ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Rochester, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Rochester, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Rochester, New York is VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 437 reviews. Other highly rated options include Elmwood Agency, Jackie Ortiz - State Farm Insurance Agent, Quinton Insurance. This directory lists 55 medicare insurance agents serving Rochester.

Showing 55 medicare insurance agents in Rochester, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC1577 W Ridge Rd Suite 216(585) 663-2004
2Elmwood Agency1 Reserve View Blvd(585) 548-4500
3Jackie Ortiz - State Farm Insurance Agent225 Alexander St(585) 325-1960
4Quinton Insurance2700 Elmwood Ave(585) 244-9004
5Freeway Insurance1363 Long Pond Rd(585) 225-2560
6FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY448 Titus Ave(585) 678-8008
7Insurance Marketplace Agency150 Allens Creek Rd Suite 220(585) 482-9980
8InsuranceTrak Services4515 Culver Rd # 206(585) 282-0934
9Lifetime Financial Group, LLC35 State St(585) 325-2525
10Farmers Insurance - Miriam Rivera1038 Lyell Ave(585) 360-0094
VI
1577 W Ridge Rd Suite 216
VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Residents of Rochester, New York, who are eligible for Medicare are the clients served by VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC. This agency helps individuals navigate Medicare plan options, including supplements and prescription drug coverage. It provides personalized guidance to ensure clients make informed decisions about their healthcare benefits. Local Medicare rules and enrollment periods are reviewed during consultations. The agency’s Medicare insurance services also extend to individuals living in the neighboring community of Greece, ensuring broader coverage across the greater Rochester metro area.

EA
1 Reserve View Blvd
Elmwood Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Elmwood Agency serves Rochester, New York, and the surrounding Monroe County area as a Medicare Insurance Agent. The company assists individuals with navigating their Medicare options during initial enrollment and annual open enrollment periods. It provides guidance on comparing Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Supplement policies to find suitable coverage. The agency also helps beneficiaries understand Part D prescription drug plans available in the region. Elmwood Agency specifically handles plan comparisons for Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement insurance in the Rochester area.

JO
225 Alexander St
Jackie Ortiz - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Serving Rochester, New York, and the surrounding Monroe County communities, Jackie Ortiz - State Farm Insurance Agent provides Medicare insurance guidance and plan options for eligible individuals. The agency handles the complexity of Medicare enrollment, including understanding different parts and supplemental coverage choices. For each client, it begins with a thorough review of individual healthcare needs and preferences before presenting available plan details. This personal assessment allows the agency to tailor its recommendations by carefully comparing options to find the most suitable fit for each situation.

QI
2700 Elmwood Ave
Quinton Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Quinton Insurance provides Medicare insurance consultation and enrollment services to residents of Rochester, New York. Its representatives assist clients with understanding plan options, managing annual enrollment periods, and coordinating benefits with existing coverage. The agency also offers ongoing support for policy adjustments and claims questions. It serves individuals planning for retirement healthcare needs, those transitioning from employer coverage to Medicare, and seniors reviewing their current plans. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, and small retail businesses in the Rochester area.

FI
1363 Long Pond Rd
Freeway Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Freeway Insurance serves individuals and families in Rochester, New York, who are exploring Medicare coverage options. It assists clients in navigating the complexities of Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and prescription drug plans. The agency helps customers compare plans to find suitable coverage. Medicare Insurance Agents work to simplify enrollment and annual change periods. This office also provides guidance to those in the surrounding Monroe County communities, such as Irondequoit, ensuring accessible service across the broader Rochester metropolitan area.

FM
448 Titus Ave
FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY specializes in Medicare insurance plans, including Advantage and Supplement options, serving clients throughout the Rochester, New York area. It assists individuals in navigating plan enrollment, coverage details, and annual changes to benefits. The agency helps seniors understand their options during the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period each fall, ensuring they can adjust their coverage to meet evolving health needs and budgets without interruption.

IM
150 Allens Creek Rd Suite 220
Insurance Marketplace Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Insurance Marketplace Agency assists individuals in Rochester, New York, with navigating their health coverage choices. The firm specializes in Medicare insurance options, including supplemental plans and prescription drug coverage. Its agents explain how different policies work and help clients find suitable plans for their medical needs and budgets. The agency serves a varied clientele, including those who work in area offices, warehouses, and food service establishments. Clients can schedule appointments to review their coverage and compare annual plan changes.

IS
4515 Culver Rd # 206
InsuranceTrak Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
LF
35 State St
Lifetime Financial Group, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
FI
1038 Lyell Ave
Farmers Insurance - Miriam Rivera
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Farmers Insurance - Miriam Rivera provides Medicare insurance agent services to residents in Rochester, New York, and the surrounding area. Commercial coverage options are also available for local businesses seeking appropriate plans. The agency assists clients with understanding their Medicare choices, including supplement and advantage plans tailored to individual needs. Appointments are conducted to clarify enrollment periods and coordinate plan details. Ongoing support between annual visits ensures clients remain informed of policy updates and can adjust their coverage as their healthcare requirements change.

CB
400 White Spruce Blvd suite c
Century Benefits Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 224-8138
centurybenefitsgroup.com
RG
1100 Long Pond Rd Suite 100
Rochester Group Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 794-5640
rochestergroupinc.com
VA
849 Paul Rd Ste 220
Vail Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 889-4650
vail-insurance.com
CW
558 Elmgrove Rd
Cara Welling - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 625-5888
carafromsf.com
PI
1815 S Clinton Ave Building 400 Suite 435
Paradigm Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 623-1550
paradigmnyinsurance.com/index.html#hero
TK
3221 Chili Ave
Tom Kernan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 889-3210
tomkernan.com
AG
2589 W Ridge Rd
AAA - Greece
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 227-9600
westerncentralny.aaa.com/locations/greece
BA
333 Metro Park Suite S202
The Belmont Agency Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 571-7006
belmontagencyllc.com
MI
1619 East Ridge Road
Mazzola Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 266-7130
mazzolainsurance.org
GL
2199 E Henrietta Rd #1
George Larry - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 334-0150
georgelarry.com
MP
530 Titus Ave
M-Power Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 678-8844
m-poweragency.com
CB
70 Linden Oaks #300
Clear Benefits Advisors | Medicare EASY!
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 299-2199
clearbenefitsadvisors.com
CE
900 Jefferson Rd
Century Enrollment & Benefit Services, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 507-9517
centuryadvisory.com
EB
1946 W Ridge Rd Suite B
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield Resource Center (Greece)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 225-0221
excellusbcbs.com/contact/visit-us
CB
3093 West Ridge Road Rt 104 W Roch New York Greece
A Christina Breen-Hale - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 225-8480
breen-hale.com
CA
1819 East Ridge Road
Consolidated Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 467-4110
consolidatedagencyinc.com
BR
4072 W Henrietta Rd
Beth Rogers Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 321-0015
bethrogersagency.com
EO
2450 W Ridge Rd Suite 307
Empire One Insurance Consultants
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 433-0000
empireoneinsuranceconsultants.com
AB
2800 Dewey Ave
Ahrens Benefits Company
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 601-5000
ahrensbenefitsco.com
ML
1225 Jefferson Rd Suite A03
Maust and Leone
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-7979
maustandleone.com
SG
3445 Winton Pl #109
The Schultz Group of NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 424-1780
schultzgroupofny.com
SS
306 John St
Super Senior Services Incorporated
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 802-2635
superseniorservices.com
BI
69 Empire Blvd
Bobby Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 288-2741
MJ
120 Corporate Woods
Marks Jerome M Agency LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 475-0220
marksagency.com
OS
1400 Portland Ave Ste. 24
ortolani services inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 242-9749
ortservices.com
TG
4124 W Henrietta Rd
Tom Gervais - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 359-4280
tomgervaisagency.com
BM
2284 Culver Rd
Bill M Davis Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 266-4500
wmatdavis.com
FI
550 Latona Rd Bldg D-422
Farmers Insurance - Thomas Stefanini
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 467-8733
agents.farmers.com/ny/rochester/thomas-stefanini
PI
3255 Brighton Henrietta Town Line Rd
Pinnacle Insurance Agency Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 235-6070
pinnacleinsurance.net
VM
782 Elmgrove Rd
Vanza McEntee Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 429-7606
vanzamcenteeagency.com
YM
1225 Jefferson Rd Suite A03
Your Medicare Solutions Advisor
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-7979
PI
1230 - 1260 Lyell Ave
Private Insurance NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 902-2563
NI
1567 E Henrietta Rd
National Income Life - Durhon Oldham & Brett Gryska
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 292-9610
agency.nilife.com/oldham-gryska
EI
120 Corporate Woods #150
Erie Insurance: Rochester Office
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 214-5800
erieinsurance.com/contact-erie/locations/rochester
LR
2000 S Winton Rd
Lawley ROC Insurance Services, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 413-0483
rocinsuranceservices.com
SI
25 Franklin St
Smart Insurance Rochester
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 326-0571
MA
1225 Jefferson Rd Suite A01
Maust Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-7979
maustandleone.com
UI
1400 St Paul St
Unique Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 283-0191
NM
The Legend Group, 1425 Jefferson Rd
NY Medicare Specialists
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 568-2273
nymedicarespecialists.com
MR
511 Beahan Rd Suite B
Miriam Rivera Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 206-2497
agents.farmers.com/ny/rochester/8713999-miriam-rivera
HH
Buckman's Plaza, 2590 W Ridge Rd Suite 10
Heart and Home Health
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 340-7181
lenadeluca.com
YM
2024 W Henrietta Rd Bldg 2A
Your Medicare Advisers
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 354-1915
GA
1777 English Rd # 1
Greece Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 723-1200
MM
2808 Dewey Ave
The Medicare Marketplace
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 601-5000
themedicaremarketplace.com
LS
1880 East Ridge Road
Leading Senior Benefit
Medicare Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(888) 545-0417

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Rochester Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in New York do not charge consumers for their services. Their compensation comes from insurance carriers as commissions. Plan costs vary widely: Medicare Advantage plans in Rochester may have $0 monthly premiums while Medigap plans typically range from $100 to $300 per month depending on age and plan type. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Rochester

A Medicare insurance agent in Rochester New York can help you compare Medicare Advantage Medigap and Part D plans. New York state law allows you to switch Medicare Advantage plans during certain special enrollment periods. Local agents understand the specific network options available in Monroe County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Rochester do?

A Medicare insurance agent in Rochester helps you review plan options and enroll in Medicare Advantage Medigap or Part D plans. They are licensed in New York and can explain plan costs and coverage details. Agents do not charge you directly because they are paid by insurance carriers.

When can I enroll in a Medicare plan in New York?

In New York the Initial Enrollment Period lasts seven months around your 65th birthday. The Annual Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7 each year. New York also has a unique Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31 each year.

Do I need a separate Medigap plan in New York?

Medigap plans in New York are guaranteed issue year-round if you are 65 or older. This means you can buy a Medigap policy at any time without medical underwriting. However Medigap does not cover prescription drugs so you may need a separate Part D plan.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.