ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeSupplemental Insurance AgentsOhio › Grove City

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Grove City, OH

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Grove City, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Grove City, Ohio is Joshua Haskins - GEICO Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 365 reviews. Other highly rated options include Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC, Mitchell Insurance Agency, HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader. This directory lists 15 supplemental insurance agents serving Grove City.

Showing 15 supplemental insurance agents in Grove City, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Joshua Haskins - GEICO Insurance Agent1730 Stringtown Rd(614) 689-8140
2Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC4213 Hoover Rd(614) 259-5000
3Mitchell Insurance Agency2204 Stringtown Rd(614) 875-1770
4HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader3826 Broadway(614) 277-8440
5Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC1596 Stringtown Rd(614) 277-3650
6Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle3897 Grove City Rd B(614) 277-8916
7Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency4200 Hoover Rd Suite A(614) 871-9707
8Western & Southern Life1953 Ohio Dr(614) 277-4800
9Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency3907 Broadway(614) 871-1200
10Chuck Auber Insurance LLC3011 Columbus St #202(614) 991-5184
JH
1730 Stringtown Rd
Joshua Haskins - GEICO Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Joshua Haskins - GEICO Insurance Agent serves the Grove City area and surrounding Franklin County communities. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company helps clients obtain policies that cover gaps left by major medical plans. Agents work with individuals to understand their needs and find appropriate coverage options. Specific services include accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans, which provide direct cash benefits for unexpected health events and medical visits.

SI
4213 Hoover Rd
Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC in Grove City, OH provides a range of supplemental insurance solutions designed to cover gaps not addressed by major medical plans. The agency manages ongoing service and maintenance of clients’ voluntary policies, ensuring coverage remains aligned with changing needs. It focuses on bridging deductibles, co-pays, and other out-of-pocket costs through accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The firm serves single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and local restaurants throughout the region.

MI
2204 Stringtown Rd
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency provides supplemental insurance services to individuals and businesses in Grove City, Ohio. It offers coverage options designed to fill gaps left by primary health or life policies, including plans for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity. The agency assists clients with selecting appropriate supplemental plans and provides ongoing support for policy maintenance and claims inquiries. Its services are available to residents of single-family homes, apartments, and commercial property owners managing retail stores and restaurants.

HI
3826 Broadway
HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Serving Grove City homeowners and families, HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader provides supplemental insurance agent services that help bridge coverage gaps not addressed by major medical plans. The agency offers policies designed to assist with out-of-pocket costs, such as deductibles and copays, for local residents seeking extra financial protection during medical events. Appointments are tailored to individual needs, ensuring each client understands available options for their situation. The agent also covers neighboring communities throughout the greater Columbus metro area.

NI
1596 Stringtown Rd
Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC serves Grove City, Ohio, and the surrounding Columbus-area communities. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company handles products designed to cover gaps left by major medical plans, including policies for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity. It works with individuals and local families to review their existing coverage and identify potential financial exposures from unexpected health events. For a typical job, the agent meets with clients to explain plan options and completes a needs-based comparison of available benefits.

SI
3897 Grove City Rd B
Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle in Grove City, Ohio provides supplemental insurance agents who address the difference between a single life event and recurring income protection. Their coverage options help bridge gaps left by primary health plans, offering financial support for unexpected medical or personal expenses. Service is provided strictly on an as-needed basis, allowing policyholders to request assistance when specific circumstances arise after enrollment.

LG
4200 Hoover Rd Suite A
Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency serves homeowners, small businesses, and property managers in the Grove City, Ohio area. It assists clients with supplemental insurance coverage that fills gaps left by standard policies, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The agency provides support tailored to local needs, helping customers secure additional protection for unexpected medical or property-related expenses. Its services also extend to the Columbus metropolitan region, including communities such as Hilliard.

WS
1953 Ohio Dr
Western & Southern Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Western & Southern Life in Grove City, Ohio provides specialized supplemental insurance policies to cover gaps not addressed by primary health plans, offering critical illness, accident, and hospital indemnity coverage. It assists local residents with individualized policy selections to safeguard household finances against unexpected medical costs. Many families rely on this agency for additional protection during peak illness seasons like late fall or winter cold and flu outbreaks.

MP
3907 Broadway
Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

As winter approaches in Grove City, many residents review their coverage to guard against unexpected medical expenses. Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency assists local clients in navigating supplemental insurance options designed to fill gaps left by primary health plans. Their conversations focus on individual circumstances, such as potential out-of-pocket costs or income loss from illness or injury. The agency works with area carriers to present policy choices that match each household’s needs and budget. An initial assessment of the client’s current policies and financial goals begins the process.

CA
3011 Columbus St #202
Chuck Auber Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
EA
3821 Broadway B
Emily Allen American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 871-8729
amfam.com/agents/ohio/grove-city/emily-allen
BE
3848 Broadway
Bennett ~ Edgar Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 871-3200
bennettedgarins.com
FI
3886 Broadway
Farmers Insurance - Nickolas Perini
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 875-1907
agents.farmers.com/oh/grove-city/nickolas-perini
VI
3136 Broadway #103
Village Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 875-3010
viaoh.com
FS
3907 Broadway
Fry's Equine Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 875-3711
frysequineinsurance.com/contact-us

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Grove City Cost?

Medigap premiums in Ohio vary by plan type, age, gender, and tobacco use. Monthly costs for Plan G in Grove City typically range from 120 to 200 dollars. Plan N may cost 90 to 150 dollars per month. Rates can increase each year. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Grove City

Supplemental insurance agents in Grove City Ohio help residents choose Medigap or Medicare Supplement plans that fill gaps in Original Medicare. Ohio law guarantees a six-month open enrollment period for Medigap when you first turn 65. Local agents can explain plan options like Plan G or Plan N and compare rates from multiple carriers serving Franklin County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Grove City Ohio?

A supplemental insurance agent is a licensed professional who helps you buy Medicare Supplement or Medigap policies. They work with multiple insurance companies to find a plan that fits your budget and health needs.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Ohio?

Ohio law gives you a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage or charged more due to health conditions.

Do supplemental insurance agents charge fees in Ohio?

Most supplemental insurance agents are paid by the insurance company through commissions. You typically do not pay a separate fee to the agent. Always ask about compensation before working with an agent.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.