ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Columbus, OH

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Columbus, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio is Matic Insurance Services, rated 4.8 stars across 2,528 reviews. Other highly rated options include Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent, Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio, HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible. This directory lists 28 supplemental insurance agents serving Columbus.

Showing 28 supplemental insurance agents in Columbus, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Matic Insurance Services585 S Front St #300(888) 380-6623
2Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent2140 Riverside Dr ste b(614) 485-9077
3Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102(614) 475-3583
4HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible38 Dillmont Dr(440) 503-5248
5Andrea Taylor - State Farm Insurance Agent5540 N Hamilton Rd(614) 855-9421
6Solid Insurance986 Morse Rd(614) 854-0000
7Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent2510 Billingsley Rd(614) 698-0028
8Isner Insurance Associates, Inc3695 N High St(614) 236-8691
9Sokol Eisenberg Insurance1620 E Broad St #103(614) 362-4262
10Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.3806 N High St(614) 326-0200
MI
585 S Front St #300
Matic Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Matic Insurance Services serves the Columbus, Ohio metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. It assists local clients with policies that fill gaps in primary health coverage, such as those for accidents or critical illnesses. These plans provide cash benefits directly to policyholders for specific medical events. The agency helps residents evaluate options like hospital indemnity or fixed-benefit accident insurance that can offset deductibles or lost wages.

KR
2140 Riverside Dr ste b
Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH, offers a range of supplemental insurance services, including policies designed to cover gaps left by major medical plans, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. The agency provides ongoing support for policyholders, assisting with claims and helping clients adjust their coverage as their needs change over time. It services a variety of properties and residents, including single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants.

AH
4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102
Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Homeowners, small businesses, and property managers in Columbus, Ohio turn to Slyman Insurance Group Ohio to address gaps in their existing coverage. As a supplemental insurance agent, this company offers policies that fill deductibles and exclusions left by standard homeowners and commercial plans. Clients obtain additional protection for personal property, liability, and business income interruptions. The agency also serves clients throughout the broader Franklin County metro area, including communities such as Dublin and Worthington.

HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

HealthMarkets Insurance - Chris Weible in Columbus, OH provides both one-time and recurring service options, which distinguishes short-term coverage from ongoing policy adjustments. This supplemental insurance agency assists clients with plans designed to fill gaps in primary health coverage. Services typically include evaluating individual needs, comparing policy options, and handling enrollment paperwork. For ongoing management, policy reviews occur on a scheduled basis. Additional as-needed support is available when life changes, such as a new job or family event, require immediate coverage updates.

AT
5540 N Hamilton Rd
Andrea Taylor - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Andrea Taylor - State Farm Insurance Agent specializes in supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps left by major medical plans. The agency serves clients throughout Columbus, Ohio, offering personalized assistance to help individuals and families find affordable options for dental, vision, accident, and critical illness coverage. Their general work includes explaining policy details, processing enrollments, and customizing plans to fit different budgets and health needs. As winter approaches, they also help with short-term disability policies that protect income when seasonal illnesses or injuries force someone to miss work.

SI
986 Morse Rd
Solid Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Solid Insurance serves the Columbus, Ohio area and its surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance policies that fill gaps left by major medical plans. It focuses on providing coverage for expenses such as deductibles, co-pays, and critical illness events not fully addressed by standard health insurance. The agency works with clients to identify protections that suit their individual financial needs and health situations. A typical engagement begins with a thorough review of an existing policy and then compares relevant supplemental options to find a suitable balance of cost and coverage.

PL
2510 Billingsley Rd
Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

As winter arrives in Columbus, local families often review their coverage for unexpected medical gaps. Pam Lewis-Kidder - State Farm Insurance Agent specializes in supplemental insurance policies that help cover those added costs. This agency assists residents in navigating plans designed to complement primary health insurance during seasonal illnesses or routine accidents. Each consultation begins with a thorough review of an individual’s current coverage. The initial step involves a complementary needs assessment to identify potential gaps and recommend suitable supplement options.

II
3695 N High St
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. serves the Columbus area as a supplemental insurance agent. These policies help individuals fill coverage gaps not paid by primary health plans, often including disability and critical illness protection. The company’s specialty add-ons include accident and hospital indemnity plans to offset out-of-pocket costs. This work assists local businesses with employee benefit packages, supporting both workforce financial security and employer retention efforts across commercial sectors such as offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

SE
1620 E Broad St #103
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Sokol Eisenberg Insurance serves residents of Columbus, Ohio, by helping them evaluate supplemental insurance options to cover gaps in their primary health plans. The agency also assists local businesses in selecting commercial supplemental coverage that addresses the specific needs of their employees. Their service area focuses on the greater Columbus metropolitan region, ensuring clients can access in-person consultations. After an initial enrollment, the agency schedules follow-up reviews to adjust policies as circumstances change, offering ongoing support between routine visits.

HI
3806 N High St
Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Horizon Insurance Services, Inc. in Columbus, OH is known for helping individuals secure supplemental insurance to cover gaps left by primary health plans. It assists clients in selecting affordable policies for accidents, critical illness, and hospital indemnity. The firm guides customers through plan options, explaining how these products provide direct cash benefits for out-of-pocket expenses. A specialty add-on service includes offering tailored dental and vision coverage to complete a protection package.

DC
1080 Fishinger Rd
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 486-5400
coonfareinsurance.com
GI
1500 W 3rd Ave #300F
Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 915-0977
grandviewinsuranceservice.com
HI
4450 Kenny Rd
HealthMarkets Insurance - Kelly Parton
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(380) 444-5248
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/kparton
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Nanda Madadi
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 967-8500
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/nmadadi
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Phil Schopick - Call for a free consultation and virtual appointment
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 783-0381
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/pschopick
AW
3040 Riverside Dr #201
The Al Washington Ins Agy Ltd
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 564-9156
alwashingtoninsurance.com
CI
1201 Dublin Rd #151
CK Insurance Group, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 695-3330
ck-ins.com
MI
1275 Demorest Rd
Matson Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 274-1444
matsonagency.com
HA
240 Collins Ave UNIT 2
Hyers & Associates Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(888) 901-5650
ohioinsureplan.com
HI
38 Dillmont Dr
HealthMarkets Insurance - Mike Gatteri
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 568-1324
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mikegatteri
RI
1580 Fishinger Rd
Ray Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 459-1122
rayinsurance.com
HI
4766 N High St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Robert Crouch
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 324-2642
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/rcrouch
SG
4449 Easton Way 2nd floor
Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 665-9801
sylviaagarrettagency.com
MM
200 E Campus View Blvd STE 200
My Medicare Ohio
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(888) 644-6180
mymedicareohio.com
WE
29 Frederick St
W.E. Davis Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 443-0533
wedavis.com
SI
120 Mill St
Schneider Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 471-8444
schneiderins.com
HI
38 Dillmont Dr Suite B8/B9
HealthMarkets Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 785-9405
agents.healthmarkets.com/Columbus
AA
5250 Bethel-Reed Pk
Above All Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 588-7840

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Columbus Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Ohio vary by plan type age and insurer. Medicare Supplement Plan G premiums for a 65-year-old in Columbus typically range from 120 to 200 dollars per month. Medicare Advantage plans often have lower monthly premiums sometimes 0 dollars but may include copays. Costs for hospital indemnity or accident policies depend on benefit levels. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Columbus

Supplemental insurance agents in Columbus Ohio help residents choose policies that cover costs not paid by primary health insurance such as deductibles and copays. Ohio law requires Medicare Supplement plans to be guaranteed renewable and standardized as Plans A through N. Agents can also explain Ohio-specific rules like the six-month open enrollment period for Medigap when you first turn 65.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a supplemental insurance agent in Columbus do?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you compare and enroll in policies like Medicare Supplement plans or hospital indemnity insurance. They explain coverage options and costs so you can fill gaps in your existing health plan.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Ohio?

In Ohio you have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting.

Are there Ohio-specific rules for supplemental insurance?

Yes Ohio follows federal Medicare guidelines but also requires that Medigap policies be standardized and renewable. Ohio does not allow agents to charge a fee for helping you enroll in a Medicare plan.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.