums. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Santa Fe

Supplemental insurance agents in Santa Fe, New Mexico help residents choose Medigap or other gap coverage to fill the gaps in Original Medicare. New Mexico law requires that Medigap policies be guaranteed issue during the six-month open enrollment period starting when you turn 65. Agents can explain how state regulations affect your plan choices and premiums.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Santa Fe?

A supplemental insurance agent in Santa Fe helps you compare and enroll in Medigap plans or other gap coverage. They are licensed in New Mexico and can explain how local costs and rules apply to your situation.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in New Mexico?

You have a six-month open enrollment period that starts the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time, insurers cannot deny you coverage or charge higher premiums based on health conditions.

Are Medigap plans standardized in New Mexico?

Yes, Medigap plans are standardized by the federal government and labeled A through N. New Mexico does not have additional state-specific plan types, but agents can help you compare the same plan letters from different insurers.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New Mexico Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.