ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsNew York › Garden City

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Garden City, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Garden City, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Garden City, New York is ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company, rated 3.8 stars across 625 reviews. Other highly rated options include Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent, Simon Agency, Schulman Insurance. This directory lists 20 medicare insurance agents serving Garden City.

Showing 20 medicare insurance agents in Garden City, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company1225 Franklin Ave #475(800) 365-4999
2Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent1100 Stewart Ave Ste 3(516) 302-4457
3Simon Agency900 Stewart Ave #230(516) 593-2700
4Schulman Insurance825 E Gate Blvd Suite 320(516) 632-5225
5Trustworthy Insurance LLC625 Chestnut St(516) 421-6804
6International Benefits Administrators67 Clinton Rd(878) 222-4410
7Acrisure Garden City, NY (Whitmore Group Ltd.)370 Old Country Rd(516) 746-4141
8Clancy & Clancy, a Division of RMS Insurance Brokerage, LLC100 Ring Rd W #210(516) 746-2155
9HealthCare Partners, IPA501 Franklin Ave(516) 746-2200
10Nationwide Insurance: Lopinto Insurance Agency Ltd.100 Garden City Plaza Ste 412(516) 873-3200
SL
1225 Franklin Ave #475
ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company serves the Nassau County area from its Garden City, New York base. As a medicare insurance agent, it assists clients in navigating the various parts of Medicare coverage. The company helps individuals understand the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. It also provides guidance on selecting supplemental coverage options. Specifically, ShelterPoint handles Medigap policy enrollment and Part D prescription drug plan selections for residents in this region.

SM
1100 Stewart Ave Ste 3
Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent in Garden City, NY, provides Medicare insurance guidance, helping local seniors navigate plan options and enrollments. The agency also assists with policy reviews and annual updates to ensure coverage aligns with changing health needs. By explaining the differences between Medicare parts and supplemental plans, it supports clients in making informed decisions. Services cater to individuals residing in single-family homes, apartments, retail environments, and restaurants throughout the Garden City area.

SA
900 Stewart Ave #230
Simon Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

Residents of Garden City and surrounding Nassau County find assistance navigating Medicare options through Simon Agency, a local insurance agent focused on individual healthcare coverage needs. The agent helps clients compare Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans to align with their specific medical and budgetary requirements. Services include annual plan reviews and support during enrollment periods. Serving both new and existing Medicare beneficiaries, the agency also provides guidance for clients living in nearby communities such as Hempstead and the broader Long Island metropolitan area.

SI
825 E Gate Blvd Suite 320
Schulman Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

Schulman Insurance in Garden City, NY, distinguishes between annual enrollment periods for new plans and ongoing support for claims and billing questions. Their coverage guidance focuses on Medicare Advantage, supplemental plans, and Part D drug options that meet local healthcare needs. Clients receive assistance navigating federal program rules and comparing plan benefits each year. Services are offered on a scheduled basis, with appointments available year-round for plan reviews and as-needed support during the annual enrollment window.

TI
625 Chestnut St
Trustworthy Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

Trustworthy Insurance LLC in Garden City, NY, works with individuals to navigate their Medicare coverage options, including plan comparisons and enrollment assistance. It specializes in Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans tailored to each client’s healthcare needs. The agent focuses on explaining plan benefits and costs during the annual enrollment periods. Its services are available for local commercial sectors that may require employee benefits guidance, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

IB
67 Clinton Rd
International Benefits Administrators
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

International Benefits Administrators serves Garden City and the surrounding Nassau County communities, offering local guidance on Medicare insurance options. The agency handles Medicare Supplement plans, Medicare Advantage policies, and Part D prescription drug coverage for eligible residents. It focuses on comparing plan details and benefits to help clients understand their choices within the annual enrollment periods. For a typical job, the agent reviews individual healthcare needs and current coverage, then presents suitable plan options from multiple carriers to assist in making an informed decision.

AG
370 Old Country Rd
Acrisure Garden City, NY (Whitmore Group Ltd.)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

As the annual Medicare enrollment period brings a surge of questions about plan options and cost changes, Acrisure Garden City, NY (Whitmore Group Ltd.) helps local beneficiaries navigate those decisions. The agency reviews each client’s current coverage against their anticipated medical needs and prescription drug usage. Their Medicare insurance agents work in the Nassau County area to identify suitable plan structures and network considerations. Every consultation begins with a straightforward assessment of the individual’s healthcare priorities before matching them to potential plans for the upcoming year.

CC
100 Ring Rd W #210
Clancy & Clancy, a Division of RMS Insurance Brokerage, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
HP
501 Franklin Ave
HealthCare Partners, IPA
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY

HealthCare Partners, IPA in Garden City, NY, assists clients with navigating Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans, offering personalized guidance to match individual health needs and budgets. The agency explains complex enrollment rules and plan differences clearly, helping seniors choose coverage for doctors and hospitals in the local network. It specifically assists with Annual Enrollment Period decisions, ensuring clients adjust their plans to meet changing medical needs or prescription costs before the December deadline.

NI
100 Garden City Plaza Ste 412
Nationwide Insurance: Lopinto Insurance Agency Ltd.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
AG
501 Franklin Ave
Acrisure Garden City, NY (Signature B&B)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 823-3100
acrisure.com
VA
1225 Franklin Ave RM 325
The Viking Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 496-7711
vikingagency.com
CI
950 Franklin Ave Suite 100
Contractors Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(800) 649-9094
contractorsinsurance.org
BB
600 Old Country Rd #302
Blue Block Brokerage, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 440-2200
blueblockinc.com
CA
100 Ring Rd W Suite 200
Club Agency Insurance Brokerage
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(866) 784-9785
clubagency.com
VW
300 Garden City Plaza
Vital Well Insurance NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(646) 439-6558
SI
1205 Franklin Ave 340 3rd Floor
Stratford Insurance Agency, LLC.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 489-7129
stratfordagency.com
PR
600 Old Country Rd #235
Platinum Resources
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 222-4942
platinuminsurance.com
WS
900 Stewart Ave Ste 600
Wright Specialty Insurance Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(877) 976-2111
wrightspecialty.com
JI
1225 Franklin Ave RM 325
JLS Insurance Solutions
Medicare Insurance Agent · Garden City, NY
(516) 750-2077
jlsinsurancesolutions.com/HOME

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Garden City Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Garden City do not charge you directly for their services. However, Medicare plan costs vary by carrier and plan type. For example, Medicare Supplement Plan G in New York can range from $150 to $300 per month depending on age and location. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero premiums but include copays and deductibles. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Garden City

A Medicare insurance agent in Garden City, New York can help you navigate plan choices and enrollment rules. New York has specific guaranteed issue rights and a continuous open enrollment period for Medigap plans. Local agents understand the needs of Nassau County residents and can explain how state laws affect your coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Medicare Initial Enrollment Period in New York?

The Initial Enrollment Period lasts seven months, starting three months before your 65th birthday month and ending three months after. In New York, you can also enroll in a Medigap plan during this time without medical underwriting.

Can I change Medicare plans outside of the Annual Enrollment Period in New York?

Yes, New York has a continuous open enrollment period for Medicare Supplement plans. You can switch Medigap plans at any time without health questions, but you must meet eligibility rules for Medicare Advantage changes.

Do Medicare agents in Garden City charge a fee for their services?

No, licensed Medicare insurance agents in New York are typically compensated by insurance carriers, not by clients. Their services are free to you, and they must disclose any compensation they receive.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.