ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Shirley, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Shirley, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Shirley, New York is MD365 - Shirley, rated 4.6 stars across 1,045 reviews. Other highly rated options include Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.), Lighthouse Insurance Shirley, Marlin Insurance Agency Inc. This directory lists 10 medicare insurance agents serving Shirley.

Showing 10 medicare insurance agents in Shirley, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1MD365 - Shirley800 Montauk Hwy #8(631) 772-4646
2Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.)878 Montauk Hwy(631) 395-1000
3Lighthouse Insurance Shirley960-B Montauk Hwy(631) 399-0300
4Marlin Insurance Agency Inc1138 William Floyd Pkwy(631) 281-6200
5Essential Insurance New York2 Coraci Blvd(332) 378-1898
6Long Island Medicare Planning18 Dawn Dr(631) 345-2300
7Esquire Agency396 William Floyd Pkwy 2nd Floor(631) 873-3825
8Affinity Health Plan60 Northern Blvd(631) 772-1868
9Insurance Trust501 William Floyd Pkwy(631) 395-1700
10Shirley Mastic Insurance Agency18 Ryerson Ave(631) 399-1000
MS
800 Montauk Hwy #8
MD365 - Shirley
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

MD365 serves clients in the Shirley, New York area, functioning as a local medicare insurance agent. This company helps individuals navigate the complex landscape of Medicare coverage options. Their work primarily involves explaining the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans to beneficiaries. They also guide clients through enrollment periods and necessary paperwork. The company specializes in reviewing existing prescription drug coverage needs. Specifically, they assist local residents with finding suitable Part D drug plans and coordinating benefits with Medigap supplemental policies for comprehensive healthcare access.

IW
878 Montauk Hwy
Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.)
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Island Wide Insurance Agency, located in Shirley, NY and formerly known as Stop Agency, Inc., offers Medicare insurance agent services for individuals navigating their healthcare coverage options. The agency assists clients with plan selection, enrollment, and annual review of existing policies to ensure continued suitability. Regular maintenance includes updates on changing plan benefits and cost adjustments. Its service properties include single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

LI
960-B Montauk Hwy
Lighthouse Insurance Shirley
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Serving homeowners and local residents in the Shirley, New York area, Lighthouse Insurance Shirley assists individuals with their Medicare insurance needs. As a local Medicare insurance agent, the company helps clients navigate plan options, enrollments, and annual changes to find suitable coverage for healthcare services. Its services include comparing Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans tailored to each person's situation. The agency also extends its assistance to clients throughout the surrounding parts of Suffolk County, including the neighboring community of Mastic Beach.

MI
1138 William Floyd Pkwy
Marlin Insurance Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Marlin Insurance Agency Inc serves clients in Shirley, New York, and the surrounding Suffolk County communities. As a Medicare insurance agent, the company handles enrollments for Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. It also helps beneficiaries navigate annual enrollment periods and understand their coverage options. To manage a typical job, the agency begins by reviewing an individual's current health needs and budget, then explains plan differences clearly. It finishes by presenting a selection of policies tailored to that person's specific situation.

EI
2 Coraci Blvd
Essential Insurance New York
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Essential Insurance New York specializes in Medicare plan comparisons and enrollment assistance for beneficiaries in Shirley and the surrounding area. The agency provides guidance on selecting suitable coverage options, including Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans. It helps clients navigate the annual enrollment period each fall, clarifies the options during the Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment window, and advises on special enrollment periods triggered by life changes like retirement or relocation.

LI
18 Dawn Dr
Long Island Medicare Planning
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Long Island Medicare Planning, located in Shirley, New York, clarifies the difference between the one-time initial enrollment process and the ongoing service options available for annual plan reviews. They help clients understand Part A and Part B hospital and medical coverage, alongside the Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans that supplement Original Medicare. Coverage guidance is structured specifically for eligible residents across Suffolk County. Service runs on an as-needed, scheduled, or one-time basis depending on the client's request for an appointment throughout the year.

EA
396 William Floyd Pkwy 2nd Floor
Esquire Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

For Shirley residents sorting through their annual Medicare options, Esquire Agency offers targeted guidance as a local medicare insurance agent. They help clarify the differences between original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. The agent reviews each client’s current coverage to identify possible gaps in prescription drugs or preventative care. An initial in-person or phone assessment is scheduled to evaluate individual health needs and budget constraints before recommending any policy change.

AH
60 Northern Blvd
Affinity Health Plan
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Affinity Health Plan operates as a local Medicare insurance agent in Shirley, NY, assisting individuals with navigating their healthcare coverage options. The company focuses on helping clients select appropriate Medicare Advantage plans, prescription drug plans, and Medigap policies to suit their individual needs and budgets. By offering personalized guidance through the enrollment process, the agency ensures that area seniors understand their available choices and benefits. Its services can also serve commercial sectors with offices, warehouses, and food service operations needing employee benefit guidance.

IT
501 William Floyd Pkwy
Insurance Trust
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Insurance Trust serves residential clients in Shirley and surrounding areas with guidance on Medicare insurance options, helping individuals understand their coverage needs. The agency also assists commercial clients with group plans and works with businesses requiring employee benefit solutions. Serving all of Shirley and its nearby localities, the team provides personalized appointments to explain plan details clearly. They ensure customers can request follow-up support or schedule repeat consultations between regular plan visits to address any coverage changes or questions.

SM
18 Ryerson Ave
Shirley Mastic Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Shirley, NY

Shirley Mastic Insurance Agency is a Medicare insurance agent in Shirley, New York, recognized for assisting individuals with their healthcare coverage needs. The company helps clients navigate Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare Supplement plans, and Part D prescription drug plans. They guide beneficiaries through the annual enrollment period and special enrollment periods with clear explanations. A specialty service this agency offers is helping clients compare stand-alone prescription drug plans to find the most suitable cost-saving options for their medications.

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Shirley Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in New York generally do not charge clients directly; they receive commissions from insurance companies. Plan costs vary: Medicare Part B has a standard premium of $174.70 per month in 2024 for most beneficiaries. Medicare Advantage plans in Suffolk County may have $0 premiums but can include deductibles and copays. Medigap plans range from about $100 to $300 per month depending on age and plan type. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Shirley

A Medicare insurance agent in Shirley, New York can help you navigate Medicare Part A, Part B, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans. New York law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict rules about plan comparisons and enrollment periods. Shirley residents often seek local agents familiar with Suffolk County healthcare providers and networks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Medicare Open Enrollment Period in New York?

The Medicare Open Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7 each year. During this time you can switch Medicare Advantage or Part D plans. New York also has a separate Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31.

Can a Medicare insurance agent help with Medigap plans in Shirley?

Yes, agents can help you compare Medigap plans A through N. In New York, you have a guaranteed issue right to buy a Medigap policy for 63 days after your Medicare Part B effective date. After that, medical underwriting may apply.

Do Medicare agents in New York charge fees for their services?

Most Medicare insurance agents in New York are paid by insurance carriers through commissions. They typically do not charge you a direct fee. Always confirm the payment arrangement before working with an agent.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.